Qualcomm Atheros (QCA) says that routers, gateways and other access points with its new MU-MIMO-capable 11ac WiFi chips will significantly and noticeably increase speeds for all devices such as tablets and smartphones, whether those devices have MU-MIMO or not ‘ even for devices with the older 11n or 11g versions of WiFi.
QCA’s VP of marketing, Todd Antes, said MU-MIMO (Multi-User, Multiple-Input, Multiple-Output (as opposed to Single User MIMO ‘ SU MIMO), increases a WiFi network’s efficiency by two- to three-times. QCA now offers WiFi chips for specific types of devices, all of which have MU-MIMO technology. Each chip in the family is for a specific type of device.
Access points ‘ routers, gateways and such ‘ with MU-MIMO can send and receive in MU-MIMO mode and do all the processing for it. MU-MIMO capable chips in client devices such as tablets and smartphones can receive in MU-MIMO mode.
Other vendors have told us that MU MIMO is not going to make that much difference, and that they were not pursuing in urgently, so if the Qualcomm Atheros claims are true, then it may have a significant technology lead.
We asked Antes how QCA’s new WiFi chips are different from WiFi chips recently announced by its rivals. He said that MU-MIMO is an IEEE industry standard (part of the AC standard), which QCA has embedded in all its WiFi chips. With MU-MIMO QCA does not need additional pricey WiFi chips to achieve increased speeds as Broadcom does with its newly announced 11ac platform. As to whether client devices ‘ tablets and smartphones ‘ need MU-MIMO to achieve maximum speed, he said that they do, but that QCA is already embedding MU-MIMO into all its 11ac chips and in smartphones. Of course actually fitting multiple antennas into phones is another matter.
Although MU-MIMO must be in the client device for maximum speeds, non-MU-MIMO client devices still get an improved performance and increase speeds he says. Antes likened it to driving on a freeway that has express lanes for cars with multiple occupants. That also benefits drivers in the remaining non-express lanes because they don’t have to compete for space with the multi-occupant cars.
Antes said MU-MIMO is part of the mainstream way forward for 11ac. It is based on an IEEE industry standard and can be tested by the WiFi Alliance for interoperability with other chipmakers’ WiFi chips that have and don’t have MU-MIMO. He said MU-MIMO will improve WiFi capacity for all users ‘ even legacy devices that contain 11g or 11n WiFi chips. It will especially increase the efficient use of spectrum in hotspots with large crowds such as stadiums, airports and coffee shops.
The impression that Antes gives is that in time MU-MIMO will come as standard in all 11ac WiFi chips and QCA has had a jump start on the market. He may be right.
The benefits of MU-MIMO will be instantly obvious to enterprises and to what Antes called the metro market, such as airports, stadiums and coffee shops where lots of people are trying to connect to the Net simultaneously. Buyers of routers for those will instantly see MU-MIMO’s advantages because they have to deal with the problem of WiFi congestion every time there’s a crowd. That same situation exists now or will exist in most homes where the number of WiFi devices connected simultaneously is expected to increase from about seven now to about 20 by 2020.
From a user’s perspective, where each 11ac client device with SU MIMO only gets about one-third of 350 Mbps ‘ about 117 Mbps, with MU-MIMO they can get 303 Mbps. That’s because with single user MIMO WiFi, clients are served one at a time sequentially in tiny slices of time and during those slices only one device is sending and receiving, and if it is slow, due to attenuation, interference or the nature of that device, it takes longer. The end result is that the WiFi network has a drop in throughput and capacity as more devices join the network. This situation is made worse by the streams of HD video that are streaming to multiple devices simultaneously. By contrast, according to QCA, MU-MIMO enables simultaneous transmission to groups of clients at a time ‘ up to three or four, making more efficient use of available WiFi bandwidth and speeding up transmissions.
Antes gives the impression that eventually all 11ac chips will support MU-MIMO and that his company is the first of many that will follow. The fact that MU-MIMO is supported by Qualcomm’s Snapdragon processors, which are used in most smartphones, indicates that MU-MIMO is here to stay and that routers and gateways that support MU-MIMO will have an advantage in the marketplace.
The real situation is a little more complex, as there are already MIMO benefits such as beamforming and diversity, which improve throughput, and these will disappear and be replaced by the benefits of MU-MIMO, we don’t think you can have both simultaneously. We know that QCA does not have chips which use beamforming, only Quantenna, and latterly Broadcom have this feature. So really we have to have real world test to be sure whether or not Antes is right. In fact this chip is cited as having both implicit and explicit beamforming (you need explicit to get the faster speeds) and as far as we know this is the first time QCA has offered this, so it may be attributing faster speed to the MU effect and it actually may be being achieved through its first beamforming.
Client devices like smartphones, tablets and smart TVs only need the MU-MIMO receive capability and they do not do any of the processing for MU-MIMO, which we understand to be considerable.
Chipmakers don’t like talking prices with anyone except equipment makers but QCA gives the impression that its implementation of MU-MIMO in WiFi chips that are intended for routers and gateways will cost less than multi-set platforms such as the one Broadcom has announced.
MU-MIMO is one of three new industry standard technologies that are in Wave 2 of the 11ac version of WiFi:
MU-MIMO is said to increase the theoretical maximum WiFi speeds from 3.47 Gbps to 6.93 Gbps, but MIMO already appears to do this, as other companies have pushed out the figure of 7Gbps.
QCA’s MU-MIMO compliant chips are the QCA 9980 and QCA9982 for routers and gateways and the QCA6174 for tablets and smartphones, and both are available this quarter. It also has the QCA9378 for smart TVs and set-tops and the QCA6574 for the automotive market, as well as the QCA9990 and QCA9992 for the enterprise market.