It was almost inevitable that Qualcomm, as the consummate chip maker in CDMA networks, would enter the chip market for one of the markets that it is keen to annex, that of mobile TV datacast services.
It duly came into the market very late this week with a chip called the Universal Broadcast Modem, which is not quite universal, supporting as it does, just three of the world’s leading mobile broadcast standards, instead of all four.
Predictably the one technology that is missing is T-DMB, which is mostly a technology driven by Samsung, Qualcomm’s long term Korean partner, and LG Electronics, with services already launched in Korea and some life, in the way of trials, happening in Europe.
That means the UBM chip has support for Qualcomm’s own FLO technology, as well as for Digital Video Broadcasting – Handheld (DVB-H) and Japan’s Integrated Services Digital Broadcasting – Terrestrial (ISDB-T), creating a common platform that handset manufacturers can leverage to address multiple standards.
A number of chip companies have put together multiple protocol offerings on a single chip with market leader DiBcom offering DVB-H and T-DMB on a single chip, Israeli player Siano pushing CMOS chips which can receive and decode DVB-H, DAB, DAB Enhanced Packet Mode and T-DMB with just the Japanese ISDB-T format used in Japan missing, while Texas Instrument’s Hollywood chip being built to service both DVB-H and ISDB-T.
One of the key capabilities this gives handset makers is a common architecture for the handset for both FLO phones and DVB-H phones, which hasn’t been possible before, and this opens the opportunity of one handset offering both services, especially in the US where Qualcomm owns spectrum for FLO and where Aloha Partners and SES Americom are offering DVB-H in neighboring spectrum.
It would be more difficult to offer both services on a single phone using the Crown Castle subsidiary Modeo’s network, which will also operate DVB-H services in the US, because that would require a separate antenna and radio tuner for each service, but Alohas network is so similar to the spectrum that Qualcomm is using, discarded old analog TV spectrum in 700 MHz, that a single radio should do the trick.
A move like this could make it a ‘no brainer’ for all the US cellcos to offer MediaFLO using Qualcomm chips, since it would mean that they could also offer DVB-H services on the same device.
If that happened, and another US cellco declared in favor of FLO, then the existing chip companies would need to rethink their strategy and go cap in hand to Qualcomm to license what was initially a proprietary set of protocols for MediaFLO, but which has rapidly been pushed into a standard format, or they would risk being shut out of the US mobile TV handset market by dint of not having FLO capability.
The benefits to Qualcomm are huge, not only would it make it a straight marketing fight between its MediaFLO service and the DVB-H services in the US, but it would keep the chip and handset costs down for other countries that were considering a launch of MediaFLO, such as the UK where News Corp is going to try it out, later this year.
The ISDB-T part of the chip is equally explained when we add the fact that KDDI is expected to offer a MediaFLO trial in Japan, but will certainly be offering an ISDB-T service. This means that Qualcomm could pick up that chip business on the same basis, that the chip can be used for both services, while no-one other than Samsung and LG have a MediaFLO license so they would be Qualcomm’s only competition.
Interestingly almost all of these services are based on COFDM, the signaling technology that Qualcomm is building an intellectual property play in, and we can see the future intellectual property battle forming against arch rival Nokia. Nokia has pushed the DVB-H standard and currently there is an MPEG Licensing Authority patent pool being established for the technology.
If Qualcomm not only claims some of the underlying COFDM patents that underpin all datacasting, but also some of the chip making DVB-H patents, it could put forward an argument that it deserves a big chunk of the DVB-H patent pool despite Nokia making the running for many years in the underlying DVB-H technology. The outcome could mean chip dominance in mobile TV falling to Qualcomm, despite its late arrival on the scene.
Qualcomm says that the UBM is designed as a companion to its Mobile Station Modem baseband chipsets, but also can be used with other products, so for that, read it doesn’t have to be in a CDMA phone, where Qualcomm dominates, but could just as easily be in a UMTS phone.
The chip offers support for the entire UHF bandwidth from 470 MHz to 862 MHz and can tune either 5, 6, 7 and 8 MHz channel bandwidths and can support both single and multi frequency networks. Samples are due in the first quarter of 2007, almost two years behind DibCom’s first DVB-H chips.