The wave of consolidation sweeping through pay TV is combining with the growth in OTT and hybrid services to disrupt the traditional ecosystem and threaten the established players. The big set top box makers are particularly affected since they have historically tended to focus on particular sectors, that is satellite, cable, DTT or IPTV, which are now converging as a result of mergers.
Most notably AT&T’s planned $45 billion acquisition of DirecTV will combine the former’s U-Verse IPTV and multiscreen services with the latter’s DTH offerings. If this merger gains regulatory approval, as seems likely, it will be the largest example of an emerging fully converged service combining a traditional broadcast platform, in this case satellite, with the full range of IP distribution options, including mobile. AT&T’s cause may be helped here by recent weaker net neutrality proposals from the regulator FCC (Federal Communications Commission) which would make it easier to deploy multiscreen ‘multiplay’ bundles spanning fixed and wireless. It appears that the FCC now regards mobile broadband as just another access technology that should be subject to the same regulations as fixed line services, which signifies acceptance of Fixed Mobile Convergence. It is no coincidence that AT&T’s bid for DirecTV coincided with publication of the FCC’s proposals, although these are far from a done deal yet, as there is considerable opposition from democrats in the Senate over at least the proposals regarding fast lanes within a tiered Internet, which could end up derailing the whole package.
Meanwhile in Europe Vodafone’s €7.7 billion acquisition of Kabel Deutschland is also pointing towards multiplay services combining cable TV in this case with multiscreen fixed and mobile IP delivery. The first fruits of this merger came in May 2014 when Vodafone Germany launched the new brand Home Plus, offering triple play broadband, voice and TV over a combination of VDSL and cable, with plans to add mobile TV.
Such mergers are likely to pre-empt similar consolidation within the set top industry, especially among those heavily biased towards one of the main broadcast platforms. All of the big five, that is Arris, Cisco, Technicolor, Pace and EchoStar, are either heavily weighted to one sector, or at least top heavy in two of the three. Pace is still biased towards satellite where it is the clear leader, with significantly lowers sales in cable and IPTV. Arris was once exclusively cable but has grown in IPTV, aided by its $2.35 billion acquisition of Motorola Mobility from Google in April 2013.
Mind you Arris’ cable bias has so far done the company no harm given its dominance of the two leading US MSOs, Comcast and Time Warner Cable, responsible respectively for 19% and 7% of its overall $2.1 billion revenue in 2013. So for Arris the planned merger between Comcast and TWC was good news in the sense that it would introduce no major new conflict with other set top suppliers, although with the combined company accounting for 26% of revenue it would have a lot of eggs in one basket. On top of that Arris derives 13% of its revenues from Verizon, essentially also for a cable platform since it was designed for the QAM configuration the operator initially deployed for its FiOS TV service, even though it runs on fiber to the home.
Arris has been the strongest performer over the last 18 months and overtook Pace as the world number one set top maker measured by volume in Q4 2013. That was a most spectacular quarter for the company, registering a 43% increase in shipments, spurred by Comcast itself with orders for the hybrid Arris XG1 HD DVR as part of the operator’s IP/QAM X1 platform. Arris was buoyed further at the end of 2013 by Comcast’s increasingly aggressive roll out of X1 among its 21.7 million pay TV customer base. Comcast started making X1 available to double play customers after previously having confined it to triple play bundles. This was soon followed by the announcement that X1 would serve as the platform for Comcast’s forthcoming online video distribution service slated to compete with YouTube, due to launch later this year.
During 2014 the gloss has slightly come off for Arris, not directly because of the consolidations and mergers, but as a result of other developments moving further towards consolidation of the set top. A notable negative factor for Arris especially is the growing momentum behind the RDK (Reference Design Kit), introduced by Comcast in 2012 and soon joined by TWC, as a standardized software framework for TV CPE including set tops, gateways, and hybrid devices. It was created to accelerate the deployment of next generation video products and services and also stimulate more competition among set top providers, aiming to drive down costs. This was not such good news for the established providers since it lowers the bar to entry. The key point is that the RDK code works as a separate layer from the application framework or User Interface of these devices. It is now supported by all the main cable operators, including Liberty Global and Vodafone, as well as vendors across the supply chain.
Shares in Arris have taken a hit several times this year as a result of announcements relating to RDK from major customers. One was TWC’s decision early this year to work with South Korean set top and gateway maker Humax for its first IP box integrating RDK. This is to implement Cloud Navigator, TWC’s new HTML 5 cloud-based navigation guide aimed at giving customers a more advanced user experience with enhanced search capabilities.
The Arris share price was also knocked by reports that Comcast was in talks with Apple in April over use of a set top designed by the latter to stream live and on-demand video over the cable TV firm’s network. Apple had earlier been in discussions with TWC as well over putting an app inside its set top, but the suggested Comcast deal would go further since Apple would supply the box as well.
While on the one hand these developments are leading towards commoditization of the set top they are also going in seemingly the opposite direction towards improved functionality. For years set top makers have enjoyed almost cartel like status, able to get away with lackluster low functionality boxes that would have been totally uncompetitive in an open market like smartphones or PCs.
Poor box quality was one reason for the low customer satisfaction ratings with many cable operators in particular, especially in the US. Operators have woken up to this and are showing scant loyalty to their traditional set top suppliers as they get behind RDK. In yet another example, TWC has been promoting a hybrid box called FanTV, combining a user interface with buttonless touch-based remote quite similar to the concept that Steve Jobs seemed to be talking about for Apple in the run up to his death.
But perhaps the most damaging impact of all of RDK lies in attracting Samsung to the market. Already the likes of Roku alongside Apple and Amazon had been gnawing away at the traditional set top market by encouraging cord cutting, but Samsung’s arrival as a direct competitor on the back of RDK is far more threatening. This is a threat not just in the OTT arena, but to their core business, given Samsung’s record in all major markets where it decides to compete, including smartphones, TVs and even tablets.
As a result set top makers are going to have to consolidate like their customers, given that most are mid-sized rather than large players by global standards. They have to follow their customers in order to cover all the bases and be capable of supplying multiscreen multiplatform multi-device products that meet all their needs, while also attaining the necessary economies of scale to be competitive.
Although we have focused on the set top here, similar considerations apply to all vendors that have traditionally specialized in pay TV and are still stuck in that ghetto. This means we exclude big hitters like Ericsson, Cisco and Alcatel-Lucent, which may or may not have problems of their own but are not exposed purely to pay TV. Vulnerable companies apart from Arris, Pace, Technicolor, Humax, Netgem and ADB, whose business is predominantly set tops or gateways include Harmonic, Sea Change and possibly also Kudelski. This is not to say these vendors are all set for imminent collapse, but will have to reinvent themselves soon in order to avert long term decline.