Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

6 February 2014

New Microsoft’s CEO looks to be more of the same

How do you gauge the future strategic direction of Microsoft with its new CEO in place. Does it remain focused on the old Wintel alliance which defined the PC era, or will it broaden with its acquisition of Nokia’s handset division in a mobile giant, can it rekindle its gaming or TV ambitions, or will it re-focus on the cloud, an area it has performed well in so far?

Intel also engaged in a long search for a new CEO, and like Microsoft it failed to attract, or perhaps trust, new blood, and ended up promoting a long-time veteran who’s qualifications lay in the cloud arena. Despite the same being true of Intel’s Intel’s Brian Krzanich, he has taken the mobile bull by the horns. So what will Microsoft’s new CEO, Satya Nadella do?

It’s too late for Nadella to rebuild Mediaroom, a business that never turned a profit and which put Microsoft in the awkward position of not chasing Apple into being loved by consumers. It was sold last year. The focus there was helping Telcos take on emerging cable operators by adding the video equation. It was more successful for companies like AT&T and Deutsche Telekom than it was for Microsoft, in effect doing those operators favors, while they remained closer to traditional equipment suppliers like Alcatel.

Microsoft’s gaming ambitions have been thwarted in much the same way ‘ never consistently profitable – all the Xbox has done is prevent Sony from dominating consoles ‘ now the console is seen more as an in-home video server, and most games have been imbued with a touch capability as Microsoft and Sony, along with Nintendo, have all lost ground not to Apple, but to app providers on Apple’s App store, and even those on Google Play. Gaming has simple moved into the mobile arena, and chances are that video will move there too, leaving the consoles floundering and taking on unwelcome challenges like providing the excessive decode power needed for 4K files and streams, within handfuls of pioneering homes.

Nadella has been employed at Microsoft for 22 of his 46 years, he moves from his current position as EVP of the cloud and enterprise group. This seems to indicate that the Redmond giant’s priority has been to consolidate its strengths in that area and make cloud leadership its number one goal. Certainly, that will be an easier path than transforming the company’s fortunes in the mobile and ‘post-PC’ spaces, where outgoing CEO Steve Ballmer ‘ like his Intel counterpart Paul Otellini ‘ is likely to look back on his greatest mistakes.

But in our mind another of his greatest mistakes was to keep Microsoft with the operator side of video for so long and to spend so much money on building out its console business and adding video to what is an unprofitable, hardware based backwater.

The cloud gives Microsoft the only clear way forward, combined with Nokia for the device side of the business ‘ video and game cloud services talking to thin cheap clients, that can also do enterprise work – sounds wonderful, but it’s not what we expect out of Microsoft, it is more what we have come to expect from Amazon, Google and the Android community and from smaller efforts like the Nook from Barnes and Noble, and Sony’s Gaikai.

To be honest what Microsoft should be aspiring to is simplifying Windows 8 into Windows 9, until it looks more like Android, fixing its Internet Explorer browser, so that it has some modern features and better performance, oh yes and adheres to the Mozilla specification more slavishly, and create an irresistibly cheap software layer that attracts the likes of Samsung and HTC, or gives loyal companies like Hewlett Packard, the possibility of competing effectively with those companies. The problems of the past is that Microsoft wanted the answer to everything to be the Windows it already had, rather than a new operating system called Windows being built to be the answer to everything.

An in-house man is hardly likely to understand that and one extreme view will be that Microsoft will succumb to calls from some shareholders to break up the group, putting the mobile, embedded and consumer activities into more specialized hands and spinning them off. That would mean putting Xbox in with Nokia, and tablets in a separate home from Windows 8. Isn’t that where Nokia came in?

Fans of this approach argue it could double the value of the remaining company. Yes, but for how long? We have to look to how IBM went from dominance of hardware in a free software world, to dominance of the top 100 global accounts, by embracing services. It did this under a new CEO who came out of Nabisco of all places, in the 1980s. and has never looked back.

But at the time IBM was in trouble ‘ both financial, with its revenues falling, and on the stock market, with its shares in free fall and that’s not really true yet of Microsoft, which continues to squeeze profits out of its PC and server sectors, and will likely continue to do so for some time.

There is some logic to Microsoft removing the dead hand of its PC, server and cloud divisions from the device end, but then what was the point of merging with them in the first place?

Assuming Microsoft hangs onto all of its businesses, Nadella will need to lay out a clear strategy and take some brave decisions, and he needs a structure that will allow some strong voices outside of the Windows, Server and Cloud areas, because them telling the mobile and gaming world what to think and do, is a little like buying a dog and barking yourself. Bringing Stephen Elop back into the fold would also be a major mistake, since he brought that attitude to Nokia, focusing on operating system dominance at a time when the UI was all important. In truth he never really left Microsoft and contains no views from outside of it.

And then there is the continued influence of Bill Gates and Steve Ballmer, who are major shareholders and board members. Gates is replaced as chairman by John Thompson, who headed the CEO search process and was formerly head of Symantec. But the Microsoft co-founder becomes a technology adviser to Nadella, probably spending more time in Redmond than he has for years. Gates’ reputation as a programmer is largely fake, and he was supposed to be technical, but never really was. He will provide little more than aggravation to Nadella, and brings old ideas now largely out of date, Ballmer even more so.

Their advice will be to make everything Windows and sell, sell, sell and don’t listen to those Nokia guys or the people who run Xbox.

Nadella is compromised by the way he was brought up to see technology. Talk to a modern cloud guy, they ignore all hardware issues, they think only in terms of internet protocols and they innovate, innovate, innovate. Perhaps, given that Nadella ran the cloud division, he thinks this way. In which case how did IBM and Amazon steal a march on his division. In short we can see no good news on the Horizon for Microsoft, but then again there hasn’t been any for the past ten years.