Google-owned Nest has bought security camera firm Dropcam for $555 million. The move adds a security offering to Nest’s thermostat and smoke alarms, and is proof of what we here at Rethink saw coming ‘ the beginning of a complete hardware platform from Google, admittedly by proxy. Most importantly, this gives the Nest thermostat eyes inside the user’s home, in the form of cameras and the Bluetooth motion sensors in Dropcam’s Tabs.
The all-cash deal was announced in a statement from Nest co-founder Matt Rogers, who added ‘we care very deeply about helping people stay connected to their home, especially when they’re not in their home. This is another offering that helps people get insights into their home, from anywhere in the world. I can say without a doubt that Dropcam has the best products, services and customer experience in the business.’
Rogers also made it clear that the video data would not be shared with Google. On the news of the Nest buy-out, Rogers and co had to vehemently defend themselves against accusations of selling user’s thermostat data to Google. That underlying fear of Google seeing everything happening in a user home through the new cameras will have to be assuaged by Nest, and it is a question that will no doubt dog Rogers in his future public appearances.
To US this has the feel about it of smart home rivals Google and Apple swapping roles. Google, the software and internet giant, has charged into manufacturing its own hardware, while Apple has decided to go the software-only route with its HomeKit instead of sticking to its usual high-margin hardware-centric tactic. By imitating the business plan of the other and abandoning the historic pattern, are we seeing the confusion that exists over the correct way to approach the connected home?
So we have to ask why Google has chosen to go the hardware route? It may be due to the benefits of keeping development in-house, as Google and Nest would be able to exert complete control over the product and ecosystem. Apple’s ‘Made for iPhone’ certification provides a set of criteria that a device must achieve before it can win the MFi certification, but this approach leaves the aesthetic-conscious Apple completely out of the design process. Software-only means that Apple or Google would have to react to the market and forgo the option of directly influencing consumer behavior through hardware releases.
The benefits of offering the starter-kit of a thermostat, smoke alarm and security system allows Google to push a beginner’s Android Home package experience which can be dictated entirely by Google. The advantage of the software approach is the lack of capex and development costs, but this comes at the expense of design control – which is confusing given Apple’s rigid historical control over its products and design process.
Keeping the product line under the Nest umbrella looks like Google’s attempt at not alienating hardware partners as it managed when building its own smartphones. The other main benefit is using the friendly Nest branding to satisfy some consumer concerns about privacy and the monetization of the data their homes generate.
But back to the Dropcam purchase itself and what it brings to the Nest ecosystem. Dropcam’s origins can be traced to San Francisco in 2009, when cofounder Greg Duffy desired to find out which of his neighbors was letting their dogs foul on his yard. With the other half of the business, Aamir Virani, the pair quickly went from using off the shelf hardware and writing their own software to using in-house fabricated optics and custom designs.
Dropcam has previously raised $47.8 million in venture funding with $30 million in a round last July. There had been rumors last month about Google’s interest in Dropcam, which have now been validated.
Dropcam offers a $150 standard camera and a premium $200 camera (the Pro), which operate on the home WiFi network and require a power cable. In addition, Dropcam also has the Bluetooth-powered Tab, which is a motion sensor used to activate the Dropcam Pro. The Dropcams also have an activity recognition feature that is currently in beta trials, which analyses historic video footage to establish typical user patterns and behaviors. This then allows users to program alerts that they want to receive, such as children sitting down at a table, someone opening the fridge or if the dog has entered an off-limits room.
The software is almost certainly the primary target of the acquisition, as a wealth of alternative IP cameras are available on the market. This analytical functionality would provide the Nest thermostat with eyes into the home, which we feel is the main drive behind the acquisition ‘ an easy way to expand the Nest platform.
An established camera offering gives the previously blind Nest a much greater insight into user behavior, instead of guessing as best it could using its single motion sensor which requires a user to walk in front of it to register if the home has occupants.
The tabs will pair with any Dropcam Pro unit within a hundred feet, automatically connecting to whichever unit is in range. The system can then trigger push notifications to a user’s smartphone when a Tab is activated. Example use cases include tracking the openings of doors, windows and mailboxes, but also tracking pets and expensive items such as laptops. The main focus of this is to alert a user to unexpected activity and let them check out their home using the app and the Dropcams.
A public API beta test is currently being run by Dropcam, allowing third parties the chance to achieve interoperability with Dropcam if the company judges their work to be mutually beneficial. An example of such a system might be configuring a smart lighting system to the cameras and Tabs, allowing the Dropcam system to turn on the lights if detected by sight or motion ‘ for both legitimate occupants and middle-of-the-night security concerns.
The Dropcam business model differs from Nest, in that it sells hardware but also charges an optional subscription for varying levels of cloud storage. Importantly, the cameras offer free live streaming straight out of the box, but you have to pay to store any of the footage in the cloud as local storage is currently not a supported option.
Whether Nest chooses to use this business model as well remains to be seen, but we feel that the concern about user privacy would be lessened if users are still able to use only local storage instead of a cloud-based system, which many of the more paranoid users might think is more open to exploitation. One option that certainly seems possible is adding the Dropcam storage into a user’s Google Drive allowance (currently 15GBs for free), which is a pricing strategy not available to the lowly Dropcam, but certainly a possibility for the tech leviathan that is Google.
A new ‘Works with Nest’ label will be used to denote the products that can be integrated into a Nest-powered smart home, with partnerships including established home automation platform Control4, and new deals with Jawbone, Logitech, LIFX, Mercedes-Benz and Whirlpool. The new Nest API will be available to developers looking to meet the ‘Works with Nest’ certification. Users can also create If This Then That responses for actions in the home.
Over 5,000 developers have so far expressed an interest in the API, according to Nest. The program aims to extend control of the Nest ecosystem from the thermostat itself and the smartphone app out to wearables (Jawbone), cars (Mercedes and garage door manufacturer Chamberlain) and other home peripherals (Logitech).
While the project was announced in September, the developer portal has now launched, with one example implementation coming from LIFX, who have synced their WiFi light bulbs with the Nest smoke alarm to turn red and flash when the alarm is activated ‘ targeted at the hearing-impaired market.
But the most significant piece of Nest news that came out of Google’s I/O conference is that Nest now supports Google Now’s voice control, which will let users in the home speak commands to the thermostat as well as control it by voice via smartphone when away from home. Google seems to have beaten Apple to the punch with a demonstrable voice-controlled home and product line.