One of the big revelations of CES (Consumer Electronics Show) 2014 has been Panasonic’s decision to drive its next range of smart TVs with Mozilla’s Firefox OS rather than using say the SmartTV Alliance platform with its own built-in browser. To cap a good CES for Mozilla, Chinese smartphone and telecoms equipment maker ZTE China announced it was developing a new range of phones based on the Firefox OS to ‘give mobile users more choice’. But the main significance of both announcements was that they signal increasing fragmentation rather than convergence, certainly within the smart TV market and to an extent in smart phones as well.
The move could spell the effective end of the SmartTV Alliance after seemingly good progress attracting members. Founded in June 2012 by LG Electronics, TP Vision and Toshiba, the Alliance has since attracted 16 additional members spanning a variety of ecosystem segments, including Vestel and Xumo as sponsors, along with members Warner Brothers, Dolby, Opera Software, Realtek, Arcelik, FPT Software, TPV Group, ABOX42, IBM, Obigo, Qualcomm, Technisat and Yume, as well as Panasonic itself, which joined in January 2013.
But as often with such alliances the gorilla in the room has stayed outside, in this case Samsung. As a result the Alliance has never quite escaped the status of being an anti-Samsung grouping, but at least for a while that held the body together. We should remember that Samsung has about 26% of the global smart TV market, according to Strategy Analytics, more than double LG at 11%, out of around 52 million altogether in 2013. Yet just over two years ago Sony and Sharp dominated the then nascent smart TV field.
But now faced with annihilation in the overall TV market in company with other Japanese CE makers, Panasonic is seeking desperate measures and believes that partnering with Mozilla will help it develop a distinctive line of smart TVs that will stand out from the competition. It is also part of a strategy to position the smart TVs as ideal vehicles for accessing interactive cloud services through a version of the Firefox browser optimized for video content around HTML5. As such, the aim is to make the smart TV the center of the home device constellation, through Mozilla Web APIs that can allow TVs to monitor and operate devices, including emerging smart home appliances.
The immediate objective is to install the smart TV as the mother ship of video in the home, encouraging developers to write menus and programming guides in HTML5 to run under the Firefox browser instead of as embedded programs, so that smartphones and tablets can act as remote controls as well as participate readily as companion devices. Mozilla aims to bring on personalized UIs incorporating functions that allow multiple users to share the same screen while doing different things on their own devices.
The official reason given for Panasonic’s partnership with Firefox was the usual red herring of openness. Panasonic’s US Vice President for Interactive Content and Services Group Merwan Mereby argued that current options are controlled by either Google or Apple, which as two powerful corporations seeking industry dominance ‘hold all the strings.’ As such, Android and iOS are not viable options for Panasonic, as the ecosystem is tightly controlled, Mereby contended.
In reality it has nothing to do with openness, but more a gamble that the Firefox OS will enable Panasonic to stand out by exploiting the OS’s reasonably good fit with TV. It is a lightweight OS that is economical on resources and its synergy with HTML5 and other web technologies dovetails well with smart TVs, given their requirement for continual connectivity. The idea is that EPGs and other UI features that are often embedded into TVs or set tops will now be written in HTML5, making it easier for developers to write apps for smartphones and tablets to remotely control those TVs. It also opens the door to personalized and adaptable interfaces that are much more appealing than what we have seen so far on Smart TVs.
Yet all this will be irrelevant unless Firefox gains more traction in the smart TV market. For while CES 2014 will be chalked up as a success by Mozilla it also highlighted its failure to gain adoption by other TV makers. The paradox for Panasonic is that unless other TV makers adopt the Firefox OS and therefore compete with Panasonic on that front, there is unlikely to be sufficient critical mass to attract a decent number of developers.
Although for a totally different market, ZTE was attracted to Firefox for rather similar reasons, namely its light footprint, synergy with HTML5 for media rich services and desire to stand out. In this case it is not out of desperation but to build on momentum already achieved in becoming a significant force in the global smartphone market, albeit still a bit part player compared with Samsung.
The latest available figures for Q3 2013 from IDC indicate that Samsung is still increasing its dominant share but at a reduced rate, accounting for 31.4% of 258.4 million shipments, compared with 31.0% in Q3 2012. Apple was down from 14.4% to 13.1% over the year, while Huawei rose into third place with 4.8%, Lenovo 4th at 4.7% and LG fifth at 4.6%. Next came ZTE at about 4.4%, up from just under 4% a year earlier and the move into Firefox is designed to push the company ahead of that rump into an admittedly poor third place, although in practice we don’t see the company overtaking an increasingly rampant Huawei. But at least the first Firefox OS phone made by ZTE is now available via Telefonica in Spain, which the operator says is doing well in both its European and Latin America markets.
For Mozilla the prospect of royalties through sales of Firefox OS phones in ZTE’s domestic Chinese market is more exciting. The sheer size of the population coupled with average annual GDP growth rates at around 8%, have driven incendiary growth in smart phone sales, to reach almost 100 million or almost half the world market in Q3 2013 by our estimates. This is taking account of figures released by Gartner on sales in China of so called AOSP (Android Open Source Platform) handsets, which use local app stores and neither count towards “activations” measured by Google, nor hook into Google services. The data showed that in Q3 2013 there was very much a two-speed smartphone market, with AOSP sales in China nearly doubling in a year to 84.1 million, compared with 28% year-on-year growth outside China. According to Gartner, AOSP handsets with prices ranging from $150 to $300 account for about 90% of handset sales in China and this is the problem for Mozilla. It has to break into that and also into Android’s overall stranglehold worldwide. According to IDC, Android’s share of the mobile OS market was 81% in Q3 2013, up from 74.9% year-on-year, while iOS slipped from 14.4% to 12.9%. Windows Phone overtook Blackberry into third place rising from 2.0% to 3.6%, leaving Firefox OS with all to do. At least with ZTE it is on the map.
And there is the faint hope that royalties that are now payable to Microsoft for the use of Android, almost certainly don’t apply to Mozilla and that play sot the Chinese corporate tendency to want very much not to be held in thrall by US technology.