Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

12 July 2018

MediaKind – dumb name, won’t be with us for long

The new name and working brand for the Ericsson Media Solutions division which got spun out back in February is MediaKind. We will try ourselves to be kind, but it’s tough after years of mismanagement, failure to complete, and playing second fiddle to its mobile business – there is little good that we can say. We have requested an interview, but since we were specifically not invited to the launch, it is unlikely we will receive one.

The nicest thing we can say is that many of the new management team are new to us, which may mean that lots of old-timers have stayed with Ericsson or retired and a new batch of in-house managers have come through. They cannot do worse than the last lot.

CEO. Angel Ruiz, is a 22 year man in Ericsson, Gowton Achaibar, COO & Head of R&D has been there 16 years and along with Arun Bhikshesvaran, CMO, it looks like they buddied up in the years they spent together at Ericsson India. Bhikshesvaran. Mark Russell, CTO is a Mediaroom import, and given that in development terms Mediaroom sat still for about 7 years, that does not sit well. The rest of the management team is in sales.

Most of the team seems to be based in the US, and no-one from Azuki is anywhere near the top. They have all long gone, but they used to get things done. This is corporate, staid and conservative at a time when what a media solutions business needs is to be imaginative, innovative, think outside the box, and it needs to be a master of social media.

To us this deal to sell off 51% is to take it off the books of Ericsson (to One Equity Partners) to satisfy its current Ericsson investors, but in readiness to be re-acquired by Ericsson at some future point when it has its costs under control. The word Ericsson appeared in the release far too often for its to be interpreted any other way, although if Ericsson cannot make it back on top in cellular, MediaKind may be left to wither on the vine.

Here’s a sentence and a half from the launch, “MediaKind is set to drive next-generation live and on-demand, mobile and multi-screen media experiences, and be the industry’s leading independent media technology company.” That’s a laudable aim, but to do that it needs to have a product line that focusses on bringing TV experience to phones. It certainly has a Cloud DVR product – but it will need a lot more.

The first think we can remember Ericsson doing in media was creating the Open IPTV Forum in 2007. It came at a time when it had no IPTV customers and promised to bring standardization to IPTV. At this time IPTV was a world controlled by Alcatel and Microsoft. Another member of that group was AT&T, and despite Ericsson’s protestations, all of the Mediaroom technology at AT&T has since been surrounded with code from Quickplay Media, which it acquired, is delivered over the Akamai CDN (not Ericsson’s UDN), it uses Freewheel for advertising decisioning (owned by Comcast), and encoding is partly supplied by Envivio prior to Ericsson buying that company.

At IBC 2015 Ericsson said it had been selected for the integration of AT&T’s DirectTV and U-verse platforms – but then again you would expect a CMS you owned to need some of your help for integration. There is no feeling here that AT&T has done much more than give it a contract for support of its antique core video architecture.

In fact the secret to what MediaKind really is may well be found in a 2016 release about Ericsson working with Tata Sky with its Compression Portfolio. For this read the chip which came out of its Aspex (UK) acquisition which set about creating its own compression ASIC, which we are told by Ericsson is used by several hundred operators worldwide. Our own service Rethink TV, which lists technology stacks for each of the top 100 operators, show that perhaps 5 admit to using this for encoding. Pretty much all encoding that has been set up in the past 5 years is software only on a COTs server.

Ericsson also says it has provided video compression in DTH for 4 out of the 7 DTH operators in India. Let’s just take that a bit further – the big two are going to be the merger of Dish and Videocon d2h and Tata Sky and anyone it decides to merge with (there are a few candidates) – as far as we can see only one of Dish and Videocon ever had a MediaKind product as their front line encoder – but they don’t use it for DTH and certainly not for 4K content. There are a few MPEG2 encoders provided by MediaKind but the bulk of encoding for Dish is Harmonic, while for Videocon it was Envivio. Post-merger there is no decision on a forward strategy.

Tata Sky uses Elemental for its core encoding and specifically for its 4K encoding, start-up V-Nova provides encoding for some aspects of Multi-screen – there is no MediaKind relationship we can uncover. Tata does use the Ericsson media delivery network (now UDN) – but that business remains with Ericsson.

