Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

2 October 2014

Samsung, LG pray Santa will arrive in time to sell LCD TVs

The reports coming out of DisplaySearch, very predictably still continue to peddle the idea that all is fine on the Display front, we still remain seriously sceptical about this.

The idea that LCD panels are in tight supply, which is what DisplaySearch opens with, is the opposite of what it reported in Q2, that there was an element of inventory build-up, which was taking prices down. We cannot help thinking that DisplaySearch is the mouthpiece of Samsung and LG, and reports the wishful thinking of the larger display manufacturers, rather than any kind of objective truth.

The market is supposed to be this shape (see diagram below). Q3 is supposed to suddenly be on a rising slope, but where have the DisplaySearch reports been for the last quarter. The last time it put out a serious LCD Panel report was in June, when the numbers were down, and there were high hopes for the world cup.

Well that may explain the improved shipments in July and August, the panels being ordered to replenish those sold during June and July for the world cup. But it must be obvious that the September rise from sub-14 million devices per month in June (which equates to an annual run rate of under 170 million TVs) to around 18 million a month (and an annual run rate of 216 million TVs) is a rise that comes out of optimism for the coming season, not out of any demand that has been witnessed on the open market. In other words the world cup may have emptied the excess inventory, but only the feeling that “It is business as usual in October” is driving panel shipments now. It would be interesting to know at what price those shipments are being made at.

But that’s not what DisplaySearch says. It says prices are up for mainstream sizes (32, 40, 42, 48, 49 and even 50, 55 inches) and that Samsung and LG have increased their 2014 business plan to 48 million  and 34 million units, respectively.

Given that Sony, Toshiba, Panasonic and Sharp have virtually fallen out of TV manufacture in the past 12 months, rises at those companies are surely down to growing market share, not a growing market. Again DisplaySearch says not. Including those damaged companies in the top 15 TV brands, it says that they produced 15.5 million LCD TVs in August, and that this is the highest number since January, at an annual run-rate of more like 186 million.

We are well aware that you cannot take an annual run rate from a single month in TV sales because of seasonal variation, but the levels that people are talking about getting back to is 235 million TV shipped a year, and it’s nice to see what would happen if there were 12 consecutive months of shipments at a given number when compared to that recent high number.

The most telling fact is the price these TVs are selling for. If UHD still makes up a tiny part of the market and some of these are under $1,000, then HD models are down below $500 and the two driving forces in the market – that a TV comes with a CPU powerful enough to call it a smart TV, so that it can run apps and an internet connection, and the emergence of UHD models – are not seen as enough to drive value in this market.

Yes lower prices will ship devices faster, but if the prices on these devices go down much more, no-one will make any money out of this market, and once price drops are no longer possible, shipments will dry up.

But DisplaySearch says that prices are rising and volumes are rising – and preliminary estimates for September production is 18.7 million units a rise of 9% over this time last year.

Now the market is complex, because it is global and every part of it is at a different point in its development. China has had a subsidy that was driving sales, which has been removed by the government, but the World cup continued to drive TV shipments there – and there are still a lot of homes on older TV technology, which wish to upgrade at the right price. But the growth in that market has been masking a general malaise in the US and Europe, as well as complete saturation in Japan.

When you look at places like Latin America, where pay TV is driven mostly by DTH sales, and if you add the pay TV growth in Russia, and the continued satellite TV phenomena in India, you can see that the globe has remaining hotspots of TV sales growth and it has taken time for the manufacturers to emphasize those product types which sell in those countries.

But the US and European market is not coming back and none of these reports tell us what has happened to second TV sets for the home – at Faultline we think this market died and went to tablets. Nothing below 30 inches is ever mentioned these days by the TV makers despite the fact that 40% of TV sales used to be below this level, and still there has been no shift to composite models – multiple panels per TV that you stick on wall – because manufacturers still think that the large flat screen LCD model offers the best prospects for profit. We’re sure that will change and soon. If the current ramp in supply ends up with bloated inventories that do not sell at Christmas, then it will be time for a rethink.

The 21.1 million level of panel shipments that DisplaySearch predicts (up 15%) for October would be the equivalent to over 250 million TV sets a year, if it went on for 12 months – way beyond prior record levels. We cannot see tablets being used for viewing video reconciled with these shipment levels, unless prices fall to levels which bankrupt more players.

The only reason that this is interesting for the wider audience of Faultline, is that we should know what technology future TV viewing runs on, if we want to plan any kind of delivery network for it and delivery to tablets compared to delivery over 4K TV sets, invite opposite conclusions.

It is fair to say that October is the seasonal peak for TV production as volumes rise for Christmas and Samsung, LGE, Sony, and Chinese, have reduced retail prices (some by double digits) in an attempt to stimulate sell-through admits DisplaySearch.

It tells us that all of the top brands except Chinese TV makers, who are facing fewer working days due to the October National Holidays, are increasing shipments, in Samsung and LGE’s case by more than 40% over the prior month. Oh dear, what will they do if all of those extra sets just don’t sell? Never mind we can just keep cutting prices again – although that way surely lies madness.