Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

8 November 2006

Microsoft tries to disrupt Sony’s party with Xbox video downloads

Microsoft finally has a chance to play at the game that Sony has played at so long in the gaming sector, spoiling the other guy’s party, and it says it will launch a service a week after the PS3 PlayStation, which allows Xbox players to download and view films and TV series.

All of which is pretty predictable, as we have said since we first heard about the designs for Xbox and PS3, that they will inevitably become home media servers as much as they are gaming consoles. Both Xbox and PS3 come to market boasting their own network adaptors, access to the internet, and are already connected to a TV set, they also have enough optional storage to hold films, so no PC is required in the equation.

The world just doesn’t have enough money for every home to buy a Blu-ray or HD DVD player, a games console, a DVR and a PC based Media Server, these consoles can be virtually all of them rolled into one..

The debate that has raged for the past five years about what will dominate the digital home, the PC or the TV has turned into a discussion about gaming consoles. The PS3, in the Cell chip, has so much processing power that it can drive multiple full 1080p progressive scan HD screens. That’s not the case for Microsoft’s Power 5 processor, but Microsoft came out all guns blazing claiming it to be the HD device of the future. It’s not. But part of the film downloading service will be 720p high definition films, so at least it’s trying, and it’s good enough for most US TVs.

High Definition TVs have been shipping for the past 5 years, but few people that bought them realized that until 2006 none of these could cope with real high definition, and what they did was throw away some of the pixels as the picture was rendered. Some of the sets shipping today can show the 2 million pixels that make up the top of the range HD programs.

Which is definitely going to play against Microsoft at some point, but not yet. Both the Xbox, with its new hard disk drive, and the PS3 with its bundled drive and bundled Blu-ray player, are likely to be bought by some unlikely customers, which see them as the cheapest way to buy High Definition DVD players. The overwhelming content advantage of Blu-ray be to Sony’s advantage, but this doesn’t apply to downloaded content, so that’s anyone’s game.

The truth is that the manufacturing costs of the new High Definition DVDs is something that still hurts the studios. They are far happier with a download service for HD than one where vast manufacturing runs have to be underwritten. We have already noted that Sony had always intended to offer film services to the PS3, and that could happen at launch. If Microsoft had NOT announced beforehand that it too had films online, then it could have been at a huge sales disadvantage. It has fixed that now.

The Microsoft content will come from CBS, MTV, Paramount and the Turner Broadcasting unit of Time Warner, as well as Warner Brothers itself and constitutes 1,000 hours available prior to Christmas, featuring a mix of popular TV series, films and some extreme sports like Ultimate Fighting Championships and abbreviated Nascar races, and these will be on the site from November 22nd.

Content includes CSI, Survivor and Star Trek from TV series and The Matrix, Superman Returns, Batman Forever and Mission Impossible 3, in the film category. Xbox Live registered customers will be able to download the video content.

The formula appears to be that TV series can be bought or rented, and films can only be rented, and that seems like a formula that may have been imposed by the studios. Sony on the other hand has its own studios and nearly 8,000 feature films of its own to choose from. Sony is unlikely to launch a film download service which is in danger of piracy and is expected to launch a new DRM with the PS3, so the other studios may also come on board with the Sony business model, as they have with most things Sony has done.

CBS has been strong and early in the online usage of all of its shows. It has them on iTunes, on Google Video, on its own site and virtually anywhere that a US citizen can buy online or watch advertising supported TV. So it is not an exclusive deal for the Xbox and we suspect that none of the others are either.

All of the content is only announced for US consumption, and treating iTunes as an example, it might take up to a year, perhaps longer, before licensing can be worked out for Europe and other countries, due to existing distribution relationships.

Pricing for the new video content was given out in a new currency called MS Points, with a HD film rental costing 480 points, a standard film rental some 320 points, and a TV show download to own purchase around 240 points. Think of a point as worth slightly less than a cent and you have it about right, as Microsoft said that its prices would be compatible with iTunes which offers TV series for $1.99.

Forgetting about the battle for consumer hearts and minds, both these consoles are suddenly going to put a hole in the pocket of any film service, even pay per view and VoD cable services. The pricing is roughly the same and it will be the kids that want to watch the programming in charge of the console. If any of the major operators reach out to tax such a service by introducing bandwidth caps or increased peering charges, or even lacing video stream blocks on their service, the US will have to revisit the net neutrality issue once again and legal actions could be flying about.

This is all about the fragmentation of video services. As more sources of video emerge, each one has less of the market. The net result is dilution of mindshare from broadcasting, from pay TV services and the resultant loss of advertising services for the networks. It also leads to heavily congested internet access networks and at some point, someone will ask one of these services to pay.

The other upshot of this service and the potential for Sony to run a similar service. is that the initially cheap Xbox now begins to cost more, as the extra hard disk and the HD DVD drive make it about the same price as the PS3.

Sony has already had the sense to bundle a free Blu-ray video film with the first half million sales, which means that 500,000 households are going to see something quite special in terms of visual reproduction of movie quality as soon as they get the PS3 home. That’s going to be a genuine shock.

Even if those homes don’t have HD TVs, the built-in HMDI connectivity will give a good enough showing of the TV quality, and many almost HD or HD ready TVs will show quality substantially beyond anything most US homes have ever seen.