A small spat over whether or not Nokia will support DAB TV has sprung out of the UK. The public exchange of words was over British Telecom’s annoyance that Nokia would not make handsets for its forthcoming Enhanced Packet Mode mobile TV trial.
The UK has a number of DAB networks ready built for digital audio delivery and BT is trying to piggy back on these, but is unlikely to be able to produce much more than 1 or 2 mobile TV channels for each channel of DAB, giving the narrowness of the DAB spectrum slices. BT has managed to put out 7 TV channels for its Movio service, using more than one 1.5 GHz DAB channel.
UK news source VNUnet carried the details of the squabble back and forth for the past few days.
The simple truth is that Nokia has been involved with the DVB-H standard from day one, and has provided much of the thinking behind what is today an open standard.
It has been taken up by much of Europe, including trials or services announced in Italy, Germany, the UK, Spain, France, Sweden, the Netherlands, Finland, Denmark, Portugal and the Czech Republic, and also in the US, China and even in the heartland of T-DMB a competing standard deriving mostly from Korea, there is to be a DVB-H trial.
Elsewhere there are trials known of in Japan, Kenya, Singapore, Australia, Portugal, South Africa, Canada, Taiwan and Switzerland and Nokia says it has interest from Indonesia, Thailand, and Russia.
Whereas DAB Enhanced Packet Mode has just the one BT trial. So forgive us for taking Nokia’s side on this one, but it makes perfect sense to retain its integrity supporting what is certain to be the biggest mobile TV market in the world, DVB-H. It is being quite sane by saying that it is determined not to be forced into making phones which use different technologies.
The other two targets, MediaFLO and T-DMB are mostly aligned with operators that are using CDMA, an area where Nokia has never been very strong, so it loses little from ignoring the possibility that these may become big phone markets, and sticking to its guns.
Nokia issued a statement saying it has made a commitment to support the DVB-H standard and will not be supporting the rival DAB standard, which looks like being the first to market in the UK.
Nokia’s position was described as “ridiculous” yesterday by an unnamed director of one of the UK’s largest mobile operators according to VNUnet.
The big issue in the UK is that analog TV will not be turned off until 2012 and this is being seen as the only candidate spectrum for mobile TV. But there is more than one way to skin a cat, and the UK regulator is likely to ‘re-organize’ some areas of spectrum to release some spare capacity and an international conference is being held on this in spring, which may firm up its thinking. There may, in the end, be an auction for relevant spectrum as early as this year, bringing forward mobile TV in the UK so that it is in line with the rest of Europe, and this will almost certainly be won by a DVB-H sympathetic bidder, because all of the UK Cellcos are pro-DVB-H.