Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

8 March 2006

Myrio CEO sees new set of hurdles for successful IPTV rollouts

The IPTV Forum in London this week was kicked off by Chris Coles, the CEO of Myrio, one of the middleware companies that act like glue in most IPTV projects, and now a subsidiary of Siemens.

Siemens and its Surpass system have had major successes at Belgacom and KPN this year in Europe, and Belgacom, after a slow start, is understood to be connecting about 500 IPTV homes a day.

Coles represents the old school IPTV, made up by the start ups who invented the business, as opposed to the big technology companies like Alcatel, Motorola, Cisco and Microsoft and of course his new parent company Siemens, who have recently invaded.

Coles recapped the progress made so far in IPTV and got down to business talking about the devil that is in the detail of different IPTV installations all over the World.

‘It’s not just about bundling services and churn reduction. There remain bandwidth, content and integration challenges. There are divergent take up rates, every region is different.

‘The are four things that define TV right now. Delivery options can be cable or satellite or DTH or even VHS and DVD. Viewing habits are changing through DVR and network DVR and the demand based experience began with video stores.

‘There is a lot more content produced every day that is already digital, in news and sports programming especially and the devices that it is played on are both growing (big flat TV screens) and shrinking (iPods and handsets).’

‘There is business model flux. It is well understood that the revenue model for voice is declining, so is data delivery. So cost structures need to be declining too and it is imperative that there are new revenue streams and video is essential. But video brings with it the same disruption that the world wide web brought to voice networks. And the successful companies are not those that treat video as some kind of late arriving step child. The global leaders in this technology ‘ and he pointed to PCCW and Fastweb ‘ are triple play by design and they promote the service like a mobile operator or a broadcaster, not like an incumbent telco.

‘In my experience there are four enduring aspects, the first is content, the second is communications. In the past audience engagement meant that the consumer picked up a phone or logged onto the internet. With IPTV direct interaction will become possible.

‘On the commerce side companies like BSkyB have managed to engage with customers successfully, but there are more examples of failure in the past in commerce connection to consumers, but this is improving day by day, with a pure IP model.

‘Finally there is the control aspect, one that has to be given a lot of consideration. A large number of viewers remain okay with passive viewing. To them choice looks like complexity. But there is a rapidly growing segment, which includes everybody under 30, that wants to chat, interact with TV programs, find out what their friends and neighbors are watching and share it with them.’

But then Coles went back to his warnings. ‘Not all networks are the same. They have different loop lengths, different loops density, different fiber depths, and most of all the back office and billing is different, And finally regulatory environments vary from country to country as does consumer behavior.’

‘The timeline is different in each country. If the incumbent has to rewire the country to enable a 25 Mbps signal, with outside plant programs, then you can be waiting ten years for IPTV.’

This led to his clarion cry that in order to be relevant, IPTV practitioners need to customize, and this was a parthian shot aimed behind him at his rival Microsoft. His implication was clearly that some companies offer a ‘one size fits all’ strategy, while Myrio and its partners, are more prepared to customize.

‘No two solutions are the same. There are different encoding schemes, and while everyone is opting for MPEG 4, there are a variety of implementations, and there are licensing issues.

‘How close do we take VoD to the edge of the network is another decision that varies from customer to customer. We know it is not wise to have only DVRs in the home and we know it is now wise to have it all in the network, the best is a combination, but where is the right compromise for each operator?’

‘And what is the degree of personalization that each operator will allow their consumers, that’s another key choice,’ he said before moving onto support services.

‘For Operational Support Systems most operators start with an overlay network, but there needs to be a new genre of billing system. And as for security, it is clear that IPTV networks are held to a more stringent standard by the content businesses. It is easier today to steal content from a cable or satellite network than from IPTV,’ a statement that will have made him more enemies than friends, but which is becoming increasingly true.

Coles went on to call for what he called ‘out of market’ content by which he means that IPTV systems need to evolve to bring any content in the world to a set top or a PC or to a mobile, whether it is connected to the home network or not.

And although he stuck by his guns, saying that he still believed in buying best of breed (rather than one size fits all) an IPTV project needs systems integration, project management, and above all a full system view on how to optimize a network. ‘A change in any part of the network usually has adverse affects in every other part of the network, and you have to be able to see that and fix it.’

Finally he settled on integration of services as the way forward. ‘We have some integration with voice ‘ call control and call visibility on a TV screen for instance ‘ but there needs to be more and better integration between the services in order to really prevent churn,’ said Coles. His point is that once you are used to the benefit of live TV pausing when you have an incoming call and caller id flashing on the screen, it is then that a triple play customer won’t feel comfortable canceling his TV or his phone service, because they work together. Right now they can be cancelled and all the consumer loses is a bit of discount.