Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

20 November 2014

Ofcom EPL probe is window dressing for broadband battle

Liberty Global’s Virgin Media has presented itself as a consumer rights champion in its successful bid to persuade UK regulator Ofcom to open an investigation into selling of live TV rights for English Premier League (EPL) football.

This may be supposedly in the spirit of Virgin Group founder Richard Branson but the reality is that the probe is effectively a smokescreen for the ongoing commercial and regulatory battles surrounding premium live sports rights. The outcome of the probe, opened under both the UK 1998 Competition Act and an equivalent EU wide regulation, could have significant ramifications for the way live TV sports rights evolve in line with the trend towards IP and OTT content distribution.

At the same time there is little chance that any Ofcom action will burst the grossly inflated bubble that the EPL has become, but is quite likely to succeed in slowing its expansion and changing the way that rights packages are bundled and sold. This is what could have wider implications for live sports rights beyond the UK.

The probe comes at a time when UK sports rights ownership, particularly regarding by far the most lucrative component – football, is approaching a duopoly between Sky and BT. For years it was a monopoly enabling Sky to become the major pay TV force it is, facing nominal temporary competition from various weaker competitors such as ESPN and Setanta Sports, along with UK commercial broadcaster ITV for European Champions League football.

Then BT decided to make football rights a cornerstone of its strategy for UK broadband dominance and bid aggressively to acquire two of the seven EPL packages for the three seasons 2013/2014 to 2015/2016 equating to 38 live matches per season, spending £738 million (about $1.2 billion) in the process. With Sky still showing 116 matches per season, the most a single bidder was allowed, this did not quite break the monopoly, but the game changer was BT’s subsequent acquisition of all UK live rights to Champions League football for the three seasons 2015/2016 to 2017/2018, paying £900 million ($1.45 billion). Currently these rights are shared between Sky and ITV, so this represents a major shift in the balance of UK sports rights power, with BT also gaining rights to highlights and mobile delivery.

It is important to keep an eye on the fact that measured in price paid per match the EPL is seven times more valuable for rights holders than the Champions League, reflecting the size of audiences. Under the current ITV/Sky deal, the average value per match is £907,000 ($1.5 million) and has actually fallen slightly so that BT is paying £854,000, reflecting the new deal covering 350 matches a season, slightly more than previously.

By contrast under the current deal, the average cost per match for the EPL is $6.5 million ($10.5 million). This highlights how much is at stake in the EPL battle, with the next auction due to take place early 2015. That is why Virgin Media, which as a pure distributor, stands to gain from any Ofcom action that reduces prices or at least chokes back any increase. Virgin asked Ofcom to investigate in September and the regulator has now agreed to. The main substance of the complaint is that the current arrangement ensures that consumers pay more to watch the EPL than their counterparts in the other major European footballing countries, primarily Germany, Spain, Italy and France, where many of the clubs sell their own games and where there is not one single contract for the entire league.

On closer scrutiny the Virgin Media complaint stacks up better in its argument for showing more matches live than on the issue of competition. If we take the two largest European football markets next to England, Germany and Spain, the picture is not so clear. In Germany it is true the people pay less per match on average than in the UK, reflecting lower demand for the product with the current rights package costing €485.7 million ($ 610 million) per season, about 40% of the EPL level.

But the rights are now held exclusively by Sky Deutschland, so that is hardly an argument for having two or more rights holders involved. Previously Deutsche Telekom also held rights but lost out in the last auction covering the four seasons 2013 to 2017, including not just live Bundesliga, but also 2nd Bundesliga matches, embracing all platforms, including satellite, cable, IPTV, web and mobile. Including IPTV and mobile was a serious blow to Deutsche Telekom’s pay TV strategy, so the last auction has hardly aided the cause of competition in that market.

Meanwhile in Spain rights are split between individual teams rather than sold as a package for the whole league and this has had the effect of concentrating power even more than before in the hands of Real Madrid and Barcelona, because their matches command higher live fees. In the EPL by contrast, as well as the Bundesliga, the rights bounty is distributed equally among all the clubs, which has the effect of making the leagues more competitive.

In the EPL five clubs have been in contention for the title in recent years and several more for qualification to the Champions League, while in Spain only Atletico Madrid for one season has really punctured the duopoly and as a result their matches too now command higher fees. EPL matches as a whole tend to be more competitive with even the top clubs, notably Chelsea and Manchester City this season, more likely to be given bloody noses by lower ranked teams. So while the very best and most valuable players, such as Lionel Messi, Cristiano Ronaldo, Carlos Tevez and Gareth Bale, currently ply their trade in Spain, the EPL has greater strength in depth, and to a lesser extent, so does the Bundesliga.

