Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

14 June 2006

Qualcomm sues again, Nokia rebuts and shrugs

Qualcomm filed yet another complaint with the US Trade Commission targeting Nokia, claiming it has engaged in unfair trade practices by the importing certain mobile handsets that Qualcomm says infringe on one or more of six Qualcomm patents.

Nokia immediately hit back calling Qualcomm’s pointing out that most of the patents are already covered by prior agreements, and that it still has a current license agreement that doesn’t expire until April 9th 2007. Nokia says that it, and Qualcomm, are in active negotiations to extend, or replace, the current agreements.

Nokia said that these repetitive legal actions, over GSM technologies which have been around for years just show how worried Qualcomm is over the current 3G UMTS patent negotiations. Nokia added that times have changed since it last licensed Qualcomm patents, and that it now has over 10,500 patent families of its own to consider with over 220 essential patents in GSM alone.

In effect if Qualcomm continues to insist that it can charge more for its patents than other essential patent holders, there’s going to be a war, and it’s unlikely that the US Trade Commission would really want to get involved supporting a US company that is well known to be a patents bully.

Qualcomm has requested that the ITC institute an investigation into Nokia’s imports and issue an Exclusion Order to bar them from the US. Qualcomm said it expects an ITC investigation to commence in July and that the case will be tried in the first half of next year. But we think that’s nothing more than bravado.

Qualcomm has also sued Nokia for patent infringement in the UK in May, alleging that Nokia’s sales of products which are capable of operating in accordance with the GPRS and EDGE standards, infringe two of Qualcomm’s patents in the UK.