US rights commerce start-up Navio may be years ahead of its time, but its thought processes are headed, in our view, in the right direction. It has provided a basis for buying and selling rights to access and own digital media, which are separated from the actual files that carry them.
Already Disney, Sony BMG, Shockwave and Fox Sports have signed up to the new version of the Navio software, launched this week, allowing them to sell the rights to consume a specific work rather than individual downloads.
Faultline has always believed that this would be a good step, in the right direction and it reduces the role of DRM to a simple encrypted delivery mechanism.
Navio describes its technology as ‘Rights over IP’ (RoIP) based on the idea that rights are far easier to manage than physical files, and can be created, acquired, stored, traded, transferred, and redeemed. The fact that this enables device independence is a step towards interoperable digital rights management, but without the complexity of many other approaches.
As the number of device types and file formats rise, sometimes seemingly exponentially, and various vendors try to establish a lead using proprietary formats, we seem to be moving further and further from the notion that you might be able to buy permanent standing rights to access a particular film or piece of music.
What you tend to buy instead is a single copy of that film or music in a single format, which is constrained in what you are allowed to do with it by complicated DRM software. One thing that you are rarely currently allowed to do with such a file is to convert it into another file format. So a Windows Media file that is the right dimensions for a PC might be transferable to a mobile phone, but can you change its format to H.264 and compress it to the correct screen size and still maintain its security? Well you might be able to, but it’s a complicated job for your DRM software an it requires a lot of processing power, and all of the complicated jobs that DRM is required to do may be beyond it.
That’s why one of the first jobs in DRM is to decide what formats are acceptable, with the aim of making that as few formats as possible. The MPEG 21 failed DRM standard tried to standardize on content formats, digital identifiers, meta data, and a trust model for transferring and creating decryption keys, as well as a rights expression language, for making statements about what can be done with the content, once transferred.
Such a system also needs to state unambiguously what rights are being transferred in every transaction, including those in a multi-tiered distribution chain.
A far simpler way forward is perhaps to always centralize the storage of rights. That way a file with the right format, with very simply usage rules and simpler encryption processes, can be delivered upon presentation of the ‘rights’ to a central store.
The outcome is simple even if the technology is not. A consumer buys the rights to a piece of music, and as long as he can continue to ‘prove’ who he is, using some form of federated identity, that itself is not easy to steal, then he can have multiple copies of a content file based on his current needs ‘ for the mobile, a High Definition TV set, a PC, a Mac, anything.
Having the technology, is of course, not enough and this type of tool needs to be in the hands of an enlightened content business. At present too many content businesses achieve their financial numbers by selling the same customers multiple iterations of the same content. They would need to be happy to sell the content once, and offer a multi-platform distribution system. Sure the price for a multi-content version might be more, but it would be a single transaction and permanent rights.
This approach enables device independence for web or mobile, more merchandising flexibility through mixed web and mobile bundles, and distributed transactions, enabling ecommerce to become decentralized, which in turns, says Navio, makes every customer interaction as an opportunity for another transaction.
Navio introduced this all in its product AV Commerce 2.0, which it says will work with any DRM system, and enhancements to its system include a new user interface, expanded storefront types, new content management services, new distribution options such as enhanced PIN support and mobile campaign support and management, and enhanced reporting.
For companies like Disney, this is potentially a very powerful way of welcoming in the new internet and mobile download market, taking the complexity out of the service as far as it is concerned as a company and offloading it all to Navio.
Navio’s CEO Stefan Roever, said ‘We enable brands like Atom Entertainment, Fox Sports Mobile, and Walt Disney Internet Group, to manage the pricing, bundling, promotion, and usage of their content, and build direct trusted relationships with consumers of their products. With the rights-based model, consumers gain valuable rights to their song, video, game, or other content, and can use their digital assets in more ways than current commerce models allow.’
We suspect that right now these companies see offerings like Navio as doing little more than simplifying their delivery networks and opening them up to more formats ‘ buy from a phone or buy from a web site – and making bundles easy to offer, but eventually we believe that this will allow, and potentially lead to, more enlightened offerings in the consumer market, where consumers can play content on any device and not have to worry about compatibility issues; cease to worry about moving content from one device to another; stop losing content if a device is lost or upgraded; keep content for use on next generation devices and potentially to offer super distribution through recommendations to friends on P2P networks.
So far Navio has raised $37.9 million in funding, and its business model is to charge a set up fee and a percentage of transactions on a hosted system.