Ofcom’s probe could have the effect of sustaining the strength in depth, providing there is no attempt to break up the packages by individual clubs along Spanish lines. One of Virgin Media’s complaints is that the current package restricts the number of live matches shown to only around four a week, less than half the total, while in Germany for example all matches are shown live.

Among Ofcom’s consideration is whether such rationing is helping to artificially inflate the price consumers have to pay. After all the whole package would not double in price if all matches were shown, in fact it might not cost any more, given that at present there is a bias towards including matches deemed of greater interest in the packages.

It is actually a two tier system, with BT’s allocation of 38 matches a year includes 18 of these so called “first picks”, defined as the most appealing match from each round of games. As there are 38 rounds given 20 teams playing each other twice, this means Sky has 20 first picks per season, only slightly more than BT, even though it has 116 games in total. Therefore BT actually did rather well and its package is more valuable than its overall games quota suggests.

The EPL’s argument for maintaining the status quo is that English football has traditionally kicked off at 3pm on Saturday and this is still the time most lower leagues games are played. Therefore showing live EPL matches at that time would reduce attendances at these games with a detrimental effect on English football as a whole, so this argument goes. To show all EPL games live in a staggered way so that in theory one person could watch all of them, while avoiding the 3pm watershed, would be impossible logistically, the EPL contends.

One of the few points of agreement between the English Football Supporters’ Federation and the EPL lies in preserving the 3pm blackout, but this does not mean it is right. In Germany all Bundesliga matches are shown live and attendances have not dropped either for top flight or lower leagues games. There is even an argument that televising matches live stokes interest that brings people to watch their local teams, but in any case there is no reason why the EPL cannot just side step the 3pm watershed or take measures such as ensuring that first pick matches do not clash with this. It is doubtful whether people would stay at home to watch say Stoke versus Hull, currently a premier league fixture, rather than attend their local games as usual.

The more interesting aspect of Virgin Media’s complaint is over the partition of rights between Sky and BT. This would seem to contradict the tenor of the argument by calling for a return to a Sky monopoly, when at least people only needed one subscription to watch virtually all live EPL games. But what Virgin Media is actually calling for is for both to show all the games within a single package.

Currently all games can be watched by Virgin Media and Sky pay TV subscribers, but a separate additional monthly payment has to be made for each. BT broadband subscribers currently get BT Sport bundled in free, highlighting the strategy to drive broadband growth and gain pole position for future multiple play services. This has been partially successful, with BT accounting for almost half the broadband growth over the three months July to September 2014. BT secured 88,000 net broadband additions, which is 40% of the total 220,000 over that quarter. The rest of the growth was mostly shared between Sky and TalkTalk, which use BT’s Openreach network on a wholesale basis, along with Virgin Media over its cable network.

So BT is outstripping its competitors in growth on the back of BT Sports, but not to the extent it needs to recoup its massive investment in sports rights. Taking account of annual rights and cost of sales, BT would need to reach at least 10 million subs and perhaps 11 million over the next two years to cover the outlay. But premium sports rights is not exactly a zero sum game, because participants are playing for the future as well as the present. BT’s real aim is to get close enough to paying back its outlay to make its strategy of being a major TV sports player sustainable, by increasing its ability to bid for and acquire future rights.

So while BT has no hope of breaking even for TV over the next few years it aims to hold onto its position on the podium of sports broadcasting alongside Sky. The current Ofcom investigation would slightly harm its prospects if it reduced the price Sky subscribers pay. Meanwhile Virgin Media is angling on becoming the place where people can go to watch all live sports via a single subscription.

Currently Virgin Media carries BT Sport under a wholesale contract so that it can be offered as part of its own bundle. Sky by contrast transmits BT Sport directly on a retail basis, to which access is regulated. BT does not want to sell wholesale to Sky because its strategy is to pinch the latter’s broadband subscribers and it will be allowed by the regulator to continue on this basis so long as Sky is deemed to have dominant market power. Ofcom is unlikely to change that view now, but might do after the next EPL auction and then the stage would be set for the effectively converged services Virgin Media is talking about.

But Virgin Media may not gain many subs as a result, for BT and Sky will also be offering total sports bundles and the way may be opened for other distributors to come in and take live sports content on a wholesale basis.