Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

23 August 2005

SBC names suppliers, but not the date, for IPTV set tops

SBC Communications this week confidently announced its set top choices ‘ Motorola and Scientific Atlanta – for its coming U-verse triple play, based on Microsoft IPTV and the current fiber extensions to its network under Project Lightspeed.

The decision to go for the two main US cable TV set top suppliers will come as a blow to all IP TV set top makers, especially leading French consumer electronics manufacturer Thomson.

Thomson is understood at present to be the only company on the market that is supplying set top devices that work with Microsoft IPTV, and the two chosen suppliers have issued no shipment dates.

However even Thomson’s devices are expensive and do not support the entire gamut of promised Microsoft IPTV services which are not likely to be released by Microsoft until mid 2007 anyway (see separate story).

The contracts as awarded to give equal market opportunity to both vendors and will continue through to the end of 2008. Either these contracts start at the end of this year or early next when the SBC service is supposed to go into controlled release. ‘At this time,’ went the SBC statement, ‘SBC expects to use Motorola set-top boxes initially when it scales the service’ – so not at launch – ‘with Scientific-Atlanta set-top boxes soon thereafter.’

SBC goes on about the set tops being tunerless, which is pretty na’ve given that all IPTV set tops are tunerless. What they really mean by this is that the final set top should be able to cope with multiple video streams sent to one set-top box, but this becomes a function of how much processing power they have in them for decoding and screen addressing, rather than how many tuners they have. In cable TV, even digital cable, it is a simple matter of tuning to the right frequency for a channel, since all channels come from a separate part of an 850 MHz piece of spectrum inside the cable.

SBC makes a key point in that movies stored on DVR set tops will take up about 50% of the space of existing DVR’s because the service will use either Microsoft’s own VC-1 or the standard H.264 (MPEG 4) instead of MPEG 2.

But the statement vary carefully does not mention exactly which functions will be available from the service launch, and comments like the set tops ‘will be software upgradeable to add later function’ and ‘The platform allows for future capabilities beyond what’s in the market today,’ suggest that much of the function will be added later.

The statement also reminds us that back in March, SBC awarded Scientific-Atlanta a contract to supply encoders too, which it says are now in testing. Confidential sources have told Faultline that these are also unlikely to be ready for the launch of the service and SBC may have to take more expensive equipment from a few other vendors in the interim.

Then this curious statement came from SBC. ‘Instead of using a traditional broadcast video system, in which all content is continuously sent to every customer’s home, SBC will use a switched IP-video distribution system. In the switched IP-video network, only the content the customer requests is provided to the customer, freeing up bandwidth to be used for other applications.’

In virtually all other IPTV systems around the planet a multicast is set up that goes nowhere near a home, so this statement is really being made to differentiate the system from cable operators. In Microsoft’s system the service still uses a multicast protocol that is sent from a Microsoft server. This is aided by a unicast to send extra data for a rapid channel change.

SBC then promised ‘potential’ features like instant channel changing, tunerless multiple pictures-in-picture and whole-home DVR capabilities, none of which are now likely to be seen on the stripped down launch of the service.

SBC is planning an initial controlled market entry in late 2005 or early 2006 (note the radical departure from its insistence that it will delivery this year). The company plans to add more features and functionality, including whole-home DVR and high-definition functionality, and enter more markets beginning in mid-2006. Financial terms of the set otp contracts were not disclosed.