Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

17 July 2014

Quantum Dots may rejuvenate LCD screen technology

A breakthrough new technology called Quantum Dots could be combined with existing LCD manufacturing processes, to give a dramatic improvement in color depth, power usage at the same price point as today’s LCDs. That is according to one of the leading suppliers in the market called QD Vision.

The outcome would be that the OLED market could stall, and existing LCD LED TVs will rapidly be replaced by the new devices. Eventually devices may come on the market that use the new Quantum Dot technology in LEDs, but this is likely to be even further away than economical OLED screens.

DisplaySearch brought our attention to the market when it released a report predicting quantum dot market penetration to reach 26% in smartphones, 15% in tablets and 9% in TVs by 2020. The report notes that cost is the largest barrier to adoption, but we thought this the right time to take a closer look at the variants of quantum dot technology as they are poised to revolutionize LCD screens ‘ and if that process takes off, then expect the DisplaySearch numbers to need recasting.

OLED has been thought of as the next generation of display for a while now, with its improved brightness and color fidelity. But as we know, OLED panels are expensive, largely due to their manufacturing process. While this is still the case, we don’t see LCD being usurped as the panel of choice, and now quantum dot (QD) technology looks ready to extend the dominance of LCD panels for years to come.

While full QD-LED displays are currently unfeasibly expensive to manufacture and sell to a consumer as a rival to OLED, the dots themselves have found their way into backlighting technology that is dramatically improving the color performance of bulk standard LCD panels ‘ without increasing the BOM in many cases.

This is massively disruptive for OLED, as QD-LCD threatens to completely undermine OLED’s claims for superior color and brightness performance while still being far cheaper to buy and produce alongside the benefits of lower power consumption and improved brightness compared to standard LCDs. If QD gets its foot in the door, we can’t see OLED taking off unless its sale price can be greatly reduced.

A quantum dot is a nanocrystal particle made of semiconductor materials, usually silicon or germanium. Due to its tiny size, less than 100nm and as low as 1.5nm, a quantum dot will exhibit quantum mechanical properties. Specifically, it will produce quantum confinement because the radii of the dot is less than Bohr’s radius; the approximate probable distance between the proton and electron in a hydrogen atom.

The dots work by confining an exciton, the name for the quasiparticle formed when a semiconductor absorbs a photon, within a space smaller than its Bohr radius. The exciton can be triggered by light or an electrical current to transfer energy and create luminescence. Different sized dots will emit different colors of light, with larger dots producing visible light at one end of the spectrum (red) and smaller dots producing the other (violet).

To make the eventual OLED replacement, a QD-LED screen, you sandwich billions of dots between a layer of electron-transporting and hole-transporting material and then cause the electrons to flow towards the holes by applying an electric field. This causes the electrons to collide with the electron holes and combine to form an exciton, which releases photons ‘ which produces the light. Color is controlled by changing the energy gap between the two layers. The system operation is very similar to OLED but a full QD-LED display would not require a backlight, which represents a huge saving in terms of its power consumption ‘ a key area for mobile devices.

The dots themselves are not particularly hard to manufacture. They can be produced in quantities of hundreds of kilograms, but the hard part is creating a QD-LED that can be used in a display. Centrifugal phase separation is one method used to manufacture QD arrays, but it is not able to produce multi-color QD-LEDS or the multi-LED patterns needed to compensate for this.

An alternative method of production is called contact printing, and is a solvent-free process which is necessary due to the organic material used in QDs being sensitive to solvents. The process suspends the dots in a solution that can be transferred to the desired surface, before evaporating the solution to leave a dot-coated organic monolayer. These monolayers can be combined into a multicolor QD-LED.

But dots can be used in other forms than an LED, which are much more disruptive according to their pricing. Films of dots can be created that act as filters for backlights, which allow LCD engineers to calibrate their displays for a better picture ‘ a much cheaper process for augmenting the existing LCD product with the benefits afforded by the dots, instead of redesigning the entire manufacturing process and supply chain to accommodate QD-LEDs.

But one company, called QD Vision, produces a product called Color IQ, which uses quantum dots to enhance the color fidelity of LCD panels. It notes that LCD panels can only display between 60 and 70% of the NTSC color standard, but claims that by using Color IQ the LCD panels can achieve 100% of the color. The Color IQ system currently uses 30nm dots, which are used as a color filter for the LED backlight to prevent crosstalk between color channels. As of last November, it has shipped 2 million Color IQ optic systems. Sony uses Color IQ in its 3 of last year’s Bravia range of TVs, in both Full HD and 4K/UHD. And it is this approach that is likely to rejuvenate LCD manufacture rapidly.

QD Vision says that thanks to the efficiency of the dots, BOM and complexity can be reduced in manufacturing most types of displays, lowering the overall cost of producing LCD panels. QD Vision says its product is the only way to achieve 100% NTSC compliance while maintaining Energy Efficiency Index compliance.

QD Vision currently has deals with TP Vision for 27-inch computer monitors, ‘delivering OLED-like color performance at the cost structure of LCD.’ The largest Chinese LCP panel maker, BOE, said it would use Color IQ alongside LED optics from ShineOn in its 2014 LCM monitor product lines, showcasing a 23 and 27-inch panel at Computex.

Another company called Nanosys has used dots to manufacture a film for LCD backlights, which it calls QDEF (QD Enhancement Film). By including only the required size of dot, the film filters the backlight to only let strong RGB light through, instead of the traditional backlights that typically let through a lot of blue and yellow light, but are weak on red and green ‘ which inhibits the quality of the displayed picture. With the highly saturated RGB backlight, LCD panels can be tuned and color graded to display 100% of the NTSC standard. QDEF filters already pass the 30,000 hour lifetime specification demanded by most TV makers.

Amazon has also used dots in the display for its Kindle Fire HDX tablet, although unsourced reports suggest that manufacturing cost of the QD-LEDs (notably not a film or optics approach) was relatively high ‘ suggesting that this approach might not be mature enough for a mass rollout even across the smaller sizes of panel.

In the DisplayMate hardware review, the HDX lost out to the latest Nexus 7 tablet in terms of picture quality too ‘ a troubling development considering that QD is meant to improve the color gamut and brightness of an LCD panel but Google has managed to achieve both of these criteria (including the 100% RGB color gamut) using Low Temperature Poly Silicon (LTPS) and upgraded LEDs in the backlight. However, it is likely that as time progresses the QD tech will improve, and it is also possible that Amazon just didn’t do a very good job of showcasing quantum dots in a tablet ‘ and as it won’t specify exactly how it implemented its QD-LEDS, we suspect this might be the case.

However, in the Flagship Tablet category of DisplayMate’s test, the 8.9-inch HDX surpassed the screen quality of the Nexus 10 and iPad Air, suggesting that it might be the size of the screen that inhibits the quality of the picture. Given that the other implementations of QD tech have appeared on computer monitors and TVs, it might be the small size to blame for not winning the smaller-screen showdown, as the 7-inch HDX is the smallest commercial device that has made it to market using QD-LEDs as opposed to the QD backlight films. The next iPhone is also heavily tipped to include a QD display.