Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

30 May 2014

Panasonic out of OLED as Sony hives off TV division

Panasonic’s decision this week to quite the fledgling OLED (Organic Light Emitting Diode) field for large screen TVs, highlights both continuing yield problems for the technology and the deepening malaise of Japan’s leading CE sector, with the partial exception of Sony. Panasonic cited the low yield and resulting poor profitability on production of OLEDs, while reiterating its continued presence in the market for LCD displays of all sizes.

Panasonic is selling its OLED division to Japan Display, so the country is still nominally in the OLED TV business. This is interesting in that Japan Display was set up by Sony, Toshiba and Hitachi as a joint venture to focus on LCD technology on the TV front, progressing towards UHD. Sony is on the verge of separating its TV business in its own division, while also distancing itself from OLED to focus primarily on LCD. Meanwhile Japan Display is also the world’s biggest maker of smartphone and tablet displays, numbering Apple among its clients, and its interest so far in OLED is therefore primarily for small screens.

OLED has been widely hailed as the next generation of display technology after LCD, but this will only happen in the case of large screens if the yield problem can be solved. This is an issue for all large TV screens because roughly speaking the manufacturing reject rate is proportional to the display’s surface area. For LCD technology the reject rate has been reduced to relatively low levels of around 10% for normal screen sizes, although considerably more for the largest displays.

OLED has clear quality advantages over LCD, being lighter because there is no backlight. Because OLED pixels emit light directly, viewing angles are wider, with color and contrast holding up at up to 90 degrees off center. OLED TVs can deliver an absolute black and infinite contrast ratio, with brighter pictures and faster response times of under 0.01ms, which effectively eliminates motion blur. With the Active-Matrix (AMOLED) version of the technology, pixels can be turned on and off individually, which also improves display of motion.

But the thin size makes it hard to manufacture large panels, with LG reporting yields of only around 65% for just 55 inch displays and Samsung faring worse at only 45%, having opted for a slightly different assembly approach.

Given the rule linking reject rate to surface area, Samsung would only achieve a yield of around 10% for massive 100 inch displays, which suggests that OLED panels are not going to get any larger for the time being. Both Samsung and LG remain committed to the technology and are convinced their investment will eventually pay back, even though they have postponed by two years until 2017 the projected arrival of mainstream affordable OLED TVs.

This will leave others with less deep pockets, including the Japanese contingent, continuing to bet on UHD based on LCD technology. But the question there is whether 4K will ever become widely deployed itself. There is a growing constituency arguing that as 8K is already in the pipeline and is unlikely to be superseded by say 16K, the industry may bypass 4K. The argument for 8K is that it provides the resolution needed not just for ultra large displays but also caters for possible future use cases, such as zapping and zooming in on parts of the display, for example to focus on a particular incident on a sporting field. As 8K has already been successfully demonstrated by NHK for example at the 2012 London Olympics, some are wondering why the industry should invest heavily in 4K.

Please sign up for a full FREE four week trial to our weekly service Faultline at www.rethinkresearch.biz/faultline