The mobile operators have had an understandably ambivalent attitude to introducing Wi-Fi to their systems, reducing the return on their investment in 3G, but they have largely felt forced to adopt WLans as a first step to fixed-mobile convergence and to improving indoor coverage. These aims are important to the cellcos, giving them the chance to dominate the indoor wireless network as well as the outdoor wide area, and to stake a claim in broadband and data/content access.
But to pursue them, opening up to Wi-Fi was previously seen as the only option – until the dawning interest in cellular femtocells (miniaturized base stations similar in size and cost to a WLan access point) provided an alternative platform for indoor penetration.
Now Telefonica’s UK unit O2, which has been wary of the WLan/cellular combination, looks set to be among the first to deploy femtocells commercially as part of its convergence moves. The company acquired low power spectrum in the 1781.7- 1785MHz and 1876.7-1880MHz bands, suitable for indoor GSM, in an auction in May, and intends to offer services next year, aimed at allowing enterprises to use standard cellphones seamlessly across the outdoor network and the indoor enterprise system.
This will avoid many of the hand-off issues associated with Wi- Fi/cellular convergence offerings, and avoid the need for companies to invest in expensive and battery-hungry dual-mode handsets. Femtocells enable the GSM phone to act as an office extension when the employee enters the building, reducing the voice load on the Wi-Fi network.
Low cost voice hotspots could also be implemented in public venues such as cafes or in homes. Mobile calls made within range of the customer picocell would still need to be converted to VoIP to be routed via the broadband connection, in order for users to save money, but such a system at least helps keep O2 in control of all the company’s voice access.
Even if revenues from access to internal networks have to be significantly lower than on the wide area cellular system, at least the cellco takes traffic away from the wireline phone operator, rather than sacrificing both fixed and some outdoor mobile traffic to another operator’s Wi-Fi system.
‘We can take ADSL and build out to a cell site, or else put the radio into the home or office,’ said Dave Williams, chief technology officer for Telefonica-O2 Europe, at a recent O2 strategy briefing in London. ‘Long term, we’re looking at building in 3G/GSM rather than Wi-Fi.’
Williams showed off a prototype femtocell that combines the functions of a domestic DSL router and a GSM base station, which O2 said could cost less than €100 when it ships next year. Although the target will initially be business users, at this price point it could also look to the consumer market, taking on convergence services like BT Fusion (although BT also acquired a portion of the low power spectrum). O2 is now looking for customers to take part in trials.
O2 sees femtocells as a way to limit its investment in Wi-Fi and concentrate its resources on extending the usefulness of its GSM/GPRS network as it builds out 3G and HSDPA, which it sees as its primary platform for delivering both fixed and mobile broadband triple play services in future, taking on the wirelesswireline partnerships of BT/Vodafone, Orange and others.
A recent study by ABI Research estimated that there would be 102m users of residential femtocells by 2011, with 32m of the devices installed. ‘Femtocells offer many benefits to operators,’ said principal analyst Stuart Carlaw. ‘From a technological standpoint, their better in-building coverage for technologies such as W-CDMA and HSDPA is an incredibly important aspect of service delivery.
From a strategic and financial standpoint, the routing of traffic through the IP network significantly enhances network quality and capacity, and reduces the opex that carriers expend on backhaul. On a conceptual basis, femtocells allow carriers to price cellular data services in the home aggressively, with the ultimate goal of shaping consumer behavior.’
UK regulator Ofcom awarded 12 licenses for low power services in the 1781.7-1785MHz and 1876.7-1880MHz bands. The winners were British Telecom, Cable & Wireless UK, Colt Mobile Telecommunications, Cyberpress, FMS Solutions, Mapesbury Communications, O2, Opal Telecom, PLDT (UK), Shyam Telecom UK, Spring Mobil and Teleware.