As happens so often when you ask the question, how are these two small fry going to survive, they up and merge. It’s hard to think of any part of Siemens and Nokia as being small fry, but both of them have nursed their respective network equipment divisions through a hellish past five years, trying to keep the capability to hand. The merger announced this week seems to just about achieve this.
Nokia has always said that its ability to build cellular networks went hand in hand with its handsets, and it needed more scale to compete with both Ericsson and Motorola. Siemens has already got out of handsets, selling off that division to BenQ, and network equipment on its own has never recovered the kind of pricing it had pre-2001 especially while it has to compete with new aggressive Asian suppliers such as China’s Huawei.
For Faultline readers this could well empower an invigorated IPTV effort from Siemens, through Nokia’s well established Far East channels pushing the Surpass and Myrio IPTV system that has done so well to stave off Microsoft and Alcatel at Belgacom and KPN.
The combined company would have revenues of around $15.8 billion and it merges Nokia, almost entirely in mobile networks with the part of Siemen’s that was almost entirely successful in fixed networks. Naturally the talk had to be about fixed mobile convergence, and the quadruple play.
The company will be a 50-50 jointly owned venture made up of Nokia’s Networks Business Group and Siemens’ carrier-related operations for fixed and mobile networks, it starts life with 60,000 employees and it should save around €1.5 billion ($1.8 billion) in costs annually by 2010 by merging various HQ functions, which will no doubt mean losing some of those staff.
The move is one of the first by new Nokia CEO Olli-Pekka Kallasvuo, and if that’s his style we should expect fireworks over the coming years.
He said, ‘The communications industry is converging, and a strong and independent Nokia Siemens Networks will be ideally positioned to help customers lower costs and grow revenue while managing the challenges of converging technology.’ He will serve as chairman of the new company.
The move is no doubt triggered as much by the fact that the Lucent Alcatel merger is now certain to go through, as much as the changing landscape that the AT&T and Sprint Nextel mergers have left for telecom equipment suppliers. The question remains what will happen to Nortel, which is no longer seen as large enough to compete with the merged Lucent Alcatel, and which no longer is betrothed through equipment tie in to Huawei. Nortel might even become a third partner in this merger at some point in the future under the right circumstances, but it is likely that it has too much of a product overlap for that.
Nokia Siemens Networks said that it is the third largest in the overall telecommunications infrastructure market (having leapfrogged Motorola) and will have a portfolio of IMS, 2G GSM/EDGE access, 3G WCDMA/HSDPA access, extensive mobile core, fixed broadband, transport, IPTV, LTE, WiMAX and low-cost mobile voice products tailored for emerging market operators.
Interestingly the company will have its operational headquarters in Helsinki in Finland and both Chairman and CEO, in the form of
Kallasvuo and Simon Beresford-Wylie, currently General Manager of Networks at Nokia, come from Nokia.
That puts a spin on the announcement that this is a takeover by another name, from the shareholder point of view a merger, but from the leadership point of view, an abdication by the Siemens executive. However the CFO will come from Siemens.
Siemens will now fall back into its more traditional areas such as information technology, automation and control, power, transport, medical, and lighting.