Israeli specialist, Siano Mobile Silicon, will show DVB-H and T-DMB working together on one chip at the Consumer Electronics Show in Las Vegas this week, and plans to deliver first commercial silicon in February. The company says that it will be in volume production by mid-2006 and has already sent samples to key customers.
When Siano last demo’d the chip at 3G world in Hong Kong, the company only had microcode support for DVB-H and it now has microcode for both DVB-H and T-DMB.
Siano says that T-DMB is good for about 3 channels of high grade content, but doesn’t think this is likely to be feasible outside of some Far East countries, notably China and Korea and perhaps in Germany, due to spectrum famine.
Siano decided to combine these two protocols because this will enable handset makers to build a single phone and sell it to both DVB-H operators and T-DMB operators in different parts of the world.
‘In places where both networks are likely to emerge in parallel (such as in Germany) it will be possible with two separate extra antennas, to access both services at different times, switching between them,’ says Alon Ironi, CEO of Siano. So a T-DMB delivered service might be transmitted over existing DAB spectrum in either VHF or L-band at either 200 MHz or 1450 MHz, and that could co-exist within a handset, on the same chip, with DVB-H, working either in 1450 L-band or in UHF between 470 MHz and 750 MHz.
So does that mean that some cellcos will offer both services on the same phone, or would that be too expensive? Ironi says that where both DVB-H and T-DMB services exist, this is not a problem and would only require the addition of yet another antenna. He questions whether or not this will be possible for MediaFLO however, because Qualcomm hasn’t opened the chip design up for scrutiny. Having said that, Samsung and LG Electronics are launching devices for both MediaFLO and DVB-H this week (we are unsure with which chips), so may combine them into a single handset for the US market, which will definitely have both services operating this year.
‘L-band antenna are really small, like a chip, while UHF antenna are bigger, like a small pencil embedded into the phone. It should be easy to switch between then, with a switching time of a few hundred milliseconds. It costs an extra 50 cents for a second antenna and we will be shipping our chips at a little above $10 at first, falling to $10 or below as volume ramps,’ said Ironi.
This $10 target is a bill of materials price that Texas Instruments has confirmed to us for its Hollywood chip, which straddles the Japanese ISDB-T standard and DVB-H, so the cost of adding any combination of DVB-H, T-DMB or ISDB-T to a handset should not expensive in material cost terms, nor in terms of handset real estate.
Siano expects phones built with multi protocol chips to roam across both services and across territories and to appear in volumes within laptops as well.
The bottleneck in mobile TV is not the technology, and it is no longer the battery, since they all use a bursting approach to radio delivery. Instead it is the availability of spectrum and working out which business models works best.
Cellular operators are unlikely to come to the fore in the creation of these networks, since they may back the wrong horse and there is no need for them to decide merely on one approach or to risk their own money in paying for the network.
It is already well known that Verizon in the US has signed a deal with Qualcomm for its MediaFLO technology to be rolled out towards the end of next year. That does NOT mean that it cannot also sign with Crown Castle to carry its DVB-H service as well or any other broadcaster that emerges later.
That’s like saying you have to build one TV set for CBS and another for Fox.
One approach is for Verizon to source two phones with different additional components for each network, and let users decide which TV services they want to sign up for. Another approach might be to choose a phone that can use both mobile TV networks from Qualcomm’s MediaFLO and those from Crown Castle’s DVB-H, and offer both on one phone.
It is a certainty that in Europe, where operators are experimenting with DVB-H and T-DMB, and in China, where the government is about to license two new mobile TV trials, one for DVB-H and one for T-DMB, that this strategy can be adopted by all the cellcos there, and very likely will be.
Rival NeoMagic also announced for the CES the immediate delivery of mobile TV capability, using its flagship product, MiMagic 6+. NeoMagic’s Mobile Digital Television solution is available now for the exclusively Japanese ISDB-T mobile broadcast protocol, with each of the other major broadcast protocols, DMB (including DAB), and DVB-H to come available in early 2006.
NeoMagic has specialized in chips to handle H.264 video and audio decoding at low power, and also offers the Microsoft Windows Media Video codec, known as VC 1.