Shares of Research in Motion (RIM) jumped 14% after the announcement that it has reached a settlement with NTP in its long running patent infringement saga. Despite the company paying out $612.5 million to settle the case and license the NTP technology, it resumed a value of over $15 billion, having fallen as low as $12 billion over the darkest days of the case.
No-one ever really expected the service to be switched off but it was a possibility which the court finally didn’t need to reach for.
But RIM has been more highly rated and its fall from grace is not entirely due to the fears of its mobile email system being switched off. It has been living off brand for a long time, and momentum, but there are devices and services which can do a lot more than the ubiquitous Blackberry that is the company’s mainstay product.
Nokia and Microsoft have been making inroads with cellular operators while Palm has been growing with a product line that is similar to the Blackberry.
But analysts can now factor out the court case and try to get a realistic handle on whether or not the Blackberry RIM brand is strong enough to fight off these competitors. Our view is that it won’t be, but that its brand and its carrier relationships will carry it for quite a while yet, and it can always play catch up technologically with the competition. Some analysts are saying that there is currently pent up demand in the system with orders being held up by the court case, but they are likely to shake out within a quarter or so.
The company has promised a raft of announcements and partnerships during the next 30 days that were all held up by the court case. The dispute was running for four years and towards the end, the 3 million or so US customers were getting nervous about whether or not their mobile email service might get switched off.
A previous settlement had fallen through at the much lower rate of $450 million, but RIM pulled out of that deal saying the terms were too harsh.
But the truth is that this is unlikely to be the end of the case. The key patents have been re-examined by the US patent office and although any form of counter suit may have been prohibited by the settlement, if any more NTP patents turn out not to be valid, then RIM will want some, if not all, of its money back.
Also RIM will almost certainly have to raise some money on the back of this surge in its share price, since it only had around $900 million in the bank prior to the settlement.