Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

22 September 2011

Moca 2.0 may have throughput edge, but is it enough to invade Europe?

Entropic, the US chipmaker who has been driving the MoCA (Multimedia over Coax Alliance) standard, has renewed its offensive on Europe, with a showing at IBC which cited the first availability of MoCA 2.0 chipsets, deals based around 100 Mbps internet services using Ethernet over MoCA and a continued push to make MoCA the backbone of at least some European homes, despite the distinct lack of coax in many regions.

MoCA 2.0 has been on our radar for some time with specs first discussed in mid-2009 and the standard set 15 months ago. IBC was the first public demonstration that such chips now exist. But the first MoCA offensive in Europe largely drew blanks, with some executives shrugging at the complete lack of existing coax and the lack of desire or ability, especially among multi-dwelling unit consumers, to consider it.

Most players in the home entertainment space in Europe have either gone down the WiFi route ‘ it was a hotbed of early video oriented WiFi from Ruckus for instance ‘ or have opted for HPNA, which is a rival system which carries signals over the smaller twisted pair used by telephone companies, or used the power cabling already in homes ‘ itself now the focus of an ugly battle between Homeplug supports and G.hn players.

But the inclusion within the UPC Horizon set top of a MoCA connection has re-enthused Entropic and it wheeled its big guns out at the show, in the form of Anton Monk, one of the founders talking about how the first generation of MoCA used a single 50 MHz channel and how this new generation, uses at least one , but potentially two, bonded 100 MHz channels.

Monk explained to us that MoCA uses QAM modulation on thousands of OFDM sub- carriers, but also adds complex bit loading algorithms, so that for each carrier a calculation can be done about how many bits it can deliver given its specific carrier to noise ratio, and this can change over time, so is constantly re-calculated. It’s a way of stuffing as much data into a pipe, while still ensuring that the pipe never has more than an acceptable threshold of errors. That kind of mathematical certainty is very good for carrying video, because we all know that damage through packet loss to a very small amount of data, in a key part of an I-Frame can lead to large scale pixellation and visual artifacts.

MoCA 2.0 operates between 500 MHz up to 1650 MHz , which allows multiple MoCA networks to find frequencies alongside provider services. It’s a complex piece of silicon, to say the least, which is why it has taken so long for it to arrive since standards work was completed in June 2010. The chips are not expected to be installed anywhere until first quarter next year. MoCA 1.0 operated at around 175 Mbps and was heavily criticized by rivals, but the new MoCA 2.0 claims to deliver 400 Mbps in a single 100 MHz channel, double that to 800 Mbps in two bonded MoCA channels, with an extra 20% throughput when it operates in Turbo mode, so 500 Mbps and 1 GHz, but this is something it can only do when it is operating point to point between just two devices, rather than when it is being used as a broadly based home network.

But these numbers do take MoCA slightly out of reach of the powerline communications systems in the real world. Rival Sigma Designs is fond of mentioning how its Clearpath technology speeds things up in powerline by using all three cables to create a 3 Gbps PHY, but despite this, it only cites real world performance of something like 20 to 25 Mbps at every electrical outlet in a home, using the Homeplug AV spec and something like 65 Mbps (at every outlet) using G.hn, and something like 200 Mbps using G.hn with Clearpath in 75% of home electrical outlets.

Of course G.hn is supposed to be able to work on any kind of line, twisted pair and coax as well as powerlines, so we need to be careful we are comparing like with like. In terms of real world performance for G.hn on Coax this falls from a 1 Gbps PHY to around 700 Mbps to 800 Mbps and over phone lines offers a practical payload of about 450 Mbps. There is of course no Clearpath technology for coax because there is only a single cable in coax

These are in the same ball park as MoCA primarily, because we are really just talking about standard modulations, similar amounts of spectrum and while MoCA clearly seems to have a small lead here, the chips are only just available, and a 20% throughput improvement ahead of a rival, is not going to lead to widescale replacement. HPNA on Coax customers could go anywhere, but their eco-system will probably point them at G.hn and MoCA customers will certainly not go anywhere else. Where there are green field sites which need Coax installed there is the potential in Europe for powerline to be the standard home backbone network just as much as MoCA.

We will know more about MoCA’s European success when numbers begin to emerge on the UPC Horizon installations, but since we happen to believe that this will only be targeted at the top spending 10% among its customers base, this is likely to lead to perhaps 400,000 installs over the next few years. It could be far more, but that depends on soon to be announced pricing, and then we have to know just how many of these homes actually choose to use the MoCA option. It might be just a handful, it could be all of them.

Monk is also keen remind us that like the US, more and more homes are having a second TV set in Europe, and says that this will lead to a proliferation of multi-room DVRs, which both need a high speed point to multipoint connection such as MoCA, or something like it.

The statement on MoCA 2.0 quotes a report from IHS Screen Digest, which found that the number of households in Europe with more than one TV has grown by 50% between the end of 2005 and 2011, which it says will spur the deployment of a home network. What this actually says to us is that in Europe pay TV operators will have to lay coax cable to connect TVs around the home to central storage and DVRs, so the cost is going to be on them, but the benefits, in terms of churn reduction, will be considerable. The ramp up in Blu-ray players will create the same need for a home network. So this stops being any kind of consumer decision, and is entirely an operator decision.

It may happen in Europe for MoCA, but we think operator by operator, different decisions will be taken around Europe and that even where cable operators opt for MoCA, it will lead to precious few installations. Of course many tablets will become secondary TV sets, so perhaps WiFi, and not MoCA will be the more important technology to install and it could be the dominant technology here, with powerline sufficient as a back-up, especially if they can be merged into a single IP network, as the work on P1905 intends, although that interoperability standard will also take in MoCA (yes but that will, as we say, lead operators to extra cable installation costs).

When we mentioned the UPC decision regarding MoCA to other technologists at the IBC show, the most common response was that the UPC decision was a classic case of a US parent company, dictating its European subsidiary’s decision on technology, in the process ignoring local realities. We are inclined to agree.

Despite that the MoCA release included a quote from Balan Nair, the CTO at UPC who is based in Europe., but that doesn’t mean he actually made that particular decision, just endorsed it publicly and we know that Celeno video capable WiFi is included in the device also, which may obviate coax in many cases.

So all of this makes the other MoCA announcements fairly significant, with Finnish operator Blue Lake Communications deploying InCoax Gigabit over Coax (GoCATM) in partnership with local firm InCoax Networks, so this offers other uses for the MoCA chips. This particular deal uses it to drive a relatively small telco network in Finland with Ethernet over Coax based on MoCA chips. Another similar deal with the UK’s Technetix will put it in a position to install similar technology at European cable operators ‘ potentially at Virgin Media. Technetix offers a single port Ethernet to coax adapter with an Entropic MoCA chip which provides a straightforward plug-and-play installation onto an existing home coaxial wall socket. That’s neat, take a coax wall socket and turn it into a home network. The problem here is that many European homes give the impression of having Coax installed with such wall sockets, but they are purely for rooftop antennas, but this stuff is substandard, usually using RG59 cabling and not good enough to run a MoCA signal safely over any distance.

Entropic also showed the Pace built DirecTV multi-room DVR on its stand, which is the first to deploy the Remote User Interface (RUI) system based on the RVU standard. So it can also push the idea that RVU technology works off the shelf with MoCA, although as far as we can see, it can work with any backbone technology.

The RVU standard allows a single server in a household to serve multiple clients simultaneously, providing every TV the same consistent user interface and experience and it went on trial at DirecTV in the US back in May.