The ghost of Spain’s DS2 rides again, as we always knew it would, post-bankruptcy and being acquired by Marvell, in the form of real silicon for G.hn, the three way ‘no new wires’ technology aiming for a foothold in home networks.
John Egan, Manager, Strategic Marketing and Standards at Marvell Semiconductor, and ex of DS2 talked to us this week about a chip that which could make all the difference in the survival of the G.hn standard.
‘We have silicon now and offer a full design package with it, and we are currently distributing evaluation kits and two reference designs, one for an embedded chip and another for a wall adapter,’ promised Egan.
All around the show at IBC, technology rivals were claiming that the G.hn plugfest held in Geneva in May, featured no interoperability testing between real chips. We know that Sigma had silicon and so did Lantiq, and Marvell openly admits that it turned up with an FPGA, as did Taiwan’s Metanoia. But HomeGrid very specifically pointed out that it was an event for G.hn silicon test platforms, not final silicon.
The HomeGrid, the G.hn fan club, has since announced not only the additions of three new testing events, which will culminate in December with the testing of final silicon for commercial release, but also the addition of Xingtera, a recently added member, to the list of silicon producers, which is also expected to deliver silicon at that point, and a new Israeli member TangoTec.
The specific events are scheduled for a week in October, one in November, and a comprehensive two-week test event in December. This is unusual for a new home network connectivity technology ‘ usually it is dominated by a single silicon vendor such as Intellon in HomePlug and Entropic in MoCA, until volumes are assured.
This is starting to look like G.hn has some measure of momentum, and devices are expected to be out in Q1 2012.
Egan said that Marvell has put DS2 into its Connectivity group which handles its GPON, Ethernet, WiFi, Powerline, BlueTooth and Zigbee chips. ‘The May interop was just about the PHY layer. The October event is being held by Telefonica, a company that already has RFP’s out which mention G.hn.
‘We acquired all of the R&D staff of Spain’s DS2 and its IP, and it already has firmware for its UPA powerline, version 5.0 of Spirit. We shall shortly have out version 6.0 which supports G.hn.’ The implication is that Marvell may have taken longer to be sure that its G.hn chips were ready, but that’s because it has the head start of the all the work which DS2 did in UPA, the version of powerline backed by the Universal Powerline Association, of which DS2 was a prominent member. This is why DS2 was so quick to support G.hn and was such an early aggressive cheerleader for it.
‘It already had TR069 written on cross platform firmware and the UPA system used CSMA with token passing in its 200 Mbps product line. That has needed some tweaks to handle TDMA, but we have kept all the good things that UPA could do,’ said Egan.
Essentially Marvell inherits some traffic analysis algorithms which automatically test the nature of the communication between G.hn nodes, to see if it is a bulk delivery of a movie or some back and forth negotiation between two points. Token passing, like some early pre-Ethernet networks, is a way of handing control back and forth quickly so that short messages go faster.
Marvell has even accommodated the new 3 wire MIMO system which Sigma Designs has built into its version of G,hn which it calls ClearPath. The ITU has just got through adding it to the standards stack and although Atheros has insisted that this was retrofitted to make a poor technology look modern, it immediately went and copied the idea in its latest lines of products.
‘We are adding MIMO to the chip and it will be turned on with a successive release of the Spirit firmware,’ said Egan. ‘Two years ago AT&T put out an RFP for a set top to be installed during 2012, which had to have G.hn and we think the industry is still on track for that,’ Egan added.
But given a world where there will be an initial 5 players offering silicon, Marvell has tried to add some tweaks that give it a bit of a head start against its partners/rivals in G.hn. And when you look at some of its customers, such as Sony which uses Marvell WiFi chips in its PlayStation 3, you can see how its strategy of suggesting that G.hn becomes the home’s backbone, with WiFi hanging off it, could lead to some impressive design wins among existing customers alone. What if a PlayStation came with an optional G.hn plug, for instance?
‘Some of our Fiber to the Home customers offer 150 Mbps bi-directional services, but that means that within the home the network has to cope with the 150 Mbps that is arriving new, as well as movement around the home, for instance from a DVR. In WiFi we have some 4 x 4 MIMO chips doing beamforming, and that’s 150 Mbps theoretical maximum per stream (so 600 Mbps), so a backbone has to be up around the 1 Gbps to carry all the WiFi and fresh broadband signals arriving at the home.’
However most power technologies such as HomePlug focus on the lowest speed power outlet, usually citing 20 Mbps to 25 Mbps. When we talked to Sigma it was suggesting 65 Mbps at most power outlets for its G.hn chip and 200 Mbps at 75% of outlets. ‘Our goal on G.hn over power is to offer 100 Mbps at 98% of power outlets,’ Egan said.
One area where Marvell hope to distinguish itself from rivals is among Multi-Dwelling Units (MDUs). This turns out to be an area that MoCA has also worked on (see separate story this week). ‘DS2 had already delivered a UPA system which could distinguish between different apartments on the same network, using OFDM orthogonal pre-ambles to identify the different networks. This allows the system to differentiate two homes on the same power line,’ said Egan
‘This is the number 1 or 2 requirement on every senior provider’s RFP right now in Europe, because 50% of the population lives in MDUs.’
Egan adds to the differentiators the company’s smart repeater algorithms, and IGMP snooping. Multicast video packets are delivered using the Internet Group Management Protocol, and this means the chip can snoop an IPTV packet and give it priority. And of course any UPA networks out there (not that there are many) can co-exist with the Marvell G.hn chip.
Egan talks about the company having plans, down the road to look at a low cost version of the chip for energy management, and says that outlandish ideas such as a single chip solution for both MoCA and G.hn could emerge.
‘There’s no development of that idea that I have specifically seen, but the way MoCA 2 has been designed, with the same FEC and some other similarities, if someone came up to us and said we could make money by building such a chip, it wouldn’t be impossible. We’re not religious in that way, making money is what Marvell does.’
The subject of the 1905.1 efforts to create an abstraction layer so that a variety of home networking types can interoperate is a thorny one at Marvell which claims it was the number one contributor to the papers that went into the 1905.1, points out Egan, but of course the relevant IEEE committee voted not to allow G.hn into the fold, positioning it as a step too far, and a set of devices not yet delivered.
Another feather in the cap of the Marvell Connectivity group this week was a deal it cut with China’s ZTE, which said it will manufacture a variety of Ethernet Passive Optical Network products for China based on Marvell’s Avanta family of processors. The agreement comes just a year after entering into a strategic cooperation relationship around fiber-to-the-x and follows field trials with China Telecom.