A group of shareholders are trying to block the Scientific Atlanta (SFA) acquisition by Cisco, claiming that the price just isn’t right. But considering that SFA’s share price never took it above $6 billion in value for the past two years, the $6.9 billion price tag, looks generous rather than flimsy.
Naturally the company says that the claims, filed in Georgia, are without merit and said that the company went through a long and detailed evaluation of price with three separate investment banks in what it described as a “thorough and deliberate process to obtain the best transaction at the highest price available.”
This process will all be documented when it files its proxy statement with the Securities and Exchange Commission, and it is likely that the lawyers will then back off and the deal will go through.
Although the price represented just a few percentage points above the closing price on the day the deal was struck, rumors and press speculation had raised the price considerably in the run up to the deal being cut.
Some of the complaint is down to statements made by SFA executives about not buying back its own shares, because they were aware of a material event. These statements, designed to keep executives on the right side of the law, are now being seen by some as placing an artificial lid on the market price which may have gone wildly up if they had not been made.