Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

20 October 2011

Netgem kicks off season of Q3 results with sharp decline

If the set top market is a bell weather for the pay TV sector as a whole the message is usually rather cryptic. There are vast discrepancies between the various sectors defined by geography and transmission medium, while even individual figures for specific vendors are not always what they seem.

We are now entering the season of third quarter results for 2011. French set top maker Netgem was among the first to declare with appalling sounding results for the three months ending September 30th as consolidated revenues slumped by over 50% to €16.2 million from €32.9 million over Q3 2010. The full nine monthly figures for 2011 so far were not much better, down 45% from €107.1 million to €59.4 million.

Such numbers will not be replicated by the set top sector as a whole as results filter in over the next 10 days or so, and reflect Netgem’s reliance on the unique French IPTV market. Strangely though, as we search for the silver lining of Netgem’s particular cloud, we cannot find much immediate solace in recent data on the French IPTV market. This is still growing, according to the French telecom regulator Arcep, with 11.05 million subscribers, even if this is now a declining proportion of the world’s 50 million IPV subscribers.

Netgem can though point to a strategic shift in the rather saturated French IPTV market caused by the tablet and connected TV proliferation, along with arrival of OITT players such as Google and Apple. Indeed the writing was on the wall in France even during 2010 when Netgem was doing well overall, when French sales declined 24% compared with 2009. But now Netgem has caught a cold on the international front as well, with seven fold growth from 2009 to 2010 followed by a 7% decline in the first nine months of 2011 from €32.5 million to €30.4 million, accelerating into a 46% slump by the third quarter.

Fortunately Netgem does have a coherent strategy for revival, having identified the urgent need for a change in tack from its 2010 domestic decline. The idea was to turn its set top into a media server operating as a hub within a home based multimedia cloud delivering content to connected devices in the home. This is executed by Netgem’s nCloud platform, focused particularly on tablets, with a Software Development Kit (SDK) for third parties to develop Apps. The main selling points are price, since operators do not need to invest in external cloud infrastructures, and security, since consumers’ data is confined within the home. This has led to a couple of customer gains, Monaco Telecom, and P&T Luxembourg, and looks like it will at least slow Netgem’s precipitous descent during the year’s final quarter. But whether this transition from being a set top box maker to more of a middleware vendor has come in time to arrest the fall altogether remains to be seen.

For the rest of the set top market the third quarter results look like being rather anti-climactic, no doubt with a few exceptions, but mostly marking time for greater turmoil to come. For example there is great interest in the outcome of Motorola Mobility’s acquisition by Google, turning the latter at a stroke into the world’s second biggest set top maker by volume, but as this has yet to be finally ratified by shareholders in a vote on November 17th, it will not register on Q3 results.

The vote however is almost a foregone conclusion given the money available at a time of uncertainty in the set top market. Google tabled its $12.5 billion offer for Motorola Mobility in August 2011, little over six months after Motorola’s split into two parts, Motorola Mobility Holdings including set tops and smart phones, and Motorola Solutions focusing on enterprise products and services. Since these two entities are already better known by their acronyms, MMH and MMI, we are witnessing the end of the Motorola brand, once a byword for consumer electronic quality.

For Google the takeover can be seen as an admission that its Google TV has totally failed to gain the expected traction, with the set tops now perhaps being prepared as the Trojan horse to deliver the previously unwanted service into TV homes. Google is unlikely to leave the set top division as a separate hardware maker since this would be quite inconsistent with its strategy, so instead it will use it to shift its Google TV box with a focus on becoming an innovator in the field.

The impact this will have on major rivals is unclear, notably Pace given the head to head nature of their competition. In the short to medium term it is likely to give Pace a boost because Motorola Mobility has been particularly strong in the cable TV sector where operators are not likely to welcome the prospect of intrusion from Google peddling an advertising model that undermines their business. Codec makers won’t like it either, since Google is promoting WebM, the audio-video encoding and compression format that is supposedly at least free of the royalties associated with MPEG2 and MPEG4, which dominate pay TV.

