Samsung Electronics was making great claims for a new broadcasting technology at CES, regarding a technique called Advanced Vestigial Side Band, which it was pitching to local US broadcasters as a way of bundling digital TV and mobile TV into the same piece of spectrum.
What we can add to the debate though is that this is exactly the same approach that China seems to be taking onboard for its new combined digital and mobile TV standard, which goes by the same name ‘ Vestigial Side Band. Given that Samsung is sharing much of its R&D with China in wireless technologies, it’s likely this is the same technique.
VSB seems to be little more than a way of keeping two modulations going side by side in a single piece of spectrum, which do not share basic modulation techniques and which don’t interfere with one another.
In China this is a combination of a new version of time-domain synchronous OFDM used for mobile TV, with a separate digital TV signal.
But the idea of broadcasters sending out a signal which can offer digital TV and double as a mobile TV delivery would mean that each device would have to have sufficient antenna and radio reception up and down the spectrum from around 470 MHz to at least 700 and perhaps 850 MHz, because that’s where the TV signals are at present. We have to remember that a TV aerial and a TV tuner works across a bigger spectrum chunk than mobile devices are used to. Perhaps this would work for portable devices that plug in to power sockets and have external antenna, but were not sure about handsets.
VSB may be a perfectly good technology for certain conditions such as when clusters of analog TV transmissions are moved into bundles and dropped into digital transmissions in close spectral proximity. That way the reception on a handset would be able to pick up the mobile TV versions with a radio and tuner.
Of course the mobile TV would still need to be time sliced to prevent rapid battery usage and the idea that Samsung can deliver such a system for a mere $100,000 belies the fact that this is probably just the transmitter equipment to divide the signal, not one that offers the underlying mobile modulation and encoding.
Unlike much of the US press that picked up on it, we don’t think this represents another form of mobile TV to rival DVB-H and MediaFLO and it’s likely to be just a side issue.