All we hear from US operators and regulators is that the country faces a ‘spectrum famine’ and must find huge amounts of new radio waves to support exploding mobile broadband. Yet the carriers ‘ established or new ‘ pass up perfectly usable frequencies time after time. Clearwire failed to find a buyer at an attractive price for its excess 2.5GHz licenses; TerreStar’s mobile satellite frequencies went to Dish Network uncontested by any cellco; now NextWave Wireless is only just fending off the bankruptcy courts, having repeatedly failed to offload its own extensive licenses for a decent sum.
There are many factors at work. Mobile satellite spectrum for LTE enjoyed a vogue when the FCC green lighted LightSquared’s plans, but is currently under a cloud, at least until that operator can address interference issues with GPS. And operators are currently obsessed with sub-1GHz frequencies, which can support relatively quick and cheap first wave LTE roll-outs because of their long range and good indoor penetration. This has made them cool towards higher bands such as 2.5GHz (held by Clearwire and NextWave). Other elements are important. One, the carriers leading the push to 4G have significant existing spectrum holdings, which they can re-farm for LTE before they need to invest in further licenses. Verizon is the most extreme example, along with AT&T’s key motive for acquiring T-Mobile US. And all the operators are focusing on flexible infrastructure programs, like Sprint’s Network Vision, that allow them to run multiple air interfaces and switch between them almost at will. Two, there is the alluring prospect of integrating unlicensed (free) spectrum into the 4G plan, with more sophisticated adoption of Wi-Fi offload, harnessing of white spaces and other low cost ways to increase wireless capacity and put off spending on new spectrum. Three, the 2.5GHz band is almost entirely TDD-based (though Clearwire claims it has sufficient bandwidth to run paired channels anyway), and TD-LTE is not yet a mature technology, while WiMAX is not favored outside Sprint in the US.
All this has created a counter-intuitive hostility to bands of 2GHz and above, which could prove very shortsighted. The rise in mobile data usage means that all the cellcos will need more capacity quite soon, and their first stage LTE roll-outs will need to be followed, in short order, by significant second phases to supplement their data capabilities. At that point, the 2.5GHz band becomes highly desirable, well suited as it is, to dense urban capacity. Operators may be hoping that, when the time comes, they will be able to acquire these frequencies cheaply ‘ piecemeal from the many small holders in the band, or dramatically by bidding for Sprint, Clearwire or whichever combination is holding the 2.5GHz cards by 2013 or so.
If they are just turning a blind eye to the higher frequencies, a new report from Credit Suisse should open their eyes. It finds that US wireless networks are operating at 80% of total capacity, the highest figure in the world, which will necessitate urgent increases in investment in networks and in spectrum. Author Jonathan Chaplin wrote: “We think this is generally supportive of our view that carrier spectrum will be rapidly consumed and that spectrum assets are generally undervalued.’
According to the report, peak network utilization rates worldwide are 65% and will reach 70% over the next year. Based on a survey of 38 major operators, it calculated that 23% of base stations round the world have capacity constraints (based on utilization rates of more than 80% in busy hours), up from 20% last year. In the US, the percentage has risen from 26% to 38% in the same period. That will necessitate higher investment in network capacity ‘ globally, carriers expect to spend 6% more on RANs than they had predicted at the start of the year, despite falling kit prices. On average, tier one cellcos in developed economies expect RAN capex to be up by 10% year-on-year in 2011 and 16% in 2012.
“Wireless capex expectations may need to increase longer term,” said Chaplin. “Many investors seem to expect capital intensity to start to decline in 2012 once LTE spending is largely complete. Investors may be underestimating the level of equipment spending that is required on an ongoing basis to support rapid growth in wireless data.”
NextWave will be hoping that operators come to that realization sooner rather than later. It seems that the firm’s rollercoaster history may be coming to an end at last, with the firm warning this week that it had been unable to renegotiate the terms of its debt with lenders. Although it did later secure a limited waiver on its obligations to repay $129 million of secured debt, this only lasts until August 1. Failure to reach a settlement within the next two weeks could force a filing for bankruptcy protection ‘ and another interesting spectrum sale, hard on the heels of Dish Network’s purchase of TerreStar’s mobile satellite licenses, also from the bankruptcy process.
NextWave is remembered by many for being spun out of Qualcomm and then buying $4.7 billion worth of PCS licenses in 1996, failing to pay more than the $500 million down payment, and haggling with the FCC for years from within Chapter XI bankruptcy protection. Although the regulator reclaimed the licenses, NextWave secured a court order to reclaim them, and sold most of its PCS assets itself, largely to Verizon. However, it retained extensive holdings in 2.5GHz and 2.3GHz and also acquired more in the AWS auctions. It then sought to build up a spectrum-to-equipment play in WiMAX with a series of acquisitions, including IPWireless and PacketVideo, but overstretched itself financially and sold off everything except most of the spectrum assets.
It has been trying to sell many of those but has had limited success, despite the much vaunted ‘spectrum famine’ in the US. Like Clearwire, which also cancelled plans to sell off some of its 2.5GHz licenses, NextWave may have come up against hostility to high frequency spectrum, which has challenges in terms of range and indoor penetration ‘ though is often ideal for dense urban metrozones. In addition, the 2.3GHz band in the US is split in two, limiting capacity and raising interference issues.
Now its licenses could come up for sale at more attractive terms ‘ according to a filing with the SEC on Monday, NextWave is considering bankruptcy. It wrote: ‘As previously disclosed, NextWave’s cash reserves are not sufficient to meet these payment obligations.’ In the event of a default, ‘the holders of the secured notes could proceed against the assets pledged to collateralize these obligations, including all of NextWave’s domestic wireless spectrum assets. These conditions raise substantial doubt about NextWave’s ability to continue as a going concern. Inability to obtain a forbearance agreement, and ultimately a refinancing transaction or maturity extension, would significantly restrict the Company’s ability to operate and could cause it to seek relief through a filing in the United States Bankruptcy Court.’
Although operators may be unwilling to pay high prices for spectrum above 2GHz – which carries higher roll-out costs for mobile broadband than the sub-1GHz bands everyone is chasing ‘ this remains a strong base for a data network, as Clearwire shows. With mobile satellite bands currently perceived as high risk after the GPS interference issues that are dogging LightSquared, players who need more 4G capacity may look again at NextWave.