Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

22 February 2006

Orange takes a look at TDtv. Does that mean DVB-H is on hold?

What exactly can we learn from the announcement by Orange this week that it plans to try out the IP Wireless TDtv service from the middle of 2006 onwards? Well quite a lot as it happens.

It might suggest that its 50 Channel French unicast TV, where television signals are sent over the 3G mobile signal, but which hog bandwidth horribly, is not a plan that is quite working for Orange and its masters at France Telecom.

The other thing it suggests is that the DVB-H trial that it attached to, where it is using TF1 and M6 content, alongside TPS and Bouygues Telecom, won’t turn into a real business any time soon, as it would make sense for Orange to wait for the outcome of this trial.

This seems to put back proper broadcast TV on a mobile in France for at least 6 months.

The deal came a day too late to include in our last issue, and Orange has lined up to be the first mobile company in Europe to try out the technology, where an unpaired part of its 3G spectrum is used to deliver a Time Division Multiplexed signal that broadcasts TV channels as pure Internet Protocol signals. The system is based on the 3GPP Multimedia Broadcast and Multicast Services (MBMS) standard.

In Faultline’s report on mobile TV, just published, we can see that once the first multicast services arrive in Europe in the 2007, 2008 timeframe, then it will enter a fight against the datacast services using systems like DVB-H . We anticipate that many of the major European Cellcos will lean towards multicasting, where they can keep all of the revenue and control from a mobile TV service and use it as a key differentiator. Smaller operators that cannot negotiate their own content deals or pay to upgrade all their base stations, may throw in their lot with broadcasters shooting for a datacast service, and trigger a long term war in the sector.

Unicast TV in this scenario will fall away to be a free add-on. Used almost like a gimmick to get customers to upgrade to 3G. To give you an idea of the experience, the MobiTV content that is delivered to Orange, to a J2ME client, plays video at between 10 and 15 frames per second using around 128 Kbps of bandwidth. And that’s one of MobiTV’s more high resolution clients. DVB-H and IP Wireless signals are closer to 400 Kbps, and 30 frames a second, in much higher resolution.

As a result the typical behavior of an Orange mobile TV viewer is to take 3 to 5 minute ‘snacks’ of video and over the entire month they might use video for 40 to 45 minutes. In DVB-H trials, and the IP Wireless systems should deliver the same user experience, usage has averaged 20 minutes a day and peaked as high as 40 minutes a day.

The new service that Orange will try, TDtv, operates in the universal unpaired 3G spectrum bands that are available across Europe and Asia at 1900MHz and 2010MHz. It allows UMTS operators like Orange to use their existing spectrum without impacting other voice and data 3G services.

IP Wireless claims that TDtv will allow mobile operators to deliver up to 50 channels of TV for standard cell phone screens (same as unicast), or 17 higher quality QVGA channels, in 5MHz of unpaired 1.9GHz spectrum.

The big problem for IP Wireless right now is the fact that newer base station software is required and new handsets, upgraded to deal with two internal activities at once. This puts it about a year behind DVB-H roll out schedules, and will sow confusion in the market. Operators would prefer it, while broadcasters would lose all control, and will opt for DVB-H. Also spectrum issues in Europe make the Multicast system more attractive to most operators, because no new spectrum needs to be acquired. However cell sizes need to shrink in order to get the best out of the system, so a network upgrade is not avoided totally, but instead can be spread over a couple of years.

DVB-H can also be used with anything that has a decent screen, a battery and a processor, such as a PC or PDA, with the addition of just $10 of components added into the device, and so this opens up the market beyond cell phones.