Verizon has sent Netflix a cease and desist letter after images surfaced of a Netflix buffering screen which said ‘The Verizon network is crowded right now. Adjusting video for smoother playback.’ The letter threatens legal action should Netflix continue to display the message to its customers, even as part of the Trial which Netflix was conducting.
‘There is no basis for Netflix to assert that issues with respect to playback are attributable solely to the Verizon network,’ claimed the ISP. However, Netflix’s own data suggests a different story:
Here we can see that AT&T, Comcast and Verizon all sharply declined in October 2013, at a rate that differs significantly from rivals Cox, Cablevision and Google Fiber. Netflix has just released the May rankings, which show that Verizon FiOS has fallen to 10th and Verizon’s DSL offering is in 16th place ‘ last place among the largest ISPs. FiOS only manages an average connection speed of 1.9Mbps, the same as the DSL offerings from Frontier and Windstream. Cablevision is in first place with 3.03Mbps.
It’s hard to point at any specific issue that could cause the likes of Comcast, AT&T and Verizon’s service to all begin falling in October 2013. After all, the companies were posting healthy profits, suggesting that capital was available to improve the service if increased consumption was the issue at hand. The smaller ISPs have continued to provide an increased service, keeping up with consumer demand, so why can’t the larger providers?
Netflix said that the move was intended to increase transparency for consumers, largely trying to shift the blame from poor quality video services from the Netflix brand to the ISP. Verizon contends that the messages could damage Verizon’s business. Well the slow speeds could damage the Netflix business. Touch’.
‘This could cause a customer to think any attempted viewing of a video would yield a similarly ‘crowded’ experience. It is sad that Netflix is willing to deliberately mislead its customers so they can be used as pawns in business negotiations and regulatory proceedings.’
Our own opinion at Faultline is that it is sad that Verizon resorts to slowing down traffic from a company that it mistakenly perceives as a rival. It’s an open and shut case. If the FCC investigates and finds that these companies slowed down Netflix traffic arbitrarily because it is a rival, then there’s a good chance that it would impose hefty fines. Comcast might be seen to be in breach of assurances that it made when it acquired NBC.
The on-screen message came after Netflix signed a deal with Verizon to cache Netflix content inside the Verizon network ‘ a similar deal to the one signed between Netflix and Comcast in January. If you look at the Netflix graph again, you’ll notice that Comcast’s performance nosedived in October and rapidly recovered immediately after the January deal. We suspect that a very similar graph will appear come the next Netflix ISP review ‘ with the Verizon performance rapidly increasing.
This is because the move by Netflix is almost certainly an attempt by the OTT provider to force the ISP to boost its delivery performance. Netflix signed that caching agreement on the assumption that performance would improve. The public shaming of Verizon shows that this expected improvement hasn’t happened, and it is an attempt by Netflix to lay the blame where it is due and protect the brand’s reputation.
It should be noted that Verizon has plans to launch a video service. It has its FiOS TV service, but has also acquired the Intel OnCue project, which had worked on an OTT TV service, but failed due to difficulty securing content deals. Netflix is a large competitor in this sphere, one that Verizon is legally bound to cater for on its broadband network. Besmirching the Netflix brand and then launching a rival service might have been a long term market impact.
For Netflix, this is an issue of net neutrality. The Verizon customers have paid to receive data packets over a network that doesn’t discriminate against origin or grant preferential treatment. The nosedives seen in the graphs seem to support a lot of rumors in the industry that the larger ISPs have been actively throttling Netflix rather than traffic in general.
While the net neutrality argument rumbles on in the US, Netflix has been forced to sign its Comcast agreement. This semi-public shaming of Verizon’s performance is simply an attempt by Netflix to get its money’s worth out of the Verizon deal ‘ a deal that many would argue it shouldn’t have had to make.