Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

13 March 2014

Merger rumors abound as Dish and DirecTV support STELA bill

DirecTV and Dish are publicly supporting a bill that will reauthorize the Satellite Television Extension and Localism Act (STELA) for five years. Put forward by Rep. Walden of the House Energy and Commerce Committee, the proposal faces a heated debate in Congress.

It comes as US regulators decide on approving the $45 billion Comcast buyout of Time Warner Cable, which will certainly trigger talk of a merger of the two leading satellite TV companies. The bill was heard by the House Communications Subcommittee on March 12th.

Dish has just signed a deal with ABC-Disney to halt the Dish AutoHop feature that let users automatically skip adverts on recorded programming. That feature will now only be available on programs older than three days. In return, Dish has secured Disney’s catalog for its new OTT offering. DirecTV will no doubt look to secure a similar deal with Disney, but since it was not skipping advertising automatically, it may have to find some other benefit to negotiate with.

The Satellite Television Extension and Localism Act of 2010 governed the retransmission of broadcast TV by satellite companies. The 2010 act was a renewal of STELA 2004, and granted statutory licenses for the satellite companies as well as modernizing the licensing system. The intention was to encourage satellite providers to make more local content available.

If the deal expires and is not renewed, some 1.5 million rural satellite customers who cannot pick up broadcast signals via an antenna will lose access to any out-of-market broadcast channels received through their satellite dish after December 31st. It will also put the satellite operators at a disadvantage to local cable operators, which in our view would reduce competition.

While focused on the blanket licenses for satellite retransmission, STELA also allows the FCC to require bargaining in good faith during the retransmission consent disputes that will affect Dish and DirecTV’s combined 34 million customers. There have been a number of recent coverage blackouts as a result of disputes between broadcasters and carriers.

Part of the draft bill would end the requirement that set tops come with cards to descramble signals. Consumer groups fear this will lead to unequal treatment for customers who buy boxes in a store rather than rent them from the pay TV supplier ‘ which they fear may raise the cost of each box by around $50.

The bill will also try to end the currently-legal collusion between broadcasters, aiming to allow cable and satellite companies to reject joint negotiations from broadcasters in favor of individual agreements with a single broadcaster.

FCC president Tom Wheeler has complained that retransmission fees have ‘skyrocketed from $28 million in 2005 to $2.4 billion in 2012, nearly an 8,600% increase in seven years.’ Matthew Polka, CEO of the American Cable Association, said ‘adoption of Wheeler’s proposed order would represent a victory not only for fair competition but also for millions of consumers who are being victimized by TV station conglomerates, which have the perverse idea that collusion is somehow consistent with their legal charter to bargain in good faith.’

Critics of the current laws surrounding TV and video broadcast, complain that they are severely outdated, written in 1992 and 1996, and see STELA as a short-term fix to the entrenched problems that are tangled up by the political process. While DirecTV and Dish applaud the decision, their rival cablecos and telcos will undoubtedly counter through extensive lobbying.

A previous draft of the STELA bill had eliminated the requirement for cable providers to include certain channels on their lowest tiers of packages. This was initially applauded by broadcasters, but has been dropped from the final bill, to their displeasure.

Should the two satellite providers merge, they stand to save billions in costs that are saved by offloading the redundant satellites that are surplus to requirement, something Dish did by selling 5 satellites to EchoStar for $11 million.

The distinction between the satellite and cable mergers is seen in the disparity between content rights that Comcast-TWC would enjoy, thanks to Comcast owning NBC-Universal.

Of the Time Warner Cable and Comcast merger, Dish chairman Charlie Ergen said that it ‘certainly doesn’t hurt the case for consolidation within the satellite industry.’

The cable providers are the 1st and 4th largest TV providers in the US. The two satellite companies fall in between, at 2nd and 3rd, and should the cable merger go ahead it would be hard to deny a satellite merger on the same grounds. A US TV duopoly looms on the horizon.