Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

15 January 2015

Ofcom creates formula for assessing VULA broadband margins

UK regulator Ofcom took the lead this week in laying down a model to regulate VULA (Virtual Unbundled Local Access) broadband – something which is sweeping across Europe since the beginning of 2014. VULA grants a guaranteed bandwidth connection to a home, rather than unbundling the local access line – something which has become necessary with both vectored broadband and fiber sharing.

Rather than providing a physical line, VULA provides a virtual connection that gives communication providers a direct link to their customers and provides flexibility over how this link is integrated into their network and product offerings.

In a 282 page document Ofcom explained its concerns over the continuing market power that British Telecom holds, and talked through the detailed thought processes behind how it intends to ensure that wholesale margins in broadband continue to allow rivals to earn a crust.

We first came across the VULA term in late 2012 used by Deutsche Telekom and it has since cut deals with both Vodafone and Telefonica to provide access to its huge German broadband base via a VULA agreement. It sees partnership with “telcos” as core to fighting against rival broadband technologies such as cable.

Ofcom said during 2013 that it would work towards unbundled regulation in VULA and has now produced its definitive document. However the document has no actual numbers in the key places, redacting prices and wholesale percentages in the public version of the document, to protect BT’s competitive position. The logic however is laid out in painstaking detail, and Ofcom has decided that where BT provides free TV channels, such as BT Sport, or a free set top box, then this must be included in the pricing formula offered to rival players.

BT argues in the document that this is unfair and adds a further £350 million to £400 million to its overall margin costs. Ofcom disagreed and said it was less and that it was also justified.

But Ofcom is clear on the threat posed by VULA agreements saying, “We consider that there is a relevant risk of adverse effects arising from a price distortion. We therefore consider that it is necessary to intervene to ensure that BT cannot use its Significant Market Power in the Wholesale Local Access market to set the VULA margin … such that it causes retail competition in superfast broadband to be distorted.” Right now BT has about 80% of the UK wholesale market in broadband.

One of the key details the report reveals is that BT wholesale margins right now are wider than Ofcom would insist upon, so there is plenty of scope for rivals to take BT Infinity lines and make the same kind of profit on them as BT is making. The exercise is more so that there is a model in place and a regular 6 monthly check to see that things stay that way.

“We consider that this aim is most appropriately achieved in this review period by ensuring that BT does not set the VULA margin such that it prevents an operator with slightly higher costs than BT (or some other slight commercial drawback relative to BT) from being able to profitably match BT’s retail superfast broadband offers.”

It looks to us like Ofcom is the first regulator in Europe to set VULA policy and it is likely that others will follow many of the decision it has taken. Most of its detailed calculations are in line with Berec (Body of European Regulators for Electronic Communications) recommendations, which has already considered this area.

The economic model is based on an adjusted equally efficient operator approach, which uses BT’s own costs and revenues, with the addition of adjustments to reflect other communication providers’ lower average customer lifetimes and higher bandwidth costs.

This all kicked off perhaps because in May 2013 TalkTalk, a rival broadband provider in the UK, made a complaint and Ofcom responded by opening an investigation. TalkTalk said BT had abused a dominant position in the supply of superfast broadband and failed to maintain a sufficient margin between its upstream and downstream prices, thereby operating an abusive margin squeeze. Ofcom decided that there was no case to answer, but has proceeded to this new unbundling model.

Ofcom justifies its inclusion of the unit costs of BT Sport in its calculation saying, “We consider the VULA margin control will have limited impact on BT’s incentives to bid for future rights. We accept that, under our proposals, higher net BT Sport costs will increase the VULA margin that BT needs to maintain. However, even absent regulation, we would expect BT to only bid for content where the associated revenues outweigh the rights costs. . .” It says much the same about offering a free set top box for its BT TV and concludes that BT has other advantages that will make up for including these costs prior to calculating the wholesale maximum price.

Included in BT’s VULA cost calculation were marketing, customer service costs, billing and bad debt, labor costs, R&D,  accommodation, IT spend, and marketing platform spend, among others.

Currently Ofcom concludes that BT’s broadband prices are higher than those of Sky and TalkTalk for comparable bundles, and by maintaining a mandated margin, it hopes to keep it this way.