Reliance Jio has a relationship with Ericsson, but not as far as we can see with MediaKind. It offers a cheap smartphone and cellular service, with 300 TV channels, boasts people watching TV on their phone using 11 GB or 12 GB per month in video data, and it plans to disrupt the DTH market in India too. Its sister company Reliance used Ericsson for mobile, and a deal was cut to allow Jio to buy its assets, while Ericsson had it over a barrel in bankruptcy proceedings. Under such conditions deals are sometimes struck for equipment, but it is not one of the top 7 DTH players, although give it a year and it might be. Jio is famous for disrupting the Indian MNO market with 100 million new customers in under a year.

The market leader in terms of satellite customers is the free to air service DD Free Dish, and perhaps MediaKind has a relationship here, but this is a poorer cousin of the top DTH players – and it buys on price, not quality.

At the press conference there were other claims made – that MediaKind has 900 customers, 350 of which are broadcasters and also counts as its customers 9 of the top 10 global telecommunications companies, 9 of the top 10 cable companies; 9 of the top 10 satellite operators, 8 of the top 10 broadcast/media companies. Quite frankly we do not believe these numbers.

Comcast replaced Envivio encoders with Elemental encoding many years ago, but it will still have the odd encoder lying around; Sky has never used Ericsson for encoding, it uses Elemental and has some Cisco for some purposes. It doesn’t even use Ericsson UDN and instead uses Nokia CDNs. DirecTV may well be using Ericsson for some CMS consolidation, and it did use Envivio for OTT encoding, but fundamentally it is not an Ericsson house. It uses Harmonic for broadcast encoding.

Our point is this – the team does itself a disservice claiming the high ground and saying it is already the biggest and the best, when that’s really not true. The broadcast business Red Bee remains with Ericsson, so most of the broadcasters should not count as MediaKind customers; and many operators use Ericsson for their cellular infrastructure, but you cannot give credit to MediaKind for this, as it’s no longer meant to be part of Ericsson and should stand on its own.

Given that Tandberg TV, Envivio and Aspex were all about encoding and part of the Azuki portfolio also supplied this – there is a lot of inherited broadcast and pay TV business in here, none of it the current cutting edge.

In essence we would suggest that MediaKind’s revenue streams are at present mostly maintenance and support revenues, captive revenues and not at the cutting edge. So to characterize the company as innovative with a special management team, which has spent $3 billion on R&D over the past 11 years (which is only $300 million a year). The main thrust seems to be that MediaKind is going to sell its way out of trouble – we would suggest that first and foremost it needs a serious strategy rethink.

Encoding is shifting to transcoding and that’s happening in the cloud and falling in value per encode. Currently it has the wrong weapons, Envivio which is not cloud based and an ASIC; all the money in OTT video is in UI enablement like voice and also in centralized management systems, starting with billing and working out towards Service Management platforms and storefronts. MediaKind has none of these, although Ericsson has a fine BSS/OSS platform.

MediaKind claims to have targeted dynamic ad insertion – but we don’t know anyone who uses this at present. The company needs a programmatic advertising engine, an addressable advertising engine for its broadcast customers, but the Red Bee metadata business has remained with Ericsson, so it does not have the advantage of working with deep metadata, except through partnership with Ericsson. Most rivals are using AI to extract deeper metadata anyway.

MediaFirst also needs to leverage ABR multicast of some description to drive down costs of video delivery for its MNO customers. Video is moving to the phone, and any innovation that it can bring to support this would be appreciated. This is an area where MediaKind could indeed be first – but don’t hold your breath. It once preached MBMS for video and ten years on has little to show for it.

Angel Ruiz, CEO, MediaKind, said, “We understand the power of media and how it is evolving. It runs in our DNA and it’s our passion. With our pioneering heritage and strong foundations fueled by deep innovation, we have a single goal in mind: to enable our customers to create and deliver immersive media experiences. We are uniquely positioned to help shape and lead the future of global media technology. Our award-winning technologies and established industry heritage and forward-thinking experts equip organizations with the end-to-end technology solutions needed to embrace media of all kinds.”

Mr Ruiz we respectfully disagree at present but would love to be proved wrong. It’s easy to say we don’t like the name and make fun of a failing organization and we should not do it, but the chances are that MediaFirst is too like Mediaroom and MediaFirst and probably this business is not designed to be on its own for long, and either it will re-merge into Ericsson in a couple of years or will fail and be gobbled up by a larger predator, like the new NDS creation that has just done much the same thing in separating from Cisco. They probably belong together.