Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

8 November 2006

NTP now chasing Palm over ‘dubious’ wireless email patents

Fresh from its $612 million settlement with Blackberry inventor Research in Motion (RIM), in March, NTP, which claims core patents in wireless email, is now going after Palm. The privately-held two-man company has licensed its technology to Nokia, Good Technology and Visto, which is also suing Microsoft for a similar claimed patent breach.

Palm naturally rejects the complaints, and begins building on the defense that RIM put forward, which is that the patents are of doubtful validity, and likely to be rescinded by the US Patent and Trademark Office.

The statement from Palm says: ‘All seven of the patents asserted are being re-examined by the USPTO and have been rejected by the re-examiners as invalid. Palm also noted that the NTP patents disclose a pager-based email service that has nothing in common with the mobile-computing devices invented by Palm.’

Palm will remember the agony suffered by RIM shareholders in the run up to the resolution of its own suit, with the prospect of an injunction being supported by a court that would have seen the RIM wireless email system shut down in the US, although in the end this was never upheld.

The problem with legal actions like these is that regardless of who holds what patents, the legal process disrupts business, stopping customers signing up and deflating share values, so Palm may end up taking a license, despite being fairly clear that the patents are worthless. But it will have a couple of years during which it can delay the court hearings while the USPTO completes its inspection of the patents. If NTP patents are not upheld, the RIM license payment could get reversed, and that could take the steam out of NTP legal efforts.

The USPTO has already issued a final rejection for some of the NTP patents although NTP has filed for appeals over these rejections.

In December a suit targeting Microsoft’s Windows Mobile 5.0 software, was issued by Visto over mobile email and data acess patents which cover sending email from servers to mobile devices without requiring a manual download.