It’s almost as if everyone in the US agreed to make all their Over The Top announcements together at The Cable Show this week in Chicago, perhaps it’s because it’s the last date in the Summer for products that will be delivered this year in the holiday season. But perhaps top of the pile of announcements are those from Motorola Mobility which issued a broadside of new devices, which give it an end to end OTT capability, in an attempt to ensure its continued dominance of US cable.
Gone is the wishy, washy Motorola which always came last to a new technology, rather begrudgingly, and instead this is a business fighting for every deal that it has on its home soil. The two major announcements was one in partnership with Comcast Innovation Labs which has jointly developed its new Televation home WiFi TV device and the other with Time Warner Cable for a home video gateway, the DCX3600M, which delivers video to and around a cable home in IP format.
The shape of Motorola Mobility was always going to force it to head down a path where it led on communication between pay TV service providers and handsets and tablets, and the move has the stamp of CEO Sanjay Jha, who has driven the company’s comeback in handsets over the past three years.
The first part of Motorola’s TV to phone strategy is the Comcast co-developed device, which can tune into cable TV coax, decrypt using CableCard, and then resend the video stream out around the home as WiFi, after re-encoding and re-encrypting it. The device is called the Televation and has a 1GHz digital tuner alongside the CableCard and streams the cable video signal throughout the home to portable devices and other set tops.
Motorola said at the Cable show in Chicago this week that it worked closely with engineers at Comcast Innovation Labs to develop Televation, which implies that Comcast will be the first to deploy the technology. Perhaps Comcast will even have a part of the intellectual property and an exclusive for a period. However no prices or timescales for Comcast using this were given. If Motorola manages such a deal, then it could also have found a major buyer for its Xoom tablet in the same stroke, making it available to 23 million US cable homes through Comcast.
Motorola has always said that it was developing a TV Tablet for Verizon’s FiOS service, but so far Comcast and Time Warner, it’s oldest stalwart clients, are the ones that appear to be ready to rely on new Motorola technology.
There is a considerable technological leap in the Televation product and it will need some neat footwork by Comcast to come into play. The big problem here has always been the ability to protect video streams once they are bouncing around the home on WiFi, and in a parallel announcement Motorola Mobility has separately launched a version of DTCP-IP provided by its recent DRM acquisition Secure Media. The system is called Internet Protocol Rights Management-Home Network (IPRM-HN) and it has just been passed by the Digital Transmission Licensing Administrator’s (DTLA) approval process for both streaming and storage. Now that doesn’t mean that the Hollywood Studios have okayed it, for that it would probably have to pass some kind of security audit and then get proposed by the DLNA as a standard in its stack. As we understand it DTCP-IP has to be implemented with a security chip in the hardware, and yet this version appears not to have that since it is aimed at both Android and iOS and although Motorola could put a chip into its Xoom tablet, it can’t put one inside an Apple iOS device although it could design a dongle for it.
Also Hollywood Studios are still uncomfortable with the process of copying a TV program onto a tablet or a smart phone for viewing outside the home, so although it has the DTLA approval for how this process works, content owners are only likely to allow the streaming capability in its Televation not storage. But Motorola insists that it can use the authentication and encryption in IPRM-HN to make a copy on a device which is connected to and registered to the home network. Yes it can be done, and we’ve seen DTCP-IP versions in software only (for instance set top company ADB had one at IBC), but whether Comcast can convince its channels to go along with the idea in a deployment, is another matter. Of course Comcast now owns NBC, so it can seed the market with its own content and show everyone else that the water is fine and invite them in. It is only someone like Comcast that can start something like this, other operators would not have enough clout with studios. Motorola Mobility said that CableLabs had also ratified the product.
The Televation will plug directly into a Wireless router with an Ethernet port and can then stream encrypted WiFi signals throughout the home. This makes more and more sense of the announcement by Motorola Mobility last month of a WiFi video network bridge, the VAP2400. So Motorola can now send a dedicated TV signal throughout the home using WiFi, including bridging it to other rooms even if usual WiFi connections are weak. So far DTCP-IP has only found a home in multi-room DVRs and these have almost all been connected with a physical wire using MoCA or HPNA. The Motorola system seems to be entirely wireless and aimed at smart phones and tablets. But as we go through these announcements there is a feeling that what Motorola is actually saying is, ‘Whatever you want, we can build it,’ and has adhered to different scenarios for different operators, so it will probably do one based on MoCA or HPNA or G.hn or Homeplug AV if anyone asks for it.
