Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

21 July 2011

Rovi loses second European patent case ‘ investors completely ignore it

Rovi has suffered a second set back in a European court over its EPG patents, once thought to be universally enforceable. But back in March the UK High Court delivered a blow to Rovi over its EPG patents, saying they were not infringed by Virgin Media and more to the point, not valid in the UK.

And we said at the time that the big difference between the US patent system is that in European courts apply a test of what is patentable by asking is it ‘a technical solution to a technical problem.’ In the US, software and business processes have famously been patentable, which is achieved by calling the process a computer program or saying that it relies on a specialist computer, when in fact that is only one way of implementing what is simply an idea. Even in the US, the Bilski case which went to the Supreme Court there is beginning to show that perhaps many US patents are no longer valid either, where they are a broad conceptual patents such as a business idea.

But now Rovi has lost its second major European case in the Netherlands which it brought against cable TV market leader Ziggo. Once again the reason given is that the Dutch court ruled the patent to be invalid in the Netherlands.

There have been a number of Rovi patent cases bubbling under across Europe, and not every country is the same, because Europe does not have a unified patent system. But other companies within the Netherlands have agreed to pay a license to Rovi in the past.

Just as the Virgin decision was being delivered M7’s Canal Digitaal, a 1 million home satellite pay TV platform, finally agreed to pay Rovi a negotiated license to avoid the costs of a court case and elsewhere in Europe Germany’s KDG, Sky Deutschland and Unitymedia are all licensees, along with Canal+ in France, News Corp in the UK, Germany and Italy, and UPC right across Europe, among others. But they will all perhaps now be questioning why some operators in one country pay while others do not have to pay, and almost certainly negotiating pressure will be brought to bear to end or reduce license payments once again.

Rovi therefore has the four largest pay TV operators in Europe ‘ the News Corp controlled Sky branded services (16 million homes), the Liberty Media UPC and Unitymedia cable groups (19 million homes), the 11 million home CanalSat in France, Belgium, Switzerland and parts of Africa and finally Kabel Deutschland with 9 million homes in Germany. Between them they make up 55 million homes in Europe, the great bulk of European pay TV homes and must now be red-face that they were dumb enough not to challenge the Rovi patents. However they may have been enlightened enough to have a most favored nation clause in their contracts, which will mean they pay whatever the lowest licensee pays, and they might argue that this is now nothing, at least in the UK and the Netherlands.

It is usually Rovi’s habit to appeal to the most senior court in the country, but it has made no statement about that as yet and just a week or so back signed a new deal with Toshiba for its smart TVs. However most of the new Rovi agreements not only include its EPG patents, but also use of its TotalGuide online guide to TV programs, which shifts search, discovery and recommendations to the cloud, so it will continue to win renewal deals for its patents, bundled into the TotalGuide deals. So far Rovi’s share price has moved up, rather than down, on the news.

Rovi was formed by the merger of Gemstar with Macrovision, which holds patents which are even weaker in our view and similarly dependent upon being able to patent ideas. Macrovision offered a series of sophisticated content protection products, which largely rely on the ministrations of the Digital Millenium Copyright Act, which has been taken for the basis of law in hundreds of countries now. So that revenue remains safe. More recently the company has bought Sonic Solutions, which had just purchased DiVX.