Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

15 January 2015

Open TV sees suit failing against Netflix, shuts it down, plays nice

We never understood the legal action brought by Swiss Nagra owner Kudelski Group on behalf of its Open TV subsidiary, against Netflix in the US. Unless it was a nuisance suit bought on behalf of a customer – Nagra works alongside Dish Network in the US, and Dish ran Blockbuster and now Sling TV – so rivals Netflix. Ostensibly it was brought to prevent many of the Open TV customers including Time Warner Cable, Comcast, Dish Network, Charter, NBC Universal and Suddenlink Communications potentially dropping Open TV software, though we’re not really sure why.

The patents at stake were all to do with interactivity, putting data on a TV screen – basic stuff that every OTT service has to do – and we said when this first came out in the US in 2012, that it was a doomed action.

There are 7 patents in total and they relate to placing internet information on a TV screen, online media delivery, using presentation syntax to offer interactivity, the creation of user profiles and systems of TV playout and Nagra was suing on behalf of Open TV, which has a strong middleware platform, particularly strong in Europe on set tops.

Now the case is over and there seems to be an agreement for the two to work together with a suggestion that Kudelksi will pre-integrate its Nagra anyCast DRM and its Open TV platform with Netflix. Now we cannot see that this is any great concession on the part of Netflix, it just means that customers who use any of the four anyCast clients (Enable, Protect, Guard and Command) can also offer Netflix and that it can also be used with the Open TV software. It looks like the Open TV suit caved in completely and integration is being done by Open TV to accommodate Netflix into its systems in order to minimize any harm.

Nagra’s AnyCast has become a spread of products from software downloadable DRM with SoC chip support, right up to full smart card protected devices and systems with special defenses against control word sharing.

Both companies will withdraw all pending patent litigation in the US and agree to a long-term stay of a pending Dutch patent litigation, another suit we felt was going nowhere. Back in December one of two suits in the Netherlands was settled in Netflix’ favor, with the Kudelski patents considered obvious and unenforceable with costs awarded against Kudelski.

In the US a judge similarly ruled that many of the Open TV patents were not enforceable, leaving one patent still in play for the court case. We made the point at the time that these were all software patents and if Kudelski was to push the same patents in the European court it would have no chance of winning. In Europe the European Patent Office accepts software patents, despite there being no basis in law for them in most European countries.

OpenTV has never sued other set top middleware providers, which really might infringe on its assets, and it has software in digital set top boxes at hundreds of millions of subscribers around the world, so you would think that it would have. If we find out what this failed action was really about, we’ll let you know.