Back in the pre-iTunes days when online music was mostly pirated, we ran stories about Napster and its exciting adventure against the establishment, and then, once it was (quite rightly) crushed by the Supreme Court on behalf of the music industry, it went legitimate and was sold off.
We’re not so sure how exciting Napster is today and we suspect that the news that it has been sold once again, to Rhapsody, is simply the gradual consolidation of the online music industry into fewer and fewer collections. This time it has been bought by a service which itself may not have too much life left in it, under fire as it is from the dual free streaming services of both Pandora and Spotify and newbies MOG and Rdio, as well as the all-powerful iTunes store and a variety of other commercial music collections, not least of which includes one from Sony and the Nokia Music Store, which is set to re-emerge after merging with Microsoft services, as a decent alternative on WP7 devices.
A major new rival will also emerge from Google through Android Market, and also Spotify has now struck a music deal with Facebook for sharing music through the social network, none of which bodes well for independent music subscription services.
Most of the words written this week focused on the slightly mischievous beginnings of Napster and its founder Shawn Fanning, who single handedly disrupted the music industry, but this looks to be a matter of tying two bricks together and asking ‘Now will they float?’
Rhapsody has been around in some form or another since 2001, beginning life as Listen.com, which RealNetworks bought in 2003 and brought aggressively to market as it landed major record labels. It only survived as a viable rival to iTunes for about 4 years when it re-jigged things, with MTV throwing its lot in with RealNetworks on the back of a contract with Verizon Wireless, which mashed in its own music service. The new jointly held business was called Rhapsody International ‘ international because it was planning to go around the world signing similar deals ‘ but none ever happened. What did happen was that in 2008 Yahoo decided to drop its own music service in favor of one from Rhapsody.
The problem was always going to be when Apple decided to let Verizon have the iPhone ‘ music lovers who happened to want to play music on their phone were likely to shift off the Verizon platform to iTunes.
In April 2010 the company was spun out on its own and we predicted that it would fade out of existence as Verizon looked to Apple. So when that happened in January, and with Sprint (which has never been a Rhapsody customer but might have been a prospect) now getting the iPhone, there are few opportunities for a subscription music service apart from Android. In a world which now expects to have their music on their phones, not a second device, Rhapsody is redundant. It’s last chance was to be acquired by Google as the basis of its own Android Market based music store ‘ but that was out of the equation last May when Google announced that it had begun work on its own. Google bought Simplify Media in May but that was really a media sharing App which can tap into an iTunes account and share music. Google may still need more music licenses, so Google still might buy the music rights of both Rhapsody and its new purchase Napster, if a merger or buyout doesn’t invalidate those rights, and if those rights give Google what it wants in a new service. Perhaps this merger is anticipating such a move by Google, but without that outlet Rhapsody has little life left in it we fear.
When we last looked at Rhapsody when it was integrated into RealNetworks it was burning through about $50 million of capital each year and it only had about $50 million left. It offers a deal for just $10 a month on a mobile phone plus a PC and has about 13 million tracks. Napster has around 15 million tracks so that overall merged number should now go up. It already has its own Android market application which it always hoped would replace its strategic relationship with Verizon, but if Google builds its own service, it could potentially throw music apps out of Android, or certainly eclipse it.
It was always thought that the global distribution of MTV, which operates on 135 television networks around the world and reaches 500 million people would have provided a basis for recommending the Rhapsody service, but so far this has not materialized.
There is no information on how much revenue and how many subscribers Napster will add to Rhapsody, but it claims to have 800,000 paying customers of its own, and Napster is clearly now down significantly below that number, despite deals to put free trials for Napster on most SmartTVs, including those from Samsung, and its inclusion bundled on Google TV, which has so far been a flop.
Best Buy, who bought Napster for $121 million in 2008, has swapped Napster for an unspecified minority ownership in Rhapsody, but whether that will be worth anything at any point in the future is another matter.