Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

12 April 2006

Modeo’s first mobile TV efforts are all Windows

Modeo, the Crown Castle subsidiary that is planning to launch the first DVB-H based mobile TV network in the US, has announced its first phone based on Window Mobile, with the network protected not by the cellular market derived OMA DRM, but by Windows Media DRM.

Windows Mobile handsets are larger, and tend to be more clunky and unwieldy compared to most DVB-H handsets, and only a few percentage of mobile phone owners have selected them despite over 40 operators over the world offering the devices (see picture below).

This means that companies like Nokia, which has labored so hard to get DVB-H taken up all over the world, will be need alternative DRM offered before it can supply phones because it staunchly refuses to support Windows Media or the Microsoft DRM system.

Of course the use of Windows Media DRM comes as no real surprise since Modeo has always said that many of its customers will be people wanting to watch mobile TV on PCs, laptops and PDAs, and the easiest way to support these is to use the Windows Media DRM client which has been openly bundled into all Windows platforms, along with Windows Media Player.

While the decision to take a phone from Taiwanese newcomer High Tech Computer (HTC), which dominates the tiny market for Windows smart phones and Pocket PCs, may mean that Modeo begins life with a cheap phone, it also means that all of the other DVB-H breakthroughs elsewhere on Symbian and Linux phones are going to be lost to it, unless it introduces a parallel DRM to work with these phones, probably one using the OMA DRM 2.0 system. On the other hand, in order for DVB-H to be viewed on PCs and PDAs it was always going to be necessary for Modeo to offer Windows Media DRM, and running two DRMs was perhaps always part and parcel of the cost of building out its network.

So far, none of the US cellular operators have come out and said they will use the US DVB-H network, with Verizon electing to go with a MediaFLO network being built by Qualcomm and Sprint Nextel working towards its own 2.5GHz network and its own TV system. That means that if Modeo fails to attract Cingular as a partner in its DVB-H network it will not have the easy channel to existing mobile customers that a nationwide cell phone network would give it. If Cingular does decide, at this late stage, to throw in with Modeo, it will have its own ideas about which phones will work best with the DVB-H QVGA screen features.

If Cingular does not decide to back the Modeo roll out, then it will have to turn to the hundreds of tiny regional cellular operations in the US as partners, as well as equipment companies like Dell and Intel, which may add the DVB-H capability onto their devices.

One of the things that has thrown a spanner in the works for media on handsets has been the way the GSM Association, which represents mobile operators, and the MPEG LA patent pool, that is working towards a license for the technologies uses in the OMA spec, have argued over licensing costs. This stalemate has left the mobile market in disarray and on the lookout for alternatives ‘ hence the Modeo decision.

The phone was in fact designed (see picture below) by Modeo and the company says that its features and functions were identified through Modeo’s consumer pilot testing program. Modeo said a lot of nice things about it, but really what we heard was ‘If we are going to have to subsidize or retail our own phone, it had better be extremely cheap.’

The Modeo handset works in quad-band GSM (850/900/1800/1900 MHz) so that it can be used virtually anywhere in the world, which implies that HTC is hoping to offer the same device to other operators around the world. The handset will support GPRS/EDGE services for high speed data access and file downloads as well.

The handset will also use Windows Media Player 10 Mobile to playback video and music stored in multiple formats, including Windows Media Audio, MP3 and AAC, the audio file type used on the iPod.

The company says that music subscription services will be offered in parallel with the mobile TV service. And if customers choose to use this phone with an existing cellular subscription, it can run Internet Explorer Mobile and Outlook Mobile, offer calendaring and email and compete head on with Blackberry style devices.

The chip driving the Windows Mobile is the Texas Instruments OMAP850 200 MHz processor, and it uses a DiBcom DVB-H Demodulator, a tuner from Microtune and a graphics processors from Nvidia. We’re not quite sure why the Nvidia chip is required, because the OMAP chip can handle the graphics perfectly well. Presumable his is because the software has already been written for Windows and on other devices the graphics chip is usually Nvidia, so there is no need for code changes on different Windows Mobile versions. A new EPG has also been designed for the phone by Penthera Technologies.

The phone includes a standard stereo headphone jack, a 1.3 mega pixel camera and a micro-SD expansion card slot that allows the user to add up to 1 GB of flash memory for storing songs, video clips, games and movies.

TV broadcasts and other video are shown on a 2.2-inch QVGA landscape display at up to 30 frames per second, with three hours of TV viewing in the battery and four hours of talk time or six days standby. But its weight is over 4 ounces, about the same as one of the big video iPods, and five times the weight of a Nano, so if Modeo is targeting the iPod, it may have a bit of a surprise coming.

Modeo has been running a long standing DVB-H trial in the US in Pittsburgh and says that it will open its network in the 30 largest US markets during the course of this year and next, including New York City.