Different shows have different personalities or throw up different problems and at Anga Cable this week in Cologne the speakers all seemed to have decided that now was the time to complain about Content Rights.
This was never more plain than in a breakfast discussion compered by Julian Clover of Broadband TV News, and hosted by Verimatrix. Every single speaker separately raised the subject of content rights as the main obstacle to improved services for consumers.
Eric Meijer, Senior Innovation Manager at Ziggo said that nPVR was on its roadmap and that there was a clear opportunity for a full 7 day catch up service in the Netherlands, but said, ‘It’s tough in the short term, the technology is all there, but the right issues are another matter.’
Almost in step Wolfgang Zeller, VP Service Engineering for Kabel Deutschland said, ‘If it was down to us, we would already have nPVR, but in Germany it is all about studios insisting that we keep a separate copy for every individual.’ He went on to admit that Kabel Deutschland so far had not even got a multiscreen delivery system, but that Vodafone its new owner is very keen on this, and that it is now working in the labs, and in another 4 to 5 months it will be ready. ‘We thought about whether or not we should build this ourselves, but it is clear that it is best to buy off the shelf technology for this,’ but he did not say what.
Danish cable firm Stofa was in the news last week for taking Elemental encoders for its multiscreen system, offering 150 TV channels, all of them out of home. Thomas Helbo, the Stofa CTO told us, ‘Out of home is common in Denmark because of the laws there, and we have 48 hour catch up services and we have start over, But the rights for start over were really complicated, and we have no nPVR for the same reason, it is purely a rights issue, not a technology one. Playback on a tablet is it easy with IP and most users watch 10 to 12 hours a week of this, but again this idea of having a separate instance for each customer makes nPVR implausible.’
The interesting thing is that none of these spokesmen coordinated this as a strike on the content industry, but instead each one was drawn to the mention of content rights by the way the discussion went. The TiVo spokesman also echoed the sentiment in the form of Joe Weber, Vice President of Technology Strategy. ‘We are showing customers nPVR on multiscreen, and it was easy for us, we had no proprietary system in place to protect, so we’ve gone down the IP, Linux and HTML 5.0 route early on.’ But once again he bemoaned the wait for content rights for nPVR to become a reality.
Verimatrix president Steve Oetegenn tried to see the side of content owners, ‘Well they all have to make sure they make as much money as possible from their content. We have one US operator who wanted us to authorize up to 30 connected devices per home, and studios just feel they need to limit it, mostly to two concurrently used licenses. We have all the tools, and we can limit the IP locations or routes, if they ask us to,’ and more or less finished on a shrug. Content owners ‘ over to you.