The mood at Pace therefore has picked up after the partly self-inflicted wounds that cut into the company late in the spring. This highlighted how headline results can be deceptive, since Pac e had just overtaken Motorola Mobility as the world number one set top maker in volume. But the fact Motorola Mobility was still top in revenue holds a clue here since it appeared Pace had achieved its volume gain by cutting margins to the bone. The volume end of the market is never a comfortable place to be for long in any technological sector, and this was reflected in considerable internal confusion and turmoil at Pace culminating in the profit warning in May 2011 that precipitated an immediate 40% fall in share price.

Since then Pace has steadied the ship and will probably post a decent set of figures for 2011 including retention of its number one volume spot, with immediate prospects of further gains from Motorola. Pace already numbers Comcast, DirecTV and AT&T among its customers, respectively among the largest in the world for cable, satellite and IPTV. The company is at least still on track to meet the revised profit target for 2011 of $150 to $170 million as opposed to the original $200 million plus forecast made at the start of the year.

But Google’s presence is a threat in the longer term if this time it gets its TV strategy right, and Pace will need to accelerate its move into more value added software and services territory, while continuing to focus on high end set top s or DVRs.

Meanwhile French based Technicolor, the third biggest set top player, is also seeing margins squeezed although to a lesser extent than Pace. The company is waiting for new service launches from some of its operator customers in 2012 to ease a tightening on its margins by creating demand for new higher value hybrid and gateway boxes.

Technicolor operates in most set top sectors but is particularly strong in satellite TV where it vies with EchoStar for number one spot. EchoStar though is more closely aligned with satellite given its origins as a spin out from US satellite operator Dish Networks and is focusing on enabling hybrid services through its ownership of Slingbox and Move Networks. Slingbox enables place shifting of content either within or especially outside the home, over the Internet, while Move Networks’ adaptive streaming technology dovetails with this to facilitate higher QoS.

One of the larger subplots will be how competition between EchoStar and Technicolor pans out in the hybrid satellite set top and gateway sector. Technicolor does look vulnerable given its reliance on relatively few large customers, including DirecTV, and in Europe UPC Broadband and News Corporation. This in turn has generated healthy business among these companies’ affiliates, such as DirecTV Latin America, Sky Brazil and Sky Mexico, along with BSkyB in the UK.

But these large companies invariably have at least one alternative supplier, which then has the chance to prize business away through innovation or price cutting. In the case of DirecTV, Pace has been getting under Technicolor’s skin, having installed its HR34 server as the central hub of DirecTV’s Home Media Center being launched this month. This features DirecTV’s RVU technology, designed to map pay TV services on a pixel by pixel basis onto secondary TVs. Technicolor is also a member of the RVU Alliance set up by DirecTV, so will be disappointed to lose out to Pace in this critical area.

The other member of the big four, Cisco, vying for third spot with Technicolor, is in a different position from the others, at least until Google’s impending acquisition of Motorola Mobility, in not being so dependent on set top revenue. set tops only accounted for around 2% of its $43.2 billion revenue for its year ending July 31st 2011, and as for Google now are subservient to a larger strategy.

Like the others Cisco had issued a rosy forecast for 2011 based on the assumption of a global rebound from earlier recession, and so has been confounded by the approach of a second dip in the US and key European markets. This has led to rumors Cisco may pull out of set tops altogether, fuelled by the sale of an set top factory in Mexico. But this looks unlikely for two reasons. Firstly set tops are still doing well for Cisco, which remains number one in IP set tops and number two to Motorola Mobility in cable TV where it is storming on DOCSIS 3.0 based gateways. Secondly and more importantly set tops have a key role to play in Cisco’s Videoscape platform to combine IPTV and OTT services.

Beyond the big four Swiss owned ADB has been one of the most innovative players gaining ground by focusing strongly on hybrid boxes for satellite, cable and terrestrial in various combinations with IP. The company entered 2011 with high hopes of achieving 40% growth on its 2010 revenues of $356.6 million to consolidate its position as the best of the rest, but also found the going tough and had to scale this forecast down to just 15% at the half year mark.

Like others ADB is trying to reposition itself as a value added provider, having launched its Services Division earlier in the year. ADB is at least still growing faster than most of its rivals and will hope to capitalize on the uncertainty surrounding some of their strategies.