For a habitually secretive company, which has often hidden behind its famous non-disclosure agreements, Qualcomm has been making a lot of public pronouncements recently. First came its warning, in a quarterly filing with the Securities and Exchange Commission, that there was risk surrounding the renewal of its patent licensing deal with Nokia, due in April 2007. Then came a body blow to the WiMAX community, one of whose less public agendas is to reduce the royalties payable by the mobile industry to Qualcomm by proposing a non-CDMA alternative for wireless communications. This took the form of a licensing deal with Soma Networks, a broadband wireless start-up that recently announced its SoftAir FlexMAX WiMAX range ‘ not significant in revenue terms, but the first time that Qualcomm had announced a patents agreement for its OFDM technologies. This is clearly the bugle call that will spark a war that has been brewing ever since the CDMA giant acquired Flarion and moved itself into the OFDM space in earnest.
While most of its licensing deals remain shrouded in non-disclosure, this one was accompanied by aggressive public statements ‘ boiling down to a simple message, which could be paraphrased as: ‘We know the world is moving gradually from CDMA to OFDM technologies, and we aim to have as strong an intellectual property basis in the latter as we do in the former.’
This will not be possible of course ‘ however, strong Qualcomm’s intellectual property in OFDM may be, and that is far from clear as yet, it will never have the control that it has enjoyed in CDMA, a technology that in commercially applicable terms it invented. But unlike many companies that seek to make a quick dollar from patents, the chipmaker is an excellent technologist and usually constructs its intellectual property fortresses on foundations of stone. We can assume that it has some real assets, acquired from Flarion and other sources. At worst for Qualcomm, they will at least be sufficiently credible to require lengthy legal testing before they can be discounted. Amid the years of test cases and infringement suits that could follow this initial declaration, Qualcomm could achieve at least one goal, to destabilize the OFDM sector and chip away at the perception that WiMAX is the natural front runner in a next generation OFDM-based wireless world.
Soma will certainly not be winning popularity contests in the WiMAX Forum. The wording of the official statements surrounding its deal with Qualcomm are significant because they explicitly mention WiMAX. Had they not, the agreement could have been dismissed as an extension of existing arrangements between the two companies in the CDMA space, since the smaller organization makes a platform that can support multiple air interfaces. As it is, Soma said: ‘As a principal member of the WiMAX Forum it is crucial that Soma Networks guarantees our customers that we have rights to key patents essential for OFDMA standards.’
This is just a small first step. Soma’s judgement that Qualcomm does, indeed, hold key patents relevant to 802.16e will not carry much weight if that opinion is not backed up by larger licensees. After all, Wi-Lan, another company that was claiming ownership of fundamental intellectual property within OFDM and WiMAX, gained far larger supporters, notably Fujitsu, without taking a dominant position in the IP game. But as Rupert Baines, head of marketing at WiMAX chip specialist ‘ and close Intel partner ‘ PicoChip, put it: ‘This is a major step forward in the IPR battle to come over OFDM. This is explicitly a declaration of war.’
Baines echoes the private views of many WiMAX chip designers, that this is ‘an early declaration of check’ in a lengthy and bloody chess game to come, which started when Qualcomm acquired Flarion and made clear its intention to set up its own challenge for a major portion of the OFDM market.
‘By expanding our agreement with Qualcomm, we ensure that we have clear rights to use Qualcomm’s intellectual property within our recently announced SoftAir FlexMAX solution,’ said Yatish Pathak, Soma’s CEO. ‘We have a standard now, and we have to make sure for our operator customers that we have [intellectual property] protection. Other companies can sit around and wonder what will happen, but operators will not make a buying decision when there is uncertainty that surrounds a technology.”
Uncertainty is Qualcomm’s trump card of course. There are rarely black and white answers to intellectual property questions. Nobody is really sure, even after months of lawyers and engineers sifting through specifications, how strong a patents claim Qualcomm may have in 802.16e. Key WiMAX elements, especially those inherited with Korea’s Wi-Bro, have been developed with the aim of breaking free from Qualcomm royalties ‘ one of the reasons the Korean government funded the creation of Wi-Bro in the first place ‘ yet IEEE committee members tell horror stories of how hard it has been to exclude CDMA techniques from the specs, let alone OFDM patents that may subsequently be pounced upon by Qualcomm. The issue will be decided, almost certainly, by a long series of legal battles, and in that respect, the CDMA giant is likely eventually to find itself forced to compromise, faced with the combined market weight and budgets of Intel, Cisco and the GSM community. Indeed, in many ways its aggressive stance may prove a positive for WiMAX, giving the diverse vendors a unifying issue and also increasing its attractiveness to Nokia and Ericsson ‘ which may be suspicious of the possible impact of 802.16e on their core cellco base, but which are determined, as their recent actions in the European Commission show, to reduce the power of Qualcomm in the 3G sector and to support technologies in which the chipmaker can collect little revenue.
But before legal defeats, forced compromises or antitrust body rulings can become a real risk for Qualcomm, there is a breathing space of at least a year when uncertainty can be exploited to heighten operator and vendor caution about WiMAX. Even if it turns out not, in fact, to hold unavoidable patents in 802.16e, it will gain time to prolong the interest in CDMA2000 and pitch its own OFDM platform, which it will certainly control, as a superior alternative to WiMAX. This latter approach has suffered recently. The company has tried to push its own OFDM under a standards banner by resurrecting the IEEE 802.20 or Mobile-Fi activities, which have always been heavily oriented around Flarion technology, but this has come under IEEE scrutiny because it may be breaking the standards body’s rules on a single entity dominating a specification. Therefore it may be taking a renewed interest in asserting its IP rights elsewhere.
One of the key achievements that would put 802.16e on the tier one operator map in the next wireless generation would be a royalty-free handset (or other popular subscriber devices), which would shift the economics of mobile broadband, and in so doing, hasten the migration away from CDMA technologies at the turn of the decade. The possibility is real to achieve this breakthrough, provided the fundamental patent holders in 802.16e choose to exercise restraint in how they enforce their IP. The promise of that no-royalty handset must be kept alive for 802.16e to increase its momentum with large players, but the Soma deal is an early indication that Qualcomm will not let this happen without a bloody fight.