Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

25 October 2006

Nokia put to shame by Sony Ericsson in battle for margins

The top five handset makers continue to strengthen their hold on the sector, at the expense of midrange players, but they face their own battle to strike a balance between market share and margin. Announcing third quarter results, Nokia seemed to have veered too far towards share, while Sony Ericsson boomed on its focus on high end models.

Motorola saw a sharp profits drop that reflects its urgent need for new networks to come onstream, and its continuing over-dependence on Sprint Nextel, even as its iconic RAZR phone and its offshoots continue to drive progress. These three, plus Samsung and LG, are stealing more and more total share from smaller vendors such as the struggling Siemens/BenQ, though there is growth at the other end of the scale for white label manufacturers.

But much of the growth opportunity for cellular handsets lies in emerging markets, and this puts pressure on margins. Nokia’s net income fell by 4.1% in Q3, despite a sharp rise in revenue and cellphone shipments. It shipped 88.5 million handsets in the third quarter compared with 66.6 million units a year earlier, but the average selling price fell from €102 to €93 ($122 to $112).

Nokia reported net income of €845 million ($1.06 billion), compared with €881 million a year earlier. Sales rose 20% to €10.1 billion but, adjusting for exceptional items, group operating margin fell to 12.2% from 12.6%.

Nokia’s CEO Olli-Pekka Kallasvuo said the strong growth in entry level phones coupled with a lower percentage of sales in higher end products impacted Nokia’s margins.

Taking a longer term view, of course, this should be setting the Finnish giant up for strong market share in key markets like India, where rapid economic growth in many regions should lead in the five-year timespan to strong upgrade demand for more expensive phones.

But the short term impact on margins in the largest business unit, Mobile Phones, worried shareholders, even while it was balanced somewhat by strong performance in Nokia’s two advanced device divisions, the focus of many of its growth plans – the Multimedia unit, which sells advanced media devices, saw sales rise 45% year-on-year to €2.09 billion; while Enterprise Solutions sales advanced 27% to €257 million. Sales at the Mobile Phones unit rose 14% to €5.95 billion. This shows that Nokia is weakest in the midrange sector, a fact that Kallasvuo acknowledged in an analyst call. ‘The product portfolio needs continued improvements. We’re making those improvements,’ he said. He raised Nokia’s full year forecast for the global mobile phone market to 970 million units, from around 915 million, which would represent year-on-year growth of 22%. He also forecast that Nokia’s Q4 shipments would be up 15% on Q3’s 243 million, keeping the company’s market share stable around 36%.

One of Nokia’s key aims in the coming quarters is to wrest back the US number one spot from Motorola, and it will have taken some hope from a patchy performance from its main rival. Motorola reported a 45% decline in profit amid disappointing handset sales, which fell 1.3 million units short of its goal of shipping 55 million units in the quarter, and will need to act quickly to see off an expected major challenge in Q4 from Nokia’s revamped line-up, especially its N Series of music and media phones. Motorola posted net income of $968 million, down from $1.75bn a year earlier, when it benefited from the sale of Nextel stock and tax benefits.

Excluding gains and charges, Motorola posted earnings of 34 cents a share, in line with analysts’ estimates. Revenue rose 17% to $10.6 billion from $9.05 billion, but fell short of Wall Street expectations. Motorola partly blamed a slowdown in demand for iDEN handsets, used by Nextel, and is looking to its imminent shipment of dual-mode iDEN/CDMA phones as one of its recovery ploys for Q4. Along with the huge significance of winning the contract – with Samsung – to build Sprint Nextel’s 2.5GHz WiMAX network, this factor illustrates the vendor’s continuing reliance on its largest customer.

The other main area of concern was the infrastructure business, especially in the EMEA and Asia regions. With many providers winding down spending on GSM and moving to 3G, and with Motorola weak in UMTS, it faces a dangerously long hiatus period before its hoped-for sales of WiMAX equipment, its main strategy for compensating for 3G failures, kick in.

Although Motorola has several large contracts, serious spending will not be seen until 2008. Apart from these weak spots, the RAZR continues to drive healthy handset performance. Motorola increased its global market share to 22.4% from 22.1% though it is cautious about Q4 projections, saying it expects to generate revenue of $11.8 billion to $12.1 billion in the fourth quarter, compared with Wall Street’s forecast of $12.1 billion. However, as Motorola lowers the average selling price of the RAZR and repositions it in the midrange, to make way for new high end models like KRZR, there are fears that it will lose its magic.

The Q enterprise smartphone has had disappointing impact so far and faces tough competition from Nokia, while some new high end consumer handsets have been criticized for being too similar to RAZR – especially now that other rivals also have ultraslim models, such as the LG Chocolate (though Nokia does not).

Ericsson also saw mixed results, but not because of handsets, with its Sony joint venture one of its key growth engines in the quarter. Net profits were up 17% but sales rose less than analysts had hoped, by 13%. However, Sony Ericsson saw its volumes rise by a huge 43% year-on- year, to top 20 million units, and overtook LG once again for fourth position in the world market.

Ericsson CEO Carl-Henric Svanberg said a strong Q4 would more than make up for an uninspiring Q3. ‘Q4 should not only be stronger than normal but will also make up a bit for the third quarter,’ he told analysts, with some large UMTS and GSM orders raising hopes. For instance, Cingular published a glowing report on its 3G roll-out last week, and Ericsson recently won the lion’s share of a massive GSM contract with India’s BSNL.

Over at Samsung, the company reported a 16% increase in third quarter profits, based on strong sales of its new line of high end Ultra Edition phones. Samsung sold 30.7 million mobile phones in the quarter, a record for the company. Meanwhile, LG has unveiled the successor to its Chocolate ultraslim handset, which was the chief driver of the Korean company’s better than expected third quarter profits. LG expects to sell 6 million Chocolates this year and will ship the new model towards year end.

It surprised analysts with a profit, mainly from improvement in its mobile handset division, but warned that revenues in the fourth quarter may fall by as much as 12% compared to Q3. Sales of LG handsets rose by 5.3% during the third quarter to reach 2.126 trillion won in value and the company announced an operating profit of 79 billion won, compared to a loss of 3.5 billion won in the second quarter. Total phone shipments were up 8% compared to the previous quarter and 7% year-on-year to reach 18.5 million, 10.5 million of them in CDMA, 5.6 million in GSM and 500,000 for W-CDMA. Sales were particularly strong in North America and Korea, led by Chocolate. Overall, the mobile communications division reported sales up 4.7% on the second quarter and down 9.7% from one year ago.