Vodafone’s $9.6 billion bid for Spain’s biggest MSO Ono has just been rejected but is likely to be followed by an improved offer. This reflects ONO being a strategic as well as a tactical acquisition for Vodafone in its bid for European leadership in quad play, as an all-round provider.
On paper $9.5 billion is just about what Ono is worth by the traditional measure used to value companies in the cable sector. This is based on a value to core profit ratio of 9.4, which would rate Ono at almost exactly $9.6 billion given its 2012 earnings of $1.02 billion.
Ono, as a significant provider of broadband capacity, would establish Vodafone as a major quad play force in Spain to compete with incumbent Telefonica. It fits with its immediate objective to acquire as much fixed line capacity as possible in its four key European markets of the UK, Germany, Italy and Spain and to continue setting the pace in the overall European quad play market.
It is not, as some analysts have suggested a purely defensive move against Telefonica, even if there is an element of that. It dovetails well with its existing fixed line position in Spain as Ono is concentrated in rural and smaller urban areas while Vodafone is currently building a fiber network covering the major cities, principally Madrid and Barcelona, but also including regional capitals such as Seville, Malaga and Valencia. The future for cellular lies as part of heterogeneous network services, combined with Wi-Fi and broadband, which is why Vodafone is anxious to rebalance its infrastructure with a greater fixed line component. On top of that Ono is looking towards an IPO (Initial Public Offering) so Vodafone had to act to pre-empt that.
Vodafone’s main pan European rivals on the quad play stage include John Malone’s Liberty Global, Deutsche Telekom, Telefonica and France Telecom Orange. Of these Liberty Global has the most extensive fixed line operation spanning 12 European countries, the UK, Netherlands, Germany, Poland, Switzerland, Belgium, Ireland, Austria, Slovakia, Hungary, Belgium and the Czech Republic.
Telefonica has mobile operations in the UK, Ireland, Germany, Slovakia and Czech Republic as well as Spain, but broadband coverage is patchy outside its home country where it has 47% of the market. In the UK it sold its remaining broadband operation to BSkyB for £200 million ($320 million) in March 2013.
Orange has fixed and mobile operations in France, Poland, Spain and Slovakia, with mobile networks also in Romania as well as the UK through the joint EE venture with Deutsche Telekom. DT has substantial shares in fixed line Telcos across central and Eastern Europe, including Slovak Telekom (Slovakia), Magyar Telekom (Hungary), and T-Hrvatski Telekom (Croatia), which are now fully consolidated into T-Com/T-Home.
In addition, Magyar Telekom holds majority shares in Makedonski Telekom (Macedonia), and Crnogorski Telekom (Montenegro) all of which have also been rebranded and included under the T-Com/T-Home umbrella. DT also holds a controlling interest in the Hellenic telecommunication operator OTE, which also has shares in several other companies like the mobile operators Cosmote Greece, Cosmote Romania, Globul Bulgaria, AMC Albania, the IT&C retailer Germanos, and the Romanian telecommunication operator Romtelecom.
Vodafone itself has at least majority owned networks in all the leading European markets except France (it sold a 45% holding in SFR) and is now establishing fixed line networks in the leading countries, for example in Germany through its $10.5 billion acquisition of the country’s largest MSO Kabel Deutschland, which was finally cleared by the European Commission in September 2013.
Liberty Global is then the biggest rival in terms of geographical broadband coverage, but coming from a totally different direction with virtually no directly owned mobile capacity. Its mobile strategy spelt out recently by Chief Financial Officer Charles Bracken is to sell mobile services as part of all-inclusive bundles across all its 12 European markets over time, but by taking capacity on a wholesale basis rather than buying or building its own infrastructure.
Bracken stated that Liberty Global would offer all inclusive bundles of TV, broadband, voice and mobile reluctantly, only if driven to do so by competitors. Its mobile strategy Bracken admitted was defensive and low on capex. The situation is somewhat different in the UK where Liberty Global entered through the $23 billion acquisition of the dominant MSO Virgin Media early in 2013. Virgin Media was an established virtual mobile operator using the T-Mobile Network and now the Orange network as well following the merger in 2010 between T-Mobile and Orange to form the joint venture EE. So in the UK Liberty Global can already offer bundled quad play services, although still without owning a cellular network.
In Germany, Liberty Global could also launch quad-play packages, but again has stated it will only do so if rivals Deutsche Telekom and Vodafone go down that route. Since that looks likely, Liberty Global is almost certainly preparing for that despite its public reticence and may well end up partnering Vodafone with an MVNO, to bolster its presence there.
Meanwhile in Spain Liberty Global does appear to have come in with a bid for Ono, but this looks like a spoiler since it would struggle to find the cash after its recent $13 billion plus bid for Dutch MSO Ziggo, to achieve near total dominance of the cable market there (a deal that may face tough regulatory scrutiny).
Cash is not an issue for Vodafone following its $130 billion windfall from the sale of its stake in Verizon Wireless, back to its former partner Verizon Communications. Vodafone has earmarked $40 billion for acquisition but could devote more while still having enough for its own network expansion including fiber deployment in the key markets. It will certainly have to raise its offer for Ono substantially to quash the IPO fervor currently frothing around the company after the rejection of Vodafone’s current bid.
In parallel with its broadband expansion Vodafone is plotting moves on the content front to make its 4G services more compelling and to combat churn to low cost rivals. Against a backdrop of sliding core mobile revenues, Vodafone recently confirmed it is planning to enter the UK consumer broadband and TV market, and is now in discussion with content owners to follow up on its deal with Sky to bundle 4G mobile contracts with access to the Sky Sports mobile app. Vodafone indicated that its fixed line offer will be similar in being based on wholesale agreements rather than either direct acquisition of a broadband network or bidding for exclusive content rights. In this sense Vodafone is mirroring Liberty Global’s approach to mobile offerings.
It also indicated that Vodafone is seeking strategic alliances with appropriate operators. Some tie up with Sky in the UK looks likely to face off their common rival BT for example (although Vodafone also relies heavily on BT for backhaul in the UK). Vodafone is already competing strongly with BT in the UK corporate broadband market following its £1.04 billion ($1.65 billion) acquisition of Cable & Wireless Worldwide in April 2012.
Even so content will remain something of a side show for Vodafone, with the bulk of its war treasury being devoted to broadband expansion, through acquisition coupled with fiber build out in core urban markets.