Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

27 October 2011

Netflix ‘ learning to trust dumb, dumber and dumberer all over again

At Faultline we have been an unflagging supporter of Netflix and although its decision to increase prices and separate DVD online rental from streaming income was clearly mismanaged, we continue to see little but good eventually coming from the exercise, after an initial period when enraged customers cancel. But investors are having no truck with that version of events and after its numbers came out this week, the stock crashed once more, losing about a third of the share value in a few hours.

And once more no-one looked at the numbers or listened to the rhetoric, for one reason and one reason only, because Netflix once again had (slightly) underestimated the number of people that would cancel based on the price increase.

That miscalculation, albeit by a small margin, is a larger one in investor eyes. If the management was dumb enough to just go ahead and announce an across the board price increase, without testing the water with a survey of customers, then it’s dumb. And when it compounded that by changing the name of the DVD Online service to make customers visit two separate web sites, and that proved almost as unpopular with customers, it was shown to be ‘dumber’ still. Now the failure to fully predict that 800,000 customers would cancel makes it even ‘dumberer’ to follow the film analogy to the end.

But despite the Netflix management making some schoolboy errors, this is still a great business. It’s a bit like someone saying that because Facebook had less US users last month than the previous month (quite true) it is now worthless and on a slide like MySpace, which will inevitably end in no users. The fact that Facebook is integrated into every phone launched, argues against that, and the fact that Netflix is now embedded in hundreds of devices, argues in the same way.

But the words from the Netflix CEO Reed Hastings and CFO David Wells tell a complicated story, although one that can easily be modeled, so why can’t Wall Street manage that simple task? Simple, it can, but it is choosing to ignore the explanations of these two, based on the theory that once is an accident, twice is coincidence and a third mistake is enemy action, or in investment terms, a management team you simply no longer believe.

So what are they saying – there are some key statements in the Netflix Letter to Shareholders. The first are the numbers, the company now has 23.8 million US customers, not over 24 million. It lost 810,000 customers in one quarter. It said it would lose 500,000, give or take, although that was widely misreported as 1 million (which would mean it had done better than expected).

That comes from two figures that the management knows ‘ gross additions and cancellations, although they do not break them out separately. Gross additions are those new customers added irrespective of any who cancel.

As a result there has been a revenue rise from the global customer base, because of those price rises, up 4.2% sequentially to $822 million. Most of that came from the US. In the past four quarters revenues has risen 7.8%, 20.6%, 9.7% and now at 4.2%, this is the lowest growth rate.

There are also 1.48 million international customers also up by 510,000 with much of that down to Canada where there has been a 10% penetration of the 12.5 million Canadian households in just over 1 year. There are more international adds than in any other quarter, and given that Netflix will launch, as we always predicted it would, in the UK and Ireland in Q1 of 2012, and that it has already launched in 43 Latin American countries, which are still in ramp up phase, that number should grow radically in future quarters. If it grows just as fast in the UK as in Canada, a year from now it should have another 2.6 million homes signed up there.

The management pair also say that the company will remain profitable in Q4, but that due to expenditure launching in the UK, it will go in to a loss in Q1 and Q2 next year, before momentum rights the ship once more.

We can see the problem investors have with this, telling people that you will unprofitable is the easy part, but for a team that has messed up predictions ‘ what assurances do investors have that a return to profit will happen as predicted.

One thing that Netflix management were surprised about was the ‘PR storm’ created by their announcements. It was this that they said was responsible for a lowering in customer acquisitions during the last quarter. Of course that PR storm was created by their own actions, so it’s tough to blame the media.

Here’s another fact they gave us, that only 7% of new streaming subscribers also sign up for DVD as well. Which means the mix will change radically in favor of online streaming only, over a relatively short space of time. This makes for a more profitable business anyway.

There are more positive indicators in there for instance that subscriber acquisition costs have not gone up and that this is 24% lower than a year earlier at $15 each. And the fact that operating profit was $120 million and that this beat previous margins and came in at 15% of revenue is another good number.

On the subscriber front though, the predictions are a little less concrete. ‘Total unique US subscribers will be slightly up in Q4′, we’re not quite sure that’s a home run, because if streaming customers are down and DVD customers are down, it means there are more people paying $8 and fewer paying $16.

They openly admit that DVD subscriptions will fall further in Q4 but claim that the weekly rate of DVD cancellation is steadily shrinking, and are sure that in future quarters DVD revenues will shrink more slowly. But then why are streaming subs shrinking? Well it appears that some customers who took both services before, but who hardly used streaming, are just cancelling streaming, triggered by the price rise. This apparently peaked a few weeks ago and cancellations are steadily declining. This will make streaming additions negative in October, flat in November and strongly positive in December. But the December gains will not be big enough to suck up the October losses, so next quarter will be down overall (at which time investors will, once again shed the stock, and create more negative PR which will feed the downward spiral).

Underneath this is the single most important fact that there is year on year growth in weekly gross additions. So as soon as the bulk of cancellations get out of the Netflix system, the rate at which the company will grow will be even faster than before? But this assumes that more and more people won’t hear through word of mouth that customers departing Netflix and using say Hulu Plus or some other service, find that this is more than a good enough replacement. Netflix is flying on word of mouth recommendation, so it could fall the same way.

Other less important data is that streaming hours are climbing. This may create more in ISP peering costs but mostly indicates that the content strategy is working and people are happier and happier using the services. Netflix says that contribution from streaming was 8% in the quarter, and the slow rise in streaming numbers leads the management to predict that each quarter the contribution margin will go up by 100 basis points (1%). So assume static next quarter, up to 9% in Q1, 10% in Q2 etc’

But finally the most important part of the shareholder letter is to realistically appraise its rivals. Netflix still says that cable TV Everywhere strategies are its biggest threat (well not if cable ARPU continues to rise and there is more cord cutting) but also lists all its new exclusive deals with Dreamworks, Open Road, CW and AMC and expanded deals for TV shows with ABC, NBC Universal, Fox, CBS, Viacom, PBS and Sony Pictures Television. Basically it is saying that it has an improving set of exclusive movies and the best line up of prior season TV, even if it cannot compete on current season TV content, where customers are clearly going to Hulu Plus. It has also begun its PR war against Starz which it says is less than 10% of the hours viewed by existing customers. In fact Starz fuels about 6% of Netflix hours and only when you add in the Sony movies which have already been pulled, does it comes close to 10% of viewing.

In an analysis of Amazon Prime available content Netflix points out that not only does it already have all of that content but also that it takes up only 2% of Netflix viewing. This doesn’t count the content that is on Amazon, but which is NOT free even when you pay for Amazon Prime.

The company has many missteps available to it, and only some of them happen simply because of a skill set that Hastings and Wells don’t appear to have, and that’s predicting how upset customers are with them. It may not acquire customers fast enough in the UK and Ireland, it may see the slowing of cancellations a little too optimistically, and it may have little understanding of saturation points for this type of service in each of its territories. Prediction of those items could all elude a team that has made three major missteps already.

But signing more and more original content, and renewing new content deals for the future and across a wider range of territories, can only demonstrate upside for Netflix in the long run. A year from now we will all be laughing about this, but in the coming three quarters, the uncertainty that surrounds the errors of the Netflix leadership, will continue to dog the company’s share price.