But is this secure? Well the underlying DTCP technology is owned by Hitachi, Panasonic, Toshiba, Intel and Sony, and it is these companies that control the licensing of the technology. DTCP-IP is a method for setting up an encrypted connection between two devices, even when their first ever communication between them, when keys are swapped, has to be presumed to be eavesdropped. It uses something called an Elliptic Curve Digital Signature for authentication and the Elliptic Curve Diffie-Hellman algorithm for key exchange, which in turn relies on AES encryption and PKI.
The idea behind DTCP is that two devices ‘ server and client say ‘share a secret over a non-secret channel that may be intercepted, but only they can apply the cipher to it and it has largely been accepted by Hollywood studios as the best available technology to make this connection between set tops and portable devices. So far they have said they want to see it working with hardware support only, but putting special new hardware into every tablet on the planet isn’t going to happen, so at some point this technology will have to be ripe in a software only format.
Until this week, almost all video distribution strategies to tablets have relied on content travelling over the public internet, which is far less safe against piracy than taking a pay TV signal and sending it encrypted over WiFi. Taking the signal out of the set top also gets cable operators away from a debate about whether they have the content rights to use the internet for distribution, since this way they don’t have to. This may in fact be the reason for Comcast’s interest.
Motorola says that it has conducted focus groups with consumers who liked the idea of watching live TV somewhere other than in a traditional family room and felt it would allow them to spend more time with loved ones if they had the ability to watch different programs in the same room. Not sure how much love is being swapped in a room where two people are having different media experiences, but we suppose it’s like reading different books in the same room.
Motorola says it will provide SDKs for both Android and iOS development environments for IPRM-HN, so pay TV operators can develop client applications which let subscribers navigate, discover and select content on a tablet and give it their own look and feel. Some observers are saying that this is similar to the EchoStar Sling Box, because the Televation also transcodes from MPEG 2 to denser H.264 and re-encodes the resolution of the stream to suit the destination device. But the big difference here is that the signal remains digital throughout, and never has to be re-encoded from an analog stream, which always loses some video quality.
The deal at Time Warner Cable again seems to be a joint development and is described as a video gateway platform capable of delivering an advanced consumer in-home entertainment experience.
“Consumers want to watch content on their own terms and the migration towards video gateways is recognition that traditional set-tops are evolving to enable the entertainment experience consumers are now demanding,” said Larry Robinson, corporate vice president and general manager, Home Devices, Motorola Mobility. “Motorola’s DCX3600M Video Gateway enables service providers to shift to IP in the home so that they can more easily offer the types of services consumers are beginning to expect.”
Like the other product, the Televation, this has in built transcoding, getting you from the dominant MPEG2 environment of US cable TV, to what it is calling MEPG-4, but by which we assume this is MPEG4 part 10, the same as H.264. In the process it also transfers it from a QAM signal on a coaxial cable to an IP one, presumably turned into WiFi in the same way as the Televation so it can be consumed on mobile devices including tablets and smartphones over the home network.
The DCX3600M is different from the Televation in that it has up to six tuners working simultaneously and it can also access IP services delivered directly over DOCSIS. In fact the more we look at this it’s the same set of technical problems being solved ‘ Comcast appears to want it to be a retail proposition, so customers buy the Televation, while Time Warner Cable wants to offer a home gateway as part and parcel of its service ‘ perhaps that’s the only difference.
If so then the same DTCP-IP protection is operating in the Time Warner Cable home gateway as in the Televation, though so far it has not said so.
“The migration of our network and in-home video services to IP represents an important shift as we look to provide our consumers with the most compelling user experience possible and we are excited to collaborate with Motorola in the area of video gateways,” said Mike Hayashi, EVP, Architecture, Development and Engineering, Time Warner Cable. “These types of platforms will offer our customers greater flexibility when accessing our premium services.”
But just because these two operators believe they can bully studios to let them go ahead with WiFi to tablet distribution, it doesn’t mean that the other route to the tablet, over the public internet from a central server, complete with things like watermarking and streaming protection, isn’t also valid, so Motorola Mobility and its SecureMedia acquisition has also added Apple flavored adaptive streaming services to work alongside its SecureMedia DRM system. This doesn’t mean this is one solution for Comcast, another for Time Warner Cable and a third for everyone else, but where content isn’t organized in TV channels, there will always be a route via broadband and WiFi, to the tablet for video. Comcast and Time Warner may use this as well.
It is called Encryptonite ONE HLS+ (HLS stands for HTTP Live Streaming) and is being touted as an end-to-end adaptive streaming system offering secure content delivery to smartphones, tablets, laptops and game consoles. It could probably reach Smart TVs as well.
HLS+ uses the Apple developed HTTP Live Streaming which is being lined up as an IETF standard, and says it’s fine for both linear and on-demand content distribution to all devices and uses SecureMedia DRM function in the form of its Encryptonite One, which was originally built to protect IPTV systems.
By supporting only one streaming standard Motorola is saying ‘why not go right back to your server and put in your own streaming and then you only have to deal with one flavor of it throughout your network.’ It’s fine for operators by not device makers who live in a multiple streaming format world. But by building out the client software for each device, including Android, it means that any client device can cope with this type of stream. Google may not like it, and Microsoft may hate it, but it can be made to work.
Motorola’s SecureMedia is offering ready built versions of the client software for Android clients on smartphones and tablets, naturally including the Motorola Xoom, as well as on Motorola’s IP and hybrid set-tops (we didn’t know it had any hybrid set tops but that’s perhaps another announcement). Other clients include one for Apple iOS and OS X, Windows, and Sony Playstation 3 and in the near future Motorola says that there will be clients for Internet-connected TVs, Blu-ray Disk players and set-tops from other manufacturers.
The entire Motorola system will offer content ingestion, processing, delivery and security ‘ which Motorola says will minimize costs compared with “silo” approaches where companies have to invest in specific headend equipment and allocate additional bandwidth for each adaptive streaming format.
The SecureMedia Encryptonite ONE HLS+ system is already on trials with premier North American operators says Motorola.
Finally Comcast has said that thePlatform which it owns, will serve as a central video logistics system its Next-Generation TV initiative, so we can now get a full picture of the Comcast Next Gen OTT environment, with back end management being driven by thePlatform, and the plumbing being dealt with by Motorola (and a hybrid Xfinity IP set top from Pace ‘ see separate story). thePlatform has effectively added cloud based video management its existing mpx product line and it will serve as the central management hub for Comcast’s Xfinity TV service.
Xfinity TV is already on trial in Augusta, and allows easier navigation and search across tens of thousands of choices.
‘TV services have historically been defined by infrastructure equipment, but that’s changing,’ said Ian Blaine, CEO of thePlatform and senior vice president in Comcast Converged Products. ‘Moving forward, cloud computing will play a defining role in enabling TV service providers to innovate and differentiate. We’re very proud to support this initiative with Comcast, and it’s a testament to the robustness and scalability of our capabilities.’
mpx will manage video ingest and aggregation from multiple sources, in some cases this must be on the fly in real time and also handles metadata aggregation, normalization, and search capabilities for live-linear channels and video on demand.
thePlatform also said this week that it has signed a strategic alliance with Alcatel Lucent to help cable and IPTV providers deliver hybrid OTT and multiscreen services, including live scheduled TV, VoD and TV Everywhere services to a variety of screens. Given Alcatel’s involvement with both AT&T’s U-Verse and Verizon’s FiOS TV, it could even end up being used at these companies despite Comcast’s ownership of thePlatform.
The system comes with advanced video management and optimized video distribution through a content delivery network deployed by the service provider.
The Alcatel-Lucent Multiscreen Video Platform is made up of three main components ‘ Cloud, Content Delivery Network and Clients ‘ and thePlatform is providing the Cloud element.
And finally Comcast CEO Brian Roberts will stand up on Thursday, as this issue goes out, and announce his vision of how all this technology will come together including a description of a personalized TV experience called MyTV where users can see and access all of their recordings in one place.