Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

21 June 2018

Sinclair Broadcasting gains from supporting Trump

However history comes to judge President Trump’s unique brand of diplomacy it is clear already he is having a major impact on US media. He is well known to favor outlets sympathetic to him such as Fox News but his greatest supporter which enjoys a lower profile is Sinclair Broadcasting.

At least that was the case until the issue of its slavish support for the Trump doctrine came to the boil in April 2018 when some of its journalists revolted by leaking details of instructions they had been given. This came when Sinclair’s controversial $3.9 billion bid for Tribune Broadcasting which would give it access to an additional 43 TV stations, on top of the 193 it already had, was under review by the FCC (Federal Communications Commission).

The FCC had been accused of removing barriers to the takeover under leadership of Ajit Pai, a Republican who joined the commission in 2012 and Trump had promoted to chairman. Democrats and media freedom advocates contended this was a direct case of favors for propaganda. It was certainly true that some of Sinclair’s news broadcasts had sounded little different from those of state-controlled media outlets under dictatorships. This came to a head in April when a video made by the news and blogging website Deadspin showed Sinclair’s parroting an agreed script known as a “must run” inside the company, warning viewers of “one-sided news stories plaguing our country”. It went on in an echo of Trump’s complaints about the more liberal leaning press outlets like CNN, CBS and NBC, “Some members of the media use their platforms to push their own personal bias. This is extremely dangerous to our democracy.”

This same promotion ran 875 times on 83 stations over 12 days reaching over 17 million viewers and while no one could quarrel with the sentiment it was high hypocrisy from a broadcaster that is blatantly supportive not so much of the Republican Party in general but Trump in particular. It highlighted how in reality US media is as split for and against Trump as the whole nation, rather than being biased towards liberal values as Trump contends.

Sinclair Broadcast is publicly traded but firmly controlled by the family of Julian Sinclair Smith who founded it in 1971. Headquartered in Hunt Valley, Maryland, it is now the largest US TV station operator by total coverage as well as by stations owned, reaching 40% of the country’s households, many in the Republican heartlands of the south and Midwest. It has 8,400 staff and turnover of $2.737 billion in 2017, which was actually 0.1% down on the previous year.

In fact Sinclair has been under pressure from the rise of OTT and SVoD just like any other broadcaster and at this year’s NAB Show in April 2018 its chief TV development officer Steve Pruett said that he was looking to develop a virtual MVPD platform to counter OTT challenges to traditional over the air (OTA) broadcasting.

This would dovetail with the acquisition of Tribune, although given the furor following the revelations about Sinclair’s “must run” news lines parroting the Trump dogma, the FCC is under pressure now to be seen as even handed as it approaches the end of deliberations over whether to wave the deal through.

Naturally many democrats have been urging the FCC and Department of Justice to block the deal on competitions grounds, arguing that it would give Sinclair far greater reach than competitors extending to 72% of the nation’s households and block smaller independent media outlets. This argument has less merit in the OTT age than it did.

But one democrat Jessica Rosenworcel who is actually an FCC member argued recently that the agency should postpone its review of the proposed deal until a lawsuit against it over media deregulations that could affect the merger had been settled. That does make more sense.

In practice the FCC has just announced it will take new comments from the public on the bid until July 12th. This is because the FCC is reopening its review after Sinclair and Tribune said they would sell off some local stations to bring the deal in line with existing media ownership restrictions. Sinclair had hopes that it would not have to do this and be able to exploit Tribune’s reach into the New York, Los Angeles, Chicago and Washington, D.C areas where there is a much higher proportion of democrat voters.

This comes back to the propaganda for favors argument because under Pai’s chairmanship the FCC has eased restriction over ownerships which would have previously ruled out the Tribune acquisition by Sinclair. It now looks likely to go ahead with the concession of surrendering some of those prime stations in the big urban areas and further Sinclair’s ambition to take over from Fox News as the nation’s pre-eminent conservative media outlet.