Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

6 December 2006

Music majors unable to slip anything past Europe’s regulators

The music industry just doesn’t seem to know what to do with itself. EMI reported the likelihood of a bid last week, the Sony-BMG merger has been blocked by the European Court of First Instance and this week the deal whereby Universal, the largest label, bought BMG’s music publishing business to become the largest music publishing business, has now been referred to the European Commission.

The companies that dominate the landscape are too big to buy each other it seems, without shifting a massive competitive advantage that can harm both the other large players, or the nascent independent sector made up of some 3,000 or so, smaller companies.

It is in these conditions that anti-trust authorities usually reach for interfering regulation and potentially opt for the break up of the larger players if the private equity groups won’t do it for them.

The EC says that that its initial review of the €1.63bn ($2.1 billion) deal to sell BMG’s publishing rights to UMG in September will need a secondary review

That deal included a behind the scenes legal resolution, with Universal agreeing to drop all legal claims against Bertelsmann, including those relating to it financially supporting Napster, when it was an illegal P2P service. If the deal is blocked by the EC, does it mean that those legal battles come alive once again? Even though a $60 million payment was made y Bertelsmann to cover legal fees and expenses.

Also the deal was supposed to fund Bertelsmann’s repayment of much of the debt it incurred when it repurchased a 25% external holding from Belgian conglomerate GBL. So we presume it will still be looking for another way to pay down debt.