There is something fated about Microsoft’s approach to the European Union anti-trust authorities and it’s tempting to think the company just doesn’t understand.
This week it has resolved one anti-trust dispute with RealNetworks for the cost of $761 million (see separate story) but it seems determined to head straight down the path of bundling, into another, similar dispute, by bundling anti-trust software into its forthcoming Vista operating system.
The key thing, in a week when Professor Neil Barrett, a cross between a computer scientist and a lawyer, was appointed as the Trustee to keep Microsoft on the straight and narrow, is that if bundling is not allowed on the media player, it is automatically not allowed on anything else.
Throughout the hearings and the appeals of the past two years, Microsoft has steadfastly tried to say that bundling per se is not wrong, and that it is just trying to improve its operating system. With anti-virus, it could argue that its operating system is being attacked and it is a duty of care to protect it. But where that’s a case of annexing an existing successful market, then bundling is an abuse of market dominance. Open and shut.
Now that it has a trustee, if that trustee reports any behavior to the European Commission that constitutes a repeat of the previous infringement over bundling the Media Player, then there is a fast track to punishment.
So now that it turns out that Symantec has made an informal complaint to the European Commission, the trustee can step in to make recommendations of how to prevent damage, before it happens. When Microsoft bundled Media Player, there was no Trustee in place. The essence of this Symantec complaint is that Microsoft has said that it plans to bundle an antivirus and antispyware product into the Vista new operating system release due next year.
Just by ‘saying’ it plans to do this, sales of Symantec can be affected and it is likely that Microsoft has already crossed the line. IBM, in a consent decree, completely dropped its bundling approach after a US Court ruling, but Microsoft seems reluctant to give this up. It’s as if it is saying, ‘We haven’t had the appeal yet, we have to try it.’
If Microsoft is allowed to go ahead, this move will cut $ billions off Symantec and other companies’ share prices, because a paid service cannot compete with one that is subsidized by a monopoly with no charge.
Chances are that the new trustee, Neil Barrett, an expert in the field of computer security and cyber crime, will already be up to his ears in this on virtually his first day. Technically his job is to ‘provide technical advice to the Commission on issues relating to Microsoft’s compliance with the Commission’s 2004 Decision’
That decision had always talked about a Monitoring Trustee to assist the Commission in monitoring Microsoft’s compliance with the Decision. The Decision requires that the Monitoring Trustee must be independent of Microsoft, must possess the necessary qualifications to carry out his mandate, and have the possibility to hire expert advisors to assist him in carrying out tasks within his mandate.
So while it might look at first glance like the Trustee might only be able to establish whether Microsoft has made available a version of Windows without Windows Media Player, it is likely that he can take a watching brief over ‘re-offending.’ He will report directly to EU Competition Commissioner Neelie Kroes
It is likely that the day the anti-virus code hits the street in beta format, that the informal Symantec complaint will become formal, and the Trustee will give a report and the Competition Commissioner will move fast enough to make Microsoft management head whirl, and the fine is almost certain to be in multiple $ billions, and if the EC gets the US Justice Department back on board, the issue of breaking up Microsoft will rise to the surface once more. That last part is unlikely under the current US administration.
So why would Microsoft continue to go ahead? It might just as well build a browser that refuses to go to Google.com. If Microsoft management continues to endorse anti-trust as its main strategy, then it’s investors may decide that it’s time for yet more new management.