The Cabletelevision Advertising Bureau (CAB) says that the collective upfront ad spend from cable networks dropped 6% to $9.6 billion over the summer. This is a $577 million drop from the $10.2 billion spent on last year’s season. This drop mirrors the decline in the broadcast upfront that Faultline covered at the end of July – and is the first sustained drop for four years, falling to below the 2012-13 level. And yet still US forecasters say this year’s TV advertising will be up.
CAB said that the fall is due to clients not committing to advertising long in advance of product launches and marketing initiatives, preferring to hold onto their budgets to spend on immediate needs – opting for programmatic spend (see Faultiine 570) thanks to its increased flexibility. Given that both broadcast and cable upfront has fallen, there are signs that the old model of pre-booked slots and deals is slipping out of favor.
Since 2010, the cable upfront has consistently grown; up 19% for the 2010-11 season, 16% for 2011-12, 5$ for 2012-13, and 4.3% in 2013-14. The 6% shrinkage for the 2014-15 season is therefore quite a turnaround – and it is one that the industry was evidently not expecting.
There are a number of incremental factors that could explain why this is the case, but the rise of time-shifted viewing and the importance of social media to younger viewers and the consequent increase in spending on online video, are the most likely culprits – the latter in particular due to the valuable 18-34 age bracket and advertiser desire to put relevant marketing material in front of their eyes regardless of what format they consume.
In this case, the ability to dynamically alter ad spend as viewing shifts is perhaps inspiring an aversion to large upfront commitments on unproven content. Dynamic spending seems the safer, if a less exclusive option, and allows brands to react to changing circumstances, without exposing themselves to the risks of upfront contracts – despite its discounted nature.
Traditionally a drop in upfront spend was attributed to an increase in scatter spending – advertising purchased nearer the broadcast date – but the industry is now reporting a drop in both. The CAB says that networks will be looking to recoup the upfront shortfall in scatter, but the CEO of Omnicom, the second largest advertising group in the world, said that there was less urgency from clients in both sectors.
Similarly, in Comcast’s Q3 earnings announcement, NBC Universal chief Steve Burke said that he didn’t expect growth in the ad spend of its cable programming. “Our big cable channels are very attractive and powerful, but I just think it is unreasonable to assume that the ratings for those businesses are going to grow if you look over a five or 10 year period.”
“Several big-spending advertisers stated that they anticipated spending fewer ad dollars in this year’s upfront, and nearly all cited increased flexibility as their reason why,” said CAB CEO Sean Cunningham. “Cable networks are meeting this instinct for immediacy with multiscreen brand programs around hit shows.”