Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

24 July 2014

Netflix flies past 50 million, gains ally in Verizon dispute

Netflix is expanding in customers and revenue on all fronts as it posts strong Q2 results and passes the 50 million sub mark. Revenues were $1.34 billion, up from $1.27 billion in Q1 and $1.07 billion a year earlier, while net income has been rising faster, at $71.0 million, compared with $53.1 million in Q1 and $29.5 million in Q2 last year.

At the same time the company was buoyed on the domestic front as CDN provider Level 3 weighed in with support for Netflix in its ongoing and increasingly acrimonious dispute with Verizon over interconnection to the latter’s access network. There is no dispute now that lack of interconnect capacity rather than congestion on Verizon’s network has been causing poor streaming performance at some sites, for example in Los Angeles.

The question has been who is to blame, with Verizon at first suggesting that both Netflix and its IP transit providers such as Level 3 were at fault for failing to provide enough interconnect capacity, in the form of 10 Gbps Ethernet ports. Now Level 3 has come out and said this is nonsense, accusing Verizon of deliberately refusing to increase the capacity on the interconnect points. While other ISPs are able to increase capacity on demand according to Level 3, Verizon has blocked this and failed to cater for peaks in demand. This would be as simple as plugging in more cables between the relevant routers, said Mark Taylor, vice-president of content and media at Level 3.

Verizon declined to comment directly but referred to a recent blog that attempts to cast Level 3 rather than Netflix as the villain. Verizon accused Level 3 of attempting to hitch a ride over its network and ‘failing to keep the interest of their customers paramount.’ The blog contended that Verizon and Netflix have found a way to avoid the congestion problems that Level 3 is creating by its refusal to come up with ‘alternative commercial terms.’ It claimed that Verizon was ‘working diligently on directly connecting Netflix content servers into Verizon’s network so that we both can keep the interests of our mutual customers paramount.’

This contradicts what Netflix itself told us last week when a spokesperson stated that congestion at these interconnect point was controlled by ISPs like Verizon. Netflix insisted that neither itself nor its transit partners could do anything without Verizon’s cooperation. ‘When Verizon fails to upgrade those interconnections, consumers get a lousy experience despite paying for more than enough bandwidth to enjoy high-quality Netflix video,’ said the spokesperson. ‘That’s why Netflix is calling for strong net neutrality that covers the interconnection needed for consumers to get the quality of Internet they pay for.’

Resolving this little local difficulty may help Netflix recruit more US subscribers at a time when growth there has slowed, to the extent that it was overtaken by international for the first time in Q2. The company ended Q2 with 50.05 million members in 40 countries,1.69 million more than three months earlier and it now forecasts an accelerated rise to 53.74 million in Q3.

Of that 1.69 million subs growth, 1.22 million were international, which now accounts for 13.8 million members overall and is projected to reach 16.16 million in Q3. This highlights Netflix’ expectation that from now on, overseas streaming will account for the majority of its subscriber and revenue growth, as the OTT market is close to saturation domestically.

It is likely this trend will accelerate given that even after its impending September launch in Germany, France, Austria, Switzerland, Belgium and Luxembourg, with a combined total of 60 million broadband households, Netflix will still only be reaching about one third of global households, about 270 million out of 730 million. Admittedly it now reaches a higher proportion than that of affluent households, but there is plenty of scope for expansion across Asia and the Middle East.

It is worth noting that Netflix actually has three distinct markets, with a still healthy, if declining, business in DVD by mail in the US, beside the two principle sectors of domestic and international streaming. These all have distinctive characteristics, yet it could be said to be misleading to bracket the international markets into one when there are equally profound differences between them.

This is reflected in the fact that local content in each country now accounts for around 15% of total Netflix streaming output. Some markets pose greater challenges than others, France being a case in point where the coming of Netflix has provoked protectionist resistance. This has led to French culture minister Aur’lie Filippetti announcing a plan to reduce the time before films can be distributed on subscription VoD to 24 months after cinema release, rather than the current 36 months, but to restrict this just to services that sign up to the country’s system of financing French and European content.

Netflix has responded by insisting that it will not only contribute to production of French content, but also distribute it abroad and attempt to generate new revenues for the country’s struggling film industry. The hope is this charm offensive will enable Netflix to share the reduced window for SVoD movie release and also entice more early French members.

There is a clear, if inverse, link between Netflix’ international business and the domestic DVD business. The first is expanding and represents the company’s future, but is very expensive in terms of infrastructure, marketing and content development, while the DVD business is contracting but highly profitable, with virtually zero cost. Netflix has exercised some caution over its international expansion, having postponed it during 2012 to allow revenues to grow and offset costs. The rough rule now seems to be that Netflix launches in new markets once it approaches overall profitability with its existing international services.

Netflix came closer to breaking even internationally in Q2, with its loss there down to $15 million from $35 million in the first quarter. On this basis Netflix would make an international profit for the first time in Q4 if not Q3, but instead is likely to invest more money to enter new markets after getting going in those European countries in September. In this way the tantalizing international break-even point will continue to recede like the rainbow against Netflix’ ongoing advance. This is where the link with DVD comes in, since that has been generating a steady stream of painless cash that has been sunk in the international expansion.

In fact for the first time Netflix is now spending nothing at all on DVD marketing, having laid out just a nominal $292,000 during 2013. By comparison Netflix spent $65 million on stream marketing across both domestic and international in Q2 2014 alone.

Yet while Netflix has ceased marketing DVD it is absolutely wrong to consider that it is attempting to kill it off as some reports have suggested. It would be madness after all to murder a cash cow that is still generating over $350 million profit a year. Netflix has revealed that it had 6.26 million DVD subscribers at the end of Q2 2014 yielding $10 a month, half of which is profit. Furthermore the rate of decline is actually slowing, the loss of 400,000 over Q2 2014, being the lowest yet. At this rate DVD will still be a significant money earner for Netflix in five years’ time, so the strategy is to allow it to decline organically rather than hasten its demise.

The number is now down to a rump of subscribers who either are of a Luddite tendency or are simply sticking with DVD because the quality is better, noting the very poor average bit rates experienced by Netflix subscribers in the US of around 2 Mbps. It may well be that many of the DVD subscribers are in rural areas where fiber is not available and a long way from the nearest DSLAM so that they are unable even to stream Netflix consistently at standard definition.

Nevertheless Netflix’ domestic streaming business remains healthy overall and is getting more profitable all the time. This reflects the fact that while international expansion requires ongoing investment across marketing, infrastructure and content, on the domestic front there are a number of fixed costs that diminish per household as a proportion of ARPU as the subs base increases. Therefore the more US subs Netflix can get, the more profit each one generates, which internationally is only the case within specific markets and not overall so long as expansion continues. So cost of revenue per subscriber is on a steady downward curve in the US, standing at $63.44 for Q2 2014, compared with $63.61 for Q1 and $66.48 a year ago.

The only cloud on the horizon for Netflix is that a time will come when revenue growth slows on both the domestic and international fronts and it will run into that familiar problem facing all essentially one trick ponies with a single product. It will have to diversify and that will most likely involve moving into premium live and not just linear content, requiring another level of investment to acquire rights.

But that is for the future. In the present Netflix is sweeping all before it, claiming a scalp when Microsoft announced this week it was closing its Xbox Entertainment Studios as one of the first rationalization steps taken by new CEO Satya Nadella. That reflects Netflix own content strategy and expansion into original programming, which has raised the bar too high even for Microsoft.