Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

27 November 2014

Netflix French resistance comes from consumer lobby

Netflix has so far skipped neatly over all the French hurdles that have tripped up many lesser foreign invaders in what has become a minefield of bureaucracy and xenophobia, especially for US multinationals. To some extent Netflix has turned its French resistance to its advantage, gaining valuable publicity on the back of it during a well-organized marketing campaign ahead of its mid-September launch there.

It has succeeded in negotiating terms with the leading broadband providers except Free, after all had initially declined to come on board.  Bouygues Telecom was first to fall in line, offering the service from early this month. SFR then announced availability on its hybrid Android box combining DTT with Google TV as well as general OTT access. But the key move was an agreement with Orange to offer the video streaming service on its set tops from November, providing access to 10 million broadband subscribers.

These negotiations were described as tough by Orange chief executive Stephane Richard and involved Netflix conceding slightly better terms than to equivalent operators elsewhere. Typically Netflix offers around 10% of its revenues to ISPs for distributing its service, but in France the average amount is at least 25% and sometimes as much as a third. While the exact terms of its agreement with Orange were not disclosed it is a fair bet it was somewhere between these figures. It is notable that Free’s parent Iliad has stated that accepting the terms Netflix had put on the table did not make commercial sense, but then it does not have the clout Orange has.

So with the main broadband players on board and concessions with the French film and content production industry agreed, it looked at last as if Netflix had a clear ride in France. But then consumer organization CLCV (Consommation, logement et cadre de vie), announced it was suing Netflix on three counts, which came as a surprise in so far that it had earlier welcomed its entry on competition grounds. It is well known that the French pay TV industry has been controlled by a few powerful players which have levied higher subscription charges than neighboring countries, particularly for basic packages. This led CLCV to endorse Netflix’ entry as “entirely positive for the consumer”, expressing the hope that its subscription VoD service would stimulate competition and reduce prices in pay TV.

Against this background it looks like the CLCV’s litigation is based on pedantic adherence to the letter of consumer law rather than a volte face, with no great desire to impede Netflix. It is possible given the current French climate of hostility to US technology companies in general that some elements within CLCV jumped at the chance to toss a few rotten eggs towards Netflix.

CLCV’s first complaint is over a clause in which Netflix reserves the right to modify the terms of its contract without notifying customers. This, CLCV argues, contravenes the French law that companies must notify customers of any changes and give them the option to opt out without penalty in that event.

CLCV’s second complaint is that Netflix doesn’t guarantee the quality of service, which the group says means consumers cannot negotiate compensation or refunds if they are not satisfied. The argument here is that consumers have no yardstick upon which to base their complaint.

Finally CLCV highlights how some links of the pre-contractual information and conditions of use, relating mainly to information about gift subscriptions, copyright and intellectual property, are written in English or link to English pages, rather than being translated into French. This last complaint is a typical Gallic refrain, but one which Netflix can easily fix with the aid of Google Translate and a quick read through by one of its local legal staff. The first complaint is reasonable enough and again easily fixed.

The second complaint cannot be so directly addressed because there is no agreed yardstick for video QoS beyond bit rate, which is largely in the gift of the ISP. This has been a bone of contention between Netflix and ISPs elsewhere, especially in its home US market, where the likes of Verizon and AT&T had been accused of “standing on the hose”.

This was of course denied and the actual issue boiled down to the interconnect between the CDNs Netflix was using and the ISP access networks. Interconnection probably featured in the agreements between Netflix and the French ISPs, which may make the CLCV’s concerns over QoS somewhat irrelevant in the sense that the operator is doing what it can on a broader scale to address them. But then major US Internet companies are getting used to unreasonable and sometimes contradictory demands being imposed on them, as witnessed by the accusation in the UK that Facebook provided a safe haven for Fusilier Lee Rigby’s killers. Social media companies in particular are caught between the rock of law enforcement and the hard place of privacy advocacy – remember how Edward Snowden advised people to avoid Facebook because it was a “dangerous place”.

France is something of a special case with its unique combination of socialism and protectionism that has increasingly impeded enterprise in recent years. One of the ironies is that this has made its own industries less able to resist foreign invasion despite – or rather because of – the cultural and regulatory barriers imposed. France has a fine record in innovation and produced great technology companies like Thomson and Alcatel, but their stock has declined in recent years.

Rather than boosting its own base, the French government continues to waste its energies on defensive measures that are largely futile. Among its numerous assaults on Google, it is now threatening to levy a €1,000 penalty for every defamatory link the company fails to remove from its global network of Google subsidiaries. This is an attempt to capitalize further on Google’s  agreement earlier this year in Europe to remove links to articles that may be deemed “outdated and inflammatory”, in an extraordinary attempt to extend France’s writ to the whole world, since it would make Google’s French subsidiary responsible for the actions of sister and parent entities.

More specifically for Netflix, President Francois Hollande has called for a review of European laws on audiovisual services, which was seen as a direct response to Netflix’s arrival. As it is Netflix has to conform with restrictive French rules such as the 36 month window between theatrical movie release and online availability. Netflix also has to ensure that 40% of its programming is made in France, rather than the usual 20%, and has already commissioned a French version of House of Cards. Filmed  in Marseille, the eight-episode series in French and due to show next year depicts a vicious election battle between an ageing mayor, who has controlled the Mediterranean city for 25 years, and the young man he has chosen as his heir, but decides to challenge him, against a backdrop of corruption, violence and drug trafficking. To some it will seem eerily close to reality.

To pile on the irony Netflix cannot even show its original House of Cards in France, having sold the TV rights to Canal+, which is a direct competitor through its CanalPlay service.

But France has one of the highest levels of VoD consumption per head in the world, so with its strong catalog Netflix is actually well placed to thrive there. That is why it has been so willing to endure all the aggravations and insults to gain a foothold in that market, with now well over 100,000 subs.