Our partners over at the Online Reporter in the US got their hands on a Qplay net-top box this week, and was eager to unbox and test out the newest streaming media player. Qplay is a streaming media player that plugs into a TV set via an HDMI cord and lets a viewer stream video on the set using an iPad as a remote, via a Qplay app.
The name stems from the fact that users can create curated ‘queues’ of video from across online sources to play on the TV set. The NTB was conceived of and created by TiVo founders Jim Barton and Mike Ramsay, who have been working on the device since 2012.
The Qplay player ‘ had been erroneously reported as an HDMI dongle ‘ is more physically akin to a Roku or Apple TV, though it functions much like Google’s dongle, Chromecast. Qplay comes with a $50 price tag, a bit more expensive than Chromecast, but in line with the streaming sticks that Roku offers. As mentioned above, it uses an iPad app for navigation and control.
Qplay’s creators have launched the device in an ‘early adopter’ phase, meaning there are still plenty of details to work on, and the limited device support is certainly one of them.
Here are the immediate reactions using the device, as reported by Kendra Chamberlain:
The pros:
Content selection is pretty diverse, given its limitations. Luckily for Qplay, YouTube is a window into a vast, entertaining and at times strange world of short-form entertainment, that these days runs the gamut from viral bedroom confessional to professionally-produced, practically TV series.
Links to YouTube/Google account, Twitter, Facebook. That gives the app a pretty in-depth and accurate pool of video to pull from.
It is blissfully without ads. The YouTube ads don’t carry over onto the TV screen.
It aggregates content across sources. This is the biggest difference between Qplay and Chromecast. The Chromecast app lets you queue video, but only on an app-by-app basis. Qplay, on the other hand, brings all the content, from all of its participating content sources, together under one interface. This is a forward thinking approach to long and short-form Web video content, in which consumers can seek out videos that vary in terms of source, length and quality, all in one video consuming session.
The cons:
There are limited content sources. No Netflix or Hulu or HBO Go, like Chromecast has. Qplay said it’s working on adding Netflix now.
We think the interface is tricky, and navigating through the app and getting it to properly communicate with the TV was tough initially. This is an ultra-beta release, though, so some glitchiness is expected. Qplay offers a handy, quick tutorial video on how to use the app, which we watched twice and eventually figured out how to stream videos to the TV set. There was a bit of a lag, but that’s expected.
Limited multi-tasking on the tablet while content is streaming to the TV set. We could easily exit the Qplay app and use other apps on the tablet without interrupting the video stream on the TV set, but moving around the video playlists in the Qplay app proved problematic, as tapping on videos initiated a second stream to the tablet, meaning there were two videos playing at once. Also, the user isn’t able to add videos to the queue without interrupting the video stream on the TV set, which we found frustrating.
Creating queues requires a lean forward. The user cannot add a video to a queue without tapping on it, and ultimately initiating playback on either the tablet or the TV set. We found we had to browse through the lists, start a video, then quickly add the video to the queue. After about 10 minutes we had compiled a list of videos, which we then tried to stream to the TV set in a lean back setting.
There are definitely some glitches to work out. Unfortunately, we were unable to get our whole queue to stream to the TV. Instead, the NTB seemed to get stuck on the first video in the list, which was a video entitled ‘160 Best Arnold Schwarzenegger Movie Quotes.’ It began erratically restarting itself. And we let it play out, hoping that at the end of the video it would jump to the next video in the queue. It didn’t. Instead, it started the Schwarzenegger video from the beginning. We also tried to jump to other videos in the queue manually. The new video would play for a few seconds before the NTB would revert back to the Schwarzenegger video. We were caught in a Schwarzenegger time loop. It was, in fact, the only video we were able to play in full on the device from my queue, but had no problem streaming Qplay’s already curated playlists.
As mentioned before, the device is in an early release phase, so the interface glitches will be worked out in time, we hope, though they did pose a significant obstacle to our viewing session. The overall idea is spot on: aggregate online video into one interface, enable consumers to mix and match, and create their own programming lists of Web video, which are then played back on the TV set in a lean back experience.
At this stage, it’s not immediately obvious how Qplay has improved on the experiences offered by Apple TV, Roku or Chromecast. As a YouTube streaming player, Chromecast’s experience is superior. Until Qplay adds more content, and users can more fully take advantage of the content aggregation features of the app, comparison of the two seems unwarranted.