Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

26 May 2011

Same message, different conclusions for speakers at UK TV summit

The first five slides of almost every presentation at the Connected TV Summit in London last week, were virtually identical ‘ and they came in two flavors ‘ either this is what’s happening and it’s all a disaster, or this is what’s happening and isn’t it great.

Half of the conference was given over to discussing the various merits of what we see as defunct platforms ‘ it was HbbTV versus YouView, versus MHP versus MHEG 5, with nary a mention of Android or MeeGo or Linux. Oh yes and everyone kept saying that there was still a place for the local pay TV operator and broadcaster ‘ said more like a wish than something they truly believed in.

We could have all gone over a set of slides at the door which said that all TVs will end up as connected TVs, that some 730 million broadband lines were capable of bringing HD video to devices, that broadband would opt for tiered service pricing and that in the future, any screen which cannot show TV will be laughed at.

The broadcasters bemoaned all these facts, the analysts and equipment vendors seem to love them and the pay TV operators just wanted to say how tough it all was to actually get this to work.

After those first few sides each speaker’s message deviated. We had people looking at each devices type, so for instance Paul Erickson of IMS Research thought that Blu-ray players were Trojan horses, as were gaming platforms and that they would become the key focuses to bring commercial video over the top to TVs. He also thought that all TV content would be IP within ten years, and fussed over why it couldn’t be five years ‘ of course we agree with him, except it is likely to be at least 15 years. These things take longer than you initially think and this is take it steady Europe, not forge ahead America.

Other speakers such as Tore Meling, Digital Entertainment Director, Canal Digital, the Telenor subsidiary, complained about the task of actually trying to put together such a service ‘ pointing out that the Content owner wants 50%, the CE TV makers wants 50% and his boss wants 50% and there just aren’t enough 50% chunks to go around. ‘Content owners want to negotiate per platform, per territory so it takes a year to put new content on just one new platform.’ Perhaps that’s why everyone is still talking about putting content on an iPad, when clearly (we think so) Android is the big platform to be on. Perhaps that will be next year’s subject.

The other hue and cry came from companies telling us how difficult it is to get new widgets to work on connected TV, and the two companies Irdeto and Verimatrix, side by side on a panel about The Impact of Connected TV standards, were asked to ‘just take care of the security’ both of which agreed that securing content on 20 different tablets, across multiple different broadband types, using different operating environments, made that tough, but it could ‘just about be done,’ with the undertone of ‘just leave all that to us,’ creeping into the conversation.

But throughout the show the various constituencies showed their bias and origins, offering some remarkable beliefs about the future of broadcasting. We got everything from the mantra ‘people are watching more and more linear TV every day,’ to the wonderful new expression ‘device shifting.’ Of course people are NOT watching more TV, and those who are, are watching it in less time using DVRs, so it is becoming a lower percentage of what they do. But Nielsen will tell you that’s what’s happening, if you’re dumb enough to listen and clearly some of the speakers at Connected TV were.

On a panel which featured the great and the good from all walks of broadcasting life, the ITU, the Digital TV Group, Impala the MHEG promoter, Alticast the MHP specialist and the HbbTV Consortium, we would have expected two things ‘ utter clarity on what each of these things could do and a jolly good dust up, with dissenting opinions in every direction. There was Richard Lindsay-Davies, director general of the DTG, which directs UK TV standards; David Cutts, founder member of the International MHEG Promotion Alliance; Anthony Smith-Chaigneau, Chairman of the DVB-GEM Commercial Module, and Jon Piesing, Vice-Chair, HbbTV and Olivier Carmona, Chairman, Compliance & Test Committee, DLNA.

But when it was kicked off with the ludicrous assertion from chairman Anthony Rose, ex-CTO of YouView, that DLNA might have the agenda of becoming a copyright spy on your home network, it was clear that clarity was not going to be forthcoming and instead we were treated to a round of general paranoia from every quarter.

The overwhelming impression from a confused Q&A was that the UK, New Zealand, Hong Kong, Ireland and Australia all would go down an MHEG route, Italy and perhaps one or two others would stick to MHP and HbbTV would pick up the rest. The panel was complacent and had its collective head in the sand and while they were all ‘scared out of their wits,’ by monsters like Google and Apple, they were secretly laughing up their sleeve at them and their IP view of the world and their failure to understand TV.

But of course it is Google and Apple who will define the genuine platforms for IP TV and MHEG, HbbTV and MHP are all just place holders for either broadcasters or pay TV operators. If you asked yourself who are the worst people to control the experience of interactivity on a TV? The answer might be ‘Why the people that have fought tooth and claw to prevent the internet arriving on it’, and that would be broadcasters. We’ll all look back on those standards and have a good laugh in ten years. Well maybe 20 because these things take longer than you initially think.
Whoops was that d’j’ vu?

We were then treated to a full five minutes on how the public found the ‘red button’ interactivity far easier to use than the internet, with just a remote control, when in fact the same members of the public all currently use the internet and iPhones and also navigate the complexities of DVRs with alarming confidence. To say this view is out of touch is to understate how adrift of modern thinking European broadcasters are. The Red Button is a simple ‘open interactivity’ statement followed by ‘select option.’ It’s hard to see a less interactive environment. The most sophisticated transaction is ‘Err.. I want that one.’

This panel and the entire show missed the key point, that what is required is internet class interactivity and that multi-screen takes you into touch environments, which makes complex responses intuitive. It should also take you to the internet, not some walled garden inside the broadcaster. Sure it might take you to an internet walled garden, because the open internet is too confusing on a TV screen, but someone clever (like Apple, Google or TiVo) needs to build the walls to that garden, not to hold people back, but to make choices easier.

We think it was Erickson who said, ‘Once every screen can get internet video, choice will become an obstacle, and the winners are those who makes the experience personal through search, navigation, discovery and recommendation tools which work, but which you hardly notice.’ That’s not going to happen through MHEG, or anything delivered by a broadcaster, because they live on the other side of a time warp, which makes people think 1950s thoughts, at best. Well maybe in 